Payne Street Bake House
Address: 225 S Spring St, Louisville, KY 40206
Phone: (502) 539-4202
Price: $
Menu: View Online
Rating: 4.6
Website: http://www.nancysbagels.com/
What Time Does Payne Street Bake House Open?
Sunday,: 7:30AM to 2PM
Monday,: 7AM to 2PM
Tuesday,: Closed
Wednesday,: 7AM to 2PM
Thursday,: 7AM to 2PM
Friday,: 7AM to 2PM
Saturday,: 7:30AM to 2PM
Payne Street Bake House Directions
Payne Street Bake House Reviews
Josh Saylor
I’ve been going here for breakfast at least once or twice a month the past couple years. This past visit I got two sausage biscuits which were great. They have amazing bagel sandwiches. The bacon egg and cheese bagel on an everything bagel is the bomb. Great coffee! Check this place out!
Ron Fisher
The absolute best bagels and cream cheese I’ve ever had. There’s a wide variety of bagels to choose from with what feels like an unlimited amount of options on what to put on said bagels.
My favorite things here are: everything bagel with herb cream cheese, spicy turkey and cheese on a pumpernickel bagel, egg bacon and cheese on a variety of bagels, pimento cheese and a fried egg on a variety of bagels, and the banana bar.
You can’t go wrong with this place! Nancy’s bagels used to be sold at Quills years ago and is the reason I love bagels. This place is the same as Nancy’s.
Megan Paz
I met a friend here for brunch and it was delicious! We did go on the weekend so it was slammed & I would recommend ensuring you have plenty of time to enjoy/wait, but we were in no rush. The spinach club wrap was delicious and their bagels are pretty top notch!
*Loved the outdoor sitting area!
Tracy Thomas
Hard to write this. Son & I have been loyal Nancy’s/Payne Street patrons for over 15 years. But its not what it used to be. Quality is still great, but the service is consistently awful. Takes so long to get food (whether your order ahead or not) and orders are consistently wrong. Forgetting the coffee part of order, out of plain bagels and just substitute for whole grain without telling us (twice!). Plenty of staff but it doesn’t show in efficiency at all. Its cramped now w/ little seating & the configuration is weird. I won’t go anymore. And that makes me really sad. Hope things change, but we will find a place (with bagels that aren’t as good…for sure) that is closer to home.
High Expectations
What a treat! This bakery, hands down has the best bagels in the city. The homemade veggie cream cheese, get a big schemer! Garlic Bagels are my favorite and this place has them!! I can’t wait to try something sweet!
AK McD
Tasty bagels with many options, I got an herb tomato bagel with veggies. This visit I was happy to see that they had a vegan cream cheese option. I also added an iced chai to my order with oat milk, delicious!
Wendy Jamison
The place has to come up with a better way to keep track of what bagels they have and dont have. When i ordered, they told me they were out of 4 flavors. I ordered garlic which they had. 25 minutes later after them telling customer after customer that they were now out if the flavor they ordered.. i got the same speach, and only had 3 options to choose from. Why even choose a flavor, if its going to be out when they start making your order. The inside is HOT. Like sweltering. No apologies. Just a ton of unorganized mess.
Bill Wayne
Despite a rough few years with spotty quality during covid. Payne St. Bake House has really rebounded. If you grew up with Nancy’s this place still hits the spot. If you’re new in town or just visiting, stop by for bagels, you really won’t regret it. My only remaining gripe is the curbside ordering system slows down the checkout experience and takes up valuable parking. I know it’s not easy with a small staff but it can make for an awkwardly long wait.
Prasad Nair
Delicious bagels. I had the Sesame Bagels with Honey Walnut Cream Cheese. The Soy Milk Mocha is a gem. Contactless service. The process to order and get the bagels is simple and you get the replied to your text quickly. Highly recommended and would definitely be back.
AJ Kavanaugh
Bagel sandwich was really good. I recommend the jalapeño cheddar bagel. For a cold brew and a breakfast sandwich it was on the pricier side.
More Reviews for Payne Street Bake House
