Sweet Tooth Shop in Fayetteville (Photos, Menu, Reviews & Ratings)

Sweet Tooth Shop

Address: 4011 Sycamore Dairy Rd #102, Fayetteville, NC 28303

Phone: (910) 868-1366

Price: $$

Menu: View Online

Rating: 4.1

Website: http://www.sweettoothshop.net/

What Time Does Sweet Tooth Shop Open?

Saturday,: 10AM to 9PM

Sunday,: 12 to 8PM

Monday,: 10AM to 8:30PM

Tuesday,: 10AM to 8:30PM

Wednesday,: 10AM to 8:30PM

Thursday,: 10AM to 8:30PM

Friday,: 10AM to 9PM

Sweet Tooth Shop Directions

More Donuts In Fayetteville


Sweet Tooth Shop Reviews

Julynn Washington

Satisfying a sweet tooth. Wow, what an amazing experience. Nice clean facility, friendly and helpful staff, and delicious sweet treats. This was my first experience and it was worth the visit. I’ve been on a weightloss fitness lifestyle journey and it’s been over a year since I had ice cream. I wanted to try something different, so I decided on the Salty Carmel Truffle, and my oh my, I’m glad I did, so delicious. The triple chocolate chip cookie was awesome as well. It will be a considerable amount of time before my next visit (due to my current lifestyle journey) but I will return.

I imagine pricing is comparable, I thought it was reasonable, but I’m no expert.

If you haven’t tried it, I suggest you do, is worth checking out.

Jeanne Marie Hoffman

Sweet Tooth catered my wedding and other important events in my life. I got married in August, and people are still talking about the coconut bavarian cream wedding cake.

For the wedding cake, I sent over designs and the cake was identical to what I asked for.

For other events, I’ve ordered vegan and gluten-free cupcakes for guests who need them. Every time, they’ve arrived packaged separately and carefully to avoid contamination. My vegan friend loves the way their vegan cupcakes come out!

They also have keto friendly cheesecakes and cookies that are delicious.

I will add that they are popular so plan ahead if you’d like to use them for events. Cupcakes are easier to get closer to the event, but if you have your heart set on a cake design from them, you need to get on their calendar ASAP because they book up fast.

Izzy Street

Awesome! My mom had these delivered to our home for a birthday surprise! Super yummy. The icing was perfect level of sweetness, seriously! Every flavor was great! The wedding cake one was my favorite

Nicole Benford

My son turned 21 yesterday and we weren’t able to spend the day with him as we’d hoped. I called Jamie to discuss using door dash to send him some treats. She was very kind. She offered to let us email her a message that she could attach to the order. She ended up taking our email – laminating it and adding a 2 and a 1 candle for him! She really made the delivery much more special. And when I checked in with my son- he confirmed the desserts were delishish! Thank you Jamie!

Hayle adams

I have to say I’m disappointed with my order. I called ahead of time and ordered 4 red velvet cupcakes with CHOCOLATE icing instead of the cream cheese frosting. I completely understand this is out of the ordinary for red velvet cake, however, that’s why I called ahead for this order. When I picked up my order they clearly had scooped off the white icing and put the chocolate icing over it. As if I would not notice…

HA Homes

We read some reviews before giving Sweet Tooth a try. We can’t speak to anyone else’s reviews but we can share our opinions on the food and service. To start, the service from calling in to picking us was great. The staff all seemed willing and able to assist us.

The macaroon fillings are amazing. We had chocolate, lemon, strawberry and vanilla the macaroons themselves were also great. Even the dog treats smelled delicious. Our dog couldn’t eat them fast enough. Lastly, the strawberry cake we ordered was fresh, fragrant and moist. We will stop by if we’re back in town.

And for the 143, “if you know you know”.

L. Sparrow

As a first time customer at Sweet Tooth, I was overwhelmed by the variety of desserts offered. With the assistance of a worker, I decided to purchase the Snickerdoodle cookie and Strawberry Cupcake. Both of the items were delicious. I will be back.

NotSoNormal Lady

It’s been 3 days and I’m still upset about this, so I’m going to have to leave a review. I hate leaving something negative, but come on; this was wrong.

I ordered a dozen cupcakes, and requested they be made a specific way. My husband picked them up because I had other errands to do. When I got them they were not made correctly. I ordered these specifically as my twins favorite flavors for their birthday. We weren’t able to have a large party so I wanted to do something special.

I called the bakery to let them know of the mistake. I did not open the container at all, because I didn’t want to break the seal. The manager/owner basically told me he “technically made the cupcakes” and that he would not refund. When I asked for new cupcakes to be made the way I ordered he said he only makes so many orders a day and wouldn’t make them. When I placed my order he didn’t specify only having one flavor of icing for it. I feel like it was on purpose, especially considering his response.

It was such a let down. I make it a point to try and support small businesses, but when this is done it discourages people. Especially paying $44 for a dozen of cupcakes that are not big by any means. They were not fancy either.

I ordered vanilla cupcakes with chocolate and strawberry in rotating order. Instead he made strawberry and chocolate cupcakes with vanilla icing. So, “technically” he made the right flavors, but it wasn’t what I ordered

Cailey Barr

First time trying. Had the pecan bar, cream cheese brownie, and a sugar cookie. I enjoyed the pecan bar, just felt like salt overpowered a little. The chocolate in the brownie was very strong, but had a good consistency. I didn’t realize what I ordered wasn’t so much cheesecake but brownie. Next time I’ll just get the cheesecake slice. The sugar cookie is not soft like expected, but my daughter enjoyed it! Look forward to trying the cupcakes.

Judy Ann M.

This is our go to place when it comes to anything sweet (macarons, cupcakes & cheesecakes). Everything taste absolutely wonderful & recently we ordered a custom cake for our wedding anniversary and it was perfect! It’s affordable and very easy to get a quote/ order. Very friendly place. One of our favorite places.

More Reviews for Sweet Tooth Shop

More Donuts In Fayetteville

Donuts Guides