Casey’s in Madison (Photos, Menu, Reviews & Ratings)


Address: 3603 Cross Hill Dr, Madison, WI 53718

Phone: (608) 240-9839

Price: $

Menu: View Online

Rating: 3.4


What Time Does Casey’s Open?

Saturday,: 6AM to 10PM

Sunday,: 6AM to 10PM

Monday,: 6AM to 10PM

Tuesday,: 6AM to 10PM

Wednesday,: 6AM to 10PM

Thursday,: 6AM to 10PM

Friday,: 6AM to 10PM

Casey’s Directions

More Donuts In Madison


Casey’s Reviews


The food service portion needs to get employees that care more about being timely. We ordered pizza for pickup, went to pick it up at the quoted time (about 30 minutes after ordering) and still had to wait an hour for the pizza. The employees in the back were basically in slow motion and it took them about 15 minutes to make each pizza ahead of ours. I wasn’t told until afterward the pizza was supposed to come with sauce we never got, and the brownies we had ordered weren’t available either.

Sam Bagwell

Extremely large fuel islands. Great for RV, trailer and boat fueling. Has all the good stuff needed for road trip or quick bite to eat.

Tia Ekern

Love this place!
Some of the best pizza around, surprisingly.
Many, many selections of food to go! If they don’t have it made, they will make it.
The employees are always friendly and helpful! I always come here when I’m around.
COVID-19 measures: I feel they have appropriate measures in place. Wish their made to order sandwiches we’re still available, but it is what it is.

Michael S.

I’ve ordered pizza from this location a few times and every pizza I’ve had was not thoroughly cooked. Last time I decided to order breadsticks and I didn’t even get marinara sauce. Very disappointing as I believe this store currently has no store manager. The area supervisor / district manager really needs to look into this store.

Shanna Van Beek

The two ladies working at 9:45/9:50pm on 4/23/22 were very rude. They were just sitting and video chatting the whole time I was in the store and then I got yelled at for using the bathroom. Very disappointed to be traveling through and experience that.

Sherrie Johnson

The gal working evening of 6/30/21 was SO sweet & friendly. So nice to be in a store while traveling that was so nice & clean too!

Alexandre Therrien

Extremely slow for pizza pickup and had to get a refund for a missing item and even then I didn’t get back the full amount of what was missing

Matt Wilson

Relatively fast pumps with no ads. Great experience.

Savana Flynn

I’ve heard such good things about Casey’s but unfortunately, I just don’t see it with this location. I work near by this location and almost every single time I go in they have no food and no one to help get food or ask if they can get you anything. Half the time they are never stocked on drinks, that includes cold and hot coffee. This is why Kwik Trip will always get my business even tho it’s further down the road. Kwik Trip, without question, always has food, unmatched service, and are always 100% stocked.

Brian G

This place often isn’t open at 630 AM and when it it is, it often doesn’t have any breakfast available. I lived and traveled in Iowa and Nebraska for many years and the quality of this one is far below par in just about every way compared to many I’ve been to.

Update: don’t believe their hours online, they routinely close hours early and open late. When they close they shut off the lights at the pumps, so you have to pump your gas in the dark. By far the worst Casey’s ever, I only continue to go because it’s on the way to work.

Update: closed at 8pm on a Saturday, what clown is running this place, don’t bother unless you have to, there’s a qwik trip nearby

More Reviews for Casey’s

More Donuts In Madison

Donuts Guides