Jolly Pirate Donuts in Reynoldsburg (Photos, Menu, Reviews & Ratings)

Jolly Pirate Donuts

Address: 6689 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Phone: (614) 864-1085

Price: $

Menu: View Online

Rating: 4.6


What Time Does Jolly Pirate Donuts Open?

Saturday,: 4AM to 9PM

Sunday,: 4AM to 9PM

Monday,: Closed

Tuesday,: 4AM to 9PM

Wednesday,: 4AM to 9PM

Thursday,: 4AM to 9PM

Friday,: 4AM to 9PM

Jolly Pirate Donuts Directions

More Donuts In Reynoldsburg


Jolly Pirate Donuts Reviews

White & Gray Matters

Excellent in-house made doughnuts and cookies! I have been coming here for years, since I was a kid. I still love the freshness they bring to the table and my tastebuds. If you have time or are near reynoldsburg, please stop by and try!

Brian Dible

First time at any Jolly Pirate. The donuts were good. It just seems that all these donut places are very pricey. The donuts seemed especially small for the price. Worth trying at least once.

Bob Hosken

My wife and I have been a fan of Jolly Pirate Donuts for a long time. We visited this one when we happened to be in the area and passing by. Amazingly it was exactly as we remembered. The same flavors, and some new ones, in the same pirate chest box and the best part was the staff that gave a personal feel and service. We can only hope they will open one North of Columbus someday!

Tyler Johnson

We came in for the first time on a Sunday evening and we’re shocked that there was such a big selection still. Everything was so fresh, fluffy and delicious and the ladies behind the counter were friendly and wonderful.

Scott Fisher

I have grown up on JP donuts. The selection is excellent and love an actual donut taste… not the oil that you get at the “popular” chain. Stay strong JP.

Doug Goodyear

We got a dozen donuts…all were filled with different jellies and very good. Coffee is really good. Was so good went back 2 days later and all was the same…very

Pam Castle

My families favorite donuts for 50 years. My 5 kids were allowed 1
Donut before school every day. We went
to the Jolly Pirate every morning. We saw, Ester, Mr Massenelli every morning
as well as the older generations faithful.

Richard Johnson

The doughnuts were decent, and the staff was friendly. They did not have that wide variety. The doughnuts were a mixture of moist and dry. The bismark has virtually no filling.


Super selection of a variety of fresh made donuts, taste like they were made only moments ago. Service is quick and friendly. Order a dozen and they give a 13th for free – pick from even the big specialty donuts for the free one. See the pics!

Michael Sponsler

Hands down the Best donuts and coffee in Columbus! These are real donuts, not cotton candy like they sell at KK. I love the coffee counter . Buttermilk donuts are amazing. Even the plain old fashioned cakes donuts are delish. Go There!

More Reviews for Jolly Pirate Donuts

More Donuts In Reynoldsburg

Donuts Guides