Do shallots have more calories than onions?

Onions and shallots are two common allium vegetables used for cooking. While they share some similarities, there are also key differences when it comes to their nutritional profiles. In particular, many home cooks wonder if shallots have more calories than regular onions.

In this article, we will compare the calorie and macronutrient contents of shallots and onions. We will look at the calorie counts in a typical serving size of each, and see how other nutrients like carbohydrates, protein, and fat stack up. Understanding the calorie and nutrition facts can help you make informed choices when cooking.

Calories in Onions

Let’s start by looking at the calorie count of onions. The calorie content can vary slightly depending on the specific type and size of onion.

Here are some common calorie counts for a 1/2 cup serving of raw, chopped onion (approximately 80 grams):

  • Yellow onion: 44 calories
  • White onion: 40 calories
  • Red onion: 28 calories

As you can see, calories range from 28 to 44 calories per serving. The milder white and yellow onions are slightly higher in calories than sharper red onions.

Macronutrients in Onions

What accounts for the calories in onions? Let’s look at the macronutrient breakdown:

Nutrient Amount (in 1/2 cup raw)
Carbohydrates 10.3 grams
Fiber 1.4 grams
Protein 1.1 grams
Fat 0.1 grams

Onions get most of their calories from carbohydrates. They also provide a small amount of fiber and protein. Fat accounts for very few calories.

Calories in Shallots

Now let’s look at the calorie profile of shallots. Shallots have a slightly milder, sweeter flavor compared to onions. The calorie count is also a bit different.

Here are the calories for a 1/2 cup serving (80 grams) of raw, chopped shallots:

  • 115 calories

As you can see, shallots contain significantly more calories per serving compared to onions. A 1/2 cup of shallots has over 2.5 times as many calories as onions.

Macronutrients in Shallots

What accounts for the increased calorie count in shallots? Here is the macronutrient breakdown:

Nutrient Amount (in 1/2 cup raw)
Carbohydrates 26 grams
Fiber 3 grams
Protein 3 grams
Fat 0 grams

Shallots contain over twice as many carbs and about 3 times as much protein as onions. They are also higher in fiber. Like onions, shallots get virtually no calories from fat.

Comparing Onion and Shallot Calories

To summarize the data:

Food Serving Size Calories
Onions 1/2 cup, chopped (80g) 28-44
Shallots 1/2 cup, chopped (80g) 115

As the table illustrates, shallots contain significantly more calories per typical serving compared to onions. Shallots have roughly 2-4 times as many calories, depending on the type of onion used for comparison.

Why Shallots Have More Calories

So why exactly do shallots have a higher calorie density? There are a few potential reasons:

  • Higher carbohydrate content – Shallots contain around 2-3 times more carbs than onions
  • More protein – Shallots also have slightly more protein
  • Higher fiber – Shallots contain extra fiber
  • Higher sugar content – Shallots tend to be sweeter due to fructans and fructooligosaccharides
  • Higher water content in some onions – Red and white onions can sometimes have higher water content, resulting in fewer calories per gram

The combination of extra carbs, protein, and fiber all contribute to the increased calorie count. The sweeter flavor of shallots is also a sign that they contain more energy-containing sugars than onions.

Nutritional Benefits

Despite their differences in calories and macronutrients, onions and shallots both provide beneficial nutrition.

Some of the health benefits associated with allium vegetables like onions and shallots include:

  • Antioxidants like quercetin that can help reduce inflammation
  • Organosulfur compounds that have antimicrobial effects
  • Prebiotics that support gut health
  • Potential anti-cancer effects for certain cancers
  • Possible benefits for heart health from their sulfur compounds and quercetin

So while shallots have more calories, their extra nutrients and compounds may provide some additional health bonuses as well. Moderating portion sizes can allow you to gain benefits without overdoing the calorie intake.

Cooking Tips

Here are some quick tips for cooking with onions versus shallots:

  • Use onions when you want a stronger, sharper flavor – they contain more of the sulfury compounds that give alliums their bite.
  • Choose shallots for a more delicate, sweet flavor.
  • Add extra onions for volume – their higher water content means you can use more onions for the same number of calories as shallots.
  • Sautee shallots in butter or oil to bring out their sweetness.
  • Roast or grill onions and shallots to concentrate their flavor and sweetness.
  • Maximize nutrition by consuming onions and shallots raw in dishes like salads, salsas, and onion dip.

With some simple substitutions and cooking methods, you can adjust recipes to use shallots or onions based on your taste preferences and nutrition goals.

Should You Choose Onions or Shallots?

So which allium should you choose? Here are some factors to consider when deciding between onions and shallots:

  • Flavor – Choose shallots when you want sweeter, more delicate flavor or onions for more bite.
  • Texture – Shallots tend to hold their shape better when cooked vs. onions.
  • Cooking method – Raw, roasted, sauteed, grilled etc. all impact flavor.
  • Dietary needs – Choose shallots for more fiber and nutrients or onions to save calories.
  • Recipe specifications – Some recipes may specify onions or shallots for intended flavor.
  • Cost – Shallots typically cost a bit more per pound than onions.
  • Availability – Onions are more common than shallots in most grocery stores.

As you can see, there are many factors that can guide your choice beyond just calories. Consider your taste, texture, budget, and nutritional priorities when picking between onions and shallots.

The Bottom Line

To summarize the key differences:

  • Shallots have significantly more calories per serving compared to onions – around 115 calories in 1/2 cup of shallots versus 28-44 calories for onions.
  • The extra calories in shallots come mostly from carbs, fiber, and protein. Shallots are lower in water content.
  • Both shallots and onions provide beneficial nutrients and health-promoting compounds.
  • Choose onions for lower calories and sharper bite or shallots for sweeter, more delicate flavor.
  • Consider cooking methods, cost, recipe requirements and other factors besides just calories to guide your choices.

While shallots have more calories per serving, both shallots and onions can have a place in a healthy diet when used in appropriate portion sizes. Understanding their differences allows you to make informed choices and substitutions when cooking.

Leave a Comment