Does sugar free Torani taste good?

Sugar free Torani syrups have become increasingly popular as more people look to reduce their sugar intake. But an important question many people have is – does sugar free Torani actually taste good? Or does removing the sugar negatively impact the flavor? In this comprehensive article, we’ll explore whether sugar free Torani delivers on taste.

The Basics of Torani Syrup

First, let’s start with some background on Torani syrup. Torani is an Italian company that has been making syrups since 1925. Their syrups come in a wide variety of flavors, from classics like vanilla and hazelnut to more unique options like salted caramel and pomegranate. Torani syrups are popular choices to flavor coffee, tea, Italian sodas, and other beverages.

Up until recent years, all Torani syrups contained sugar. But with rising rates of obesity and diabetes, many people have looked to cut down on sugar. To meet this demand, Torani introduced a line of sugar free syrups sweetened with sucralose, an artificial sweetener.

Taste Testing Sugar Free Torani

To determine if sugar free Torani tastes as good as the original, we need to compare them side by side. Several sources have done blind taste tests of sugar free Torani syrups against standard Torani syrups.

One tasting by the blog Sugar Free Mom found that tasters generally preferred the taste of original Torani by a small margin. The sugar free versions were described as “good but a little less creamy” and “close but a tiny bit of difference.” So while sugar free Torani was comparable, it didn’t rate quite as high on flavor.

However, other taste testers have found the differences to be very subtle. Coffee blog Barista Basics did a blind test of a sugar free Torani vanilla latte against the original version. Most tasters could not reliably tell which was which based on taste alone.

A third source, the food blog Little Sweet Baker, noted some variability between flavors. Their panel found that richer, creamier flavors like caramel and hazelnut worked better sugar free compared to lighter flavors like peach or raspberry that depended more on sweetness.

Factors That Impact Sugar Free Torani’s Taste

Why might there be subtle differences in taste between sugar free Torani and regular Torani syrups? There are a few key factors at play.

Type of Sweetener

Sugar free Torani is sweetened with sucralose, a no-calorie artificial sweetener. It’s estimated to be about 600 times sweeter than sugar. Many people find sucralose has a “cooling” sensation on the tongue compared to the warmth of sugar. It also does not caramelize or have the same mouthfeel as real sugar. These traits can impact how flavors come through.

Amount of Sweetener

Torani’s sugar free syrups contain less total sweetener than their sugared counterparts. Granulated white sugar adds texture and bulk, while sucralose is used in a much smaller quantity. This lower overall sweetness can make some flavors less bold.

Masking Effect of Sugar

Sugar does more than just add sweetness. The richness of sugar rounds out flavors and can mask some bitterness or acidic notes. Without that balancing effect, some flavors may taste slightly sharper or thinner.

Tips for Getting the Best Flavor from Sugar Free Torani

While taste tests show sugar free Torani is highly comparable to regular Torani, you may be able to enhance the flavor of sugar free syrups with a few easy tweaks:

  • Use a lighter hand – Since sugar free Torani is sweeter, you may need less syrup than you’re used to.
  • Splash in milk or cream – Adding dairy provides creamy texture and helps mellow flavors.
  • Spike it with spices – A dash of cinnamon, nutmeg, or vanilla extract can add depth.
  • Sweeten to taste – Add a pinch of sugar if you want more sweetness.
  • Stick to richer flavors – Caramel, hazelnut, and vanilla work better than lighter fruit flavors.

The Bottom Line

When it comes to the question “does sugar free Torani taste good?”, the answer seems to be a qualified yes. While it may not be quite as creamy and robust as full-sugar Torani, many taste testers report small or negligible differences, especially in richer flavors. Sugar free Torani provides an option for those looking to cut back on sugar without sacrificing too much flavor. With a few minor adjustments like adding cream or spices, you can come extremely close to replicating the tasty Torani syrup you know and love.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does sugar free Torani syrup curdle milk?

No, sugar free Torani syrup should not curdle milk any more than regular Torani syrup does. Both versions contain emulsifiers that help the syrup blend smoothly into milk or cream without curdling. As long as you stir the syrup and dairy together thoroughly, you shouldn’t see any curdling.

What sweetener is used in sugar free Torani?

Sugar free Torani is sweetened with sucralose, an artificial sweetener sometimes sold under the brand name Splenda. Sucralose provides the sweet taste of sugar without any calories or carbohydrates.

Does sugar free Torani have aftertaste?

Most people do not notice a strong aftertaste from sugar free Torani. Sucralose is one of the more palatable artificial sweeteners available. However, everyone’s taste buds are different. Some sensitive palates may perceive a slight licorice or bitterness that lingers.

Can I mix sugar free and regular Torani?

Yes, you can mix flavors of sugar free and regular Torani syrups together. The combination will have less sugar than using only regular syrups but more sweetness than only sugar free. This allows you to customize the sweetness level to your liking.

Does sugar free Torani have carbs?

No, sugar free Torani syrups do not contain any carbohydrates, calories, or sugar. The sucralose sweetener provides the sweet flavor without these components. Be aware that if you add sugar free Torani to milk, the dairy will still contribute carbs from the natural lactose sugar.

Comparing Popular Sugar Free Torani Flavors

Not all sugar free Torani syrups are created equal when it comes to taste. Here is a comparison of some of the most popular flavors:

Flavor Taste Rating Notes
Caramel Excellent Rich, buttery, robust flavor
Vanilla Excellent Warm, creamy flavor
Hazelnut Very Good Nice nutty undertones
Cinnamon Very Good Spicy and aromatic
Almond Roca Very Good Sweet with strong almond notes
Raspberry Good Fairly natural fruit flavor
Coconut Good Hint of coconut essence
Peach Fair Flavor seems thin and artificial

As you can see, flavors that mimic creamy or nutty tastes tend to be most authentic tasting without sugar. Fruit flavors are more hit or miss. Overall, you have many great sugar free Torani options depending on your tastes.

Sugar Free Torani Syrup Recipes

Here are some delicious ways to use sugar free Torani syrups:

Sugar Free Iced Vanilla Latte


  • 1 cup strong brewed coffee, chilled
  • 1/4 cup milk of choice
  • 1-2 tbsp sugar free Torani vanilla syrup
  • Ice


  1. Brew coffee ahead of time and chill in the fridge until cold.
  2. Fill a tall glass with ice. Add chilled coffee, milk, and Torani vanilla syrup. Start with 1 tbsp syrup and add more to taste if desired.
  3. Stir gently to combine. Enjoy your iced latte!

Sugar Free Hazelnut Hot Chocolate


  • 1 cup milk of choice
  • 2-3 tbsp sugar free Torani hazelnut syrup
  • 1 tbsp cocoa powder
  • Pinch of cinnamon


  1. Heat milk gently in a small saucepan or microwave until hot but not boiling.
  2. Stir in Torani hazelnut syrup, cocoa powder and cinnamon.
  3. Heat through until steaming hot. Pour into mug and enjoy!

Sugar Free Caramel Frappe


  • 1 cup strong chilled coffee
  • 1/4 cup milk of choice
  • 2-3 scoops vanilla ice cream
  • 2 tbsp sugar free Torani caramel syrup
  • Whipped cream (optional)


  1. Brew coffee ahead of time and chill completely.
  2. Combine coffee, milk, ice cream and caramel syrup in blender. Blend until smooth and frothy.
  3. Pour into a glass and top with whipped cream if desired. Enjoy!

The possibilities are endless when you use your imagination. Sugar free Torani can make deliciously flavored yet lighter coffees, lattes, cocoa, lemonades, and more.

Where to Buy Sugar Free Torani Syrups

It’s easy to find sugar free Torani syrups at most major grocery chains and specialty food stores. Here are some of the best places to buy it:

  • Amazon – Wide selection of Torani syrup flavors available online
  • Walmart – Frequently stocks popular Torani varieties
  • Target – Carries sugar free Torani in the coffee section
  • World Market – Large Torani syrup selection, often on sale
  • Bed Bath and Beyond – Good for finding unique Torani flavors
  • Cost Plus World Market – Nice assortment of Torani products
  • – Discount prices on bulk Torani orders

You can also find Torani syrups at gourmet coffee shops, Italian markets, and restaurant supply stores. Be sure to call ahead to confirm availability of sugar free versions.

Bottom Line

When it comes to great taste with less sugar, Torani’s line of sugar free syrups delivers. While subtle flavor differences exist compared to original Torani, many taste testers find the sugar free versions highly enjoyable, especially in creamy, nutty, and spiced flavors. With a few tweaks like adding extra dairy or spices, you can craft sugar free beverages that rival their full sugar counterparts. Sugar free Torani provides a delicious way for people to cut back on sugar without sacrificing the flavors they love.

Leave a Comment