Is it OK to say John and I?

The use of “John and I” versus “John and me” is a common source of confusion in English grammar. Should you say “John and I are going to the store” or “John and me are going to the store”? Deciding when to use I or me can be tricky, but there are some simple rules to help you determine which form is correct.

In this article, we’ll provide a quick overview of when to use I versus me, summarize the key rules with examples, and go into more depth on the reasoning behind those rules. We’ll also look at some common situations where people often get tripped up on I vs. me. By the end, you’ll have the knowledge you need to confidently decide whether it’s OK to say “John and I” or if “John and me” is the right choice.

Quick Answers

– Use “John and I” when it is the subject of a sentence. For example: “John and I are going to the store.”

– Use “John and me” when it is the object of a sentence. For example: “The cashier smiled at John and me.”

– The easy way to decide is to remove John from the sentence. If you would say “I am going to the store,” then use “John and I.” If you would say “The cashier smiled at me,” use “John and me.”

– Don’t rely on what sounds right. Grammar rules determine whether to use I or me, not what may sound better.

Key Rules and Examples

Here are the two main rules for deciding when to use I vs. me:

1. Use I when it is the subject of a sentence.

For example:

– John and I are going to the park.
– The cake was made by John and I.

2. Use me when it is the object of a sentence.

For example:

– The teacher smiled at John and me.
– The prize was given to John and me.

To help decide whether a phrase is the subject or object, remove the other person’s name:

– I am going to the park. (I is subject)
– The cake was made by me. (me is object)

Some other examples:

– John and I walked the dog. (I walked the dog.)
– Please hand the book to John and me. (Hand the book to me.)
– The photo has John and me in it. (The photo has me in it.)

What’s the Reasoning Behind This?

The rules boil down to subject versus object. A subject performs an action, while an object receives an action. When using a pronoun like I or me, you have to identify its role in the sentence:

– Subject: Performs the action
– Object: Receives the action

“John and I” serves as the subject performing the action in a sentence, so it takes the subjective form I.

“John and me” serves as the object receiving the action, so it takes the objective form me.

Once you know the basic sentence roles, it’s easy to see why “John and I” is correct in some sentences but incorrect in others.

Common Scenarios for Confusion

Here are some specific situations that often trip people up when deciding whether to use I or me:

1. After Prepositions

Prepositions like at, with, to, from, above, and near are usually followed by objective pronouns like me. For example:

– The gift was for John and me.
– The photo was taken by John and me.
– The manager left a message for John and me.

2. After Verbs

Some verbs like gave, handed, showed, and offered are followed by objectives like me when there is an indirect object:

– My coworker gave John and me the reports.
– My friend showed John and me the pictures.
– The teacher handed John and me our tests.

However, when used in the passive voice, the objective changes to the subjective I:

– The reports were given to John and me by my coworker.
– The pictures were shown to John and me by my friend.

3. Compound Subjects and Objects

When John and I serve as a compound subject or object, consider if each noun would be subjective or objective on its own:

– John and I signed the contract. (I signed the contract.)
– The manager spoke to John and me. (The manager spoke to me.)

4. Comparisons

In comparisons using than or as, use the subject form I:

– John is taller than I (am tall).
– John sings as well as I (sing well).

5. After a Conjunction

When a conjunction like and, but, or or joins two subjects, use I:

– John and I were late.
– Either John or I will have to present.

When a conjunction joins an object and subject, the pronoun case doesn’t change:

– The trophy was awarded to John and me.
– The coach spoke to John but not I.

Tricks to Remember

Having trouble remembering when to use I and me? These simple tricks can help:

– Remove the other person to simplify the sentence. Would you say “I am going” or “Me am going”?

– Replace the pronoun with your own name. Would you say “John and Mark are going” or “John and Mark is going”?

– Don’t rely only on how it sounds. I and me can sound equally natural in a sentence, so formal grammar rules determine the correct usage.

– If you can replace the pronoun with we, use I (we = I + others). If you can replace it with us, use me (us = me + others).

– Remember the sentence roles – I is always a subject and me is always an object.

In Conclusion

The central rules for choosing I or me are:

– Use I when the pronoun is the sentence subject.

– Use me when the pronoun is the sentence object.

This applies in all usages of I vs. me, including:

– After prepositions (use me)
– After verbs (depends on active/passive voice)
– In comparisons (use I)
– After a conjunction joining two subjects (use I)

By identifying whether the pronoun is serving as the subject or object in a sentence, you can confidently determine whether to use I or me in any situation. Keep the sentence roles and examples above in mind, and you’ll have the knowledge you need to pick the right pronoun form and confidently say “John and I” or “John and me.”

Subject Pronouns Object Pronouns
I me
you you
he him
she her
it it
we us
they them

Leave a Comment