Is it better to store cooked lobster in the shell?

When it comes to storing leftover lobster after cooking, there are two main options – leaving the meat in the shell or removing it from the shell before refrigerating. Both methods have their benefits and drawbacks in terms of preserving flavor, texture and safety. Choosing whether to store lobster meat in or out of the shell depends on factors like how long you need to keep it, individual preferences, and how much work you want to do after cooking.

Table of Contents

Quick Answers

Is it okay to store cooked lobster in the shell?

Yes, it is completely safe and acceptable to store cooked lobster in the shell after cooking. The shell helps protect the delicate lobster meat from exposure to air, light and handling.

How long does cooked lobster last in the shell?

Properly stored cooked lobster in the shell will usually last 3-4 days in the fridge before the quality starts to decline. Make sure to cook, cool and refrigerate it quickly.

Does lobster taste better in the shell?

Many chefs and lobster aficionados insist that lobster tastes best when served in the shell. Keeping it in the shell helps lock in moisture and preserves the flavor better. The shell also provides insulation against fridge odors.

Is lobster easier to eat when shelled?

Shelled lobster meat is definitely easier to eat and requires less work at the table. Removing lobster from the shell makes it more convenient to incorporate into other dishes, salads and fillings.

Can you freeze cooked lobster in the shell?

Yes, it is fine to freeze cooked lobster in or out of the shell. Make sure it is tightly wrapped or in an airtight container to prevent freezer burn. Thaw in the fridge before using.

Pros of Storing in the Shell

Here are some of the main benefits of keeping cooked lobster in the shell:

Maintains moisture – The shell helps keep the lobster meat nice and moist, preventing it from drying out in the fridge.
Preserves flavor – Much of the taste of lobster comes from delicate enzymes in the flesh. Keeping intact helps lock in the authentic lobster flavor.
Extra protection – The hard, outer shell provides an added layer of protection from damage, air exposure and refrigerator odors.

Easier transport – Keeping lobster in the shell helps the meat hold its shape and makes it easier to transport dishes with lobster to parties or potlucks.
Insulation – The shell provides a bit of insulation that helps keep the meat colder than if it was shelled.
Tail meat stays firm – The tail meat in particular tends to get mushier and less appealing when removed from the shell.

Less work initially – Leaving it in the shell avoids the hassle of picking and cleaning all the meat after cooking.
Claws intact – The claws especially can be hard to break down, so storing them whole helps keep them usable.

Overall, the shell offers protection and locks in moisture and flavor that aid in preserving the lobster meat optimally. Many people prefer the taste and texture of meat cooked, stored and served in the shell.

Cons of Storing in the Shell

However, there are a few downsides to consider when keeping cooked lobster in the shell:

Difficult to use – It can be trickier and messier to remove lobster meat from the shell when you’re ready to eat it or use it in recipes.
Picking work later – While less work upfront, you’ll have to crack and pick the meat out of the shell when ready to serve.

Takes up more space – Shells are bulky and take up valuable real estate in the refrigerator.
Hard to weigh – If you need a specific amount of lobster meat for a recipe, it’s difficult to weigh and measure it accurately in the shell.
Can’t see condition – Once it’s refrigerated in the shell, you can’t get a good visual on the condition and freshness of the meat.

May trap bacteria – Juices can pool inside the shell and bacteria can be trapped rather than washed off shelled meat.
Difficult to portion – Portioning lobster tail or claw meat is trickier when left whole in the shell.
No claw reuse – Some recipes call for reusing cooked lobster shells. Saving shells is hard if initially stored in them.

The main inconvenience of keeping lobster in the shell is the extra work required at time of serving or using in recipes. You also lose visibility on the condition of the meat.

Pros of Removing the Shell

On the other hand, here are some benefits to removing lobster meat from the shells after cooking:

Easier to use – The meat is ready to eat or mix into any recipe. No picking required.

See condition – You can visually inspect the meat and confirm proper doneness when shelled.
Compact storage – Taking meat out of the shell reduces bulk and saves fridge space.
Accurate portions – Weighing and portioning meat is much simpler without shells.

Versatile – It’s easier to pair lobster meat with ingredients like pasta, sauce, and dressing when shelled.
Avoid bacteria – Removing meat eliminates potential bacteria build up inside shells.
Separate parts – Tail, claw, leg and body meat can be separated when shelled.

Fresher taste – Some people feel the taste is fresher and lighter when enjoyed outside the shell.
Less work for diners – No shell cracking and picking work for those being served pre-shelled lobster.

Taking the meat out makes for more practical storage. The lobster is also ready to use in a variety of dishes and recipes.

Cons of Removing the Shell

However, removing lobster from the shell does come with some downsides:

Drying out – The meat is more prone to drying out once exposed and separated from the shell.
Delicate – The delicate texture and shape of the meat can be disrupted and damaged without the shell.

Flavor loss – Subtle lobster flavors are more likely to dissipate without the protective shell.
Odor absorption – The meat can pick up smells from the refrigerator without the shell buffer.
Shorter shelf life – Shelled meat typically has a shorter shelf life compared to meat stored in the shell.

Freezer burn – Lobster meat is very prone to freezer burn when frozen without the shell.
Hard to transport – Once shelled, the meat is trickier to transport to parties or for serving without damage.
Extra work initially – Removing the lobster meat requires picking and cleaning work after cooking.

Not as impressive – Presenting an entire lobster can look more impressive than a bowl of shelled meat.

The main risk is loss of flavor, texture and appearance once the lobster meat is extracted from the shell. Proper storage techniques are needed to keep shelled meat in optimal condition.

How to Store Cooked Lobster

To get the most out of leftovers, here are some tips on storing cooked lobster:

In the Shell

Cool completely before refrigerating. Don’t store hot lobster in the shell.
Wrap in plastic wrap or store in airtight containers. This prevents drying out.
Use lobster within 3-4 days for best flavor, texture and safety.

Consider blanching briefly in an acidic liquid to kill bacteria prior to storing.
The shell provides some protection during freezing for up to 2-3 months.

Out of the Shell

Remove meat once lobster has cooled slightly but is still warm. It comes out easier.

Consider dipping meat in butter or olive oil to prevent drying out.
Wrap tightly in plastic wrap pressing out excess air or vacuum seal if possible.
Use lobster meat within 2-3 days before quality declines.

Freeze meat for up to 2 months by sealing tightly in an airtight container.

General Storage Tips

Store lobster in the coldest part of the refrigerator, ideally 32-34°F.
Avoid overcrowding lobster in the refrigerator. Air circulation is key.

Consume any leftover lobster within 3-4 days for optimum freshness and flavor.
Properly wrapped tails can freeze for up to 6 months.
Don’t re-freeze thawed lobster meat.

Following proper storage methods can help maximize the shelf life and quality of leftover cooked lobster, whether in or out of the shell.

Serving Previously Cooked Lobster

Cooked lobster stored in the refrigerator is easy to prep and incorporate into a variety of dishes:

Salads – Chopped, chilled lobster meat is delicious in salad recipes. Pair with fresh greens, veggies and citrus flavors.

Rolls – Stuff lobster salad or pieces of lobster meat into toasted rolls for easy lobster rolls.
Pasta – Toss chunks of lobster into pasta dishes and sauces for a luxury treat.
Soups and stews – Add bite-size pieces of lobster to chowders, bisques and seafood stews.

Omelets and frittatas – Finely chopped lobster is a delightful addition to omelets and egg dishes.
Pot pies – Mix lobster with sauce and vegetables in a homemade or store-bought pot pie.

For best results, gently reheat shelled lobster meat in a sauce or liquid when preparing a dish. This prevents the delicate meat from getting rubbery or chewy.

Buying Previously Cooked Lobster

In some cases, you may opt to purchase freshly cooked lobster rather than cooking it yourself:

Look for places that steam or boil lobster to order to assure freshness.
Make sure cooked lobster was properly chilled after cooking.

Pre-cooked lobster should be sold and served chilled, not hot.
Avoid places that cook lobsters far in advance and reheat them later.
The shell should look clean, not slimy or watery.

Meat should be shining and translucent, not dull or milky opaque.
Take cooked lobster straight home and refrigerate it immediately.
Eat within 1-2 days for highest quality and flavor.

When buying pre-cooked lobster, freshness and proper handling are key to ensuring you get the best quality product. Enjoy it as soon as possible once purchased.

Conclusion

Storing cooked lobster in or out of the shell both have their advantages and disadvantages. Leaving lobster meat in the shell better preserves moisture, flavor and texture. However, removing the meat allows easier handling, portioning and versatile use in recipes.

For short term storage of 2-3 days, keeping lobster in the shell is generally recommended. Over longer periods, properly wrapped lobster meat will have a slightly longer shelf life in the refrigerator. Shell or no shell, be sure to cool, store and consume leftover lobster as soon as possible for the highest quality results.

With proper chilling, sealing and refrigeration, you can safely enjoy leftover lobster for 3-4 days after cooking. This makes preparing quick lobster dishes, meals and snacks a breeze with delicious pre-cooked lobster on hand. Paying attention to storage conditions allows you to maximize the freshness, taste and usability of cooked lobster.