Is it safe to eat salamanders?

Eating salamanders is generally not recommended. Salamanders can carry salmonella and other pathogens that can make humans sick. Additionally, some salamanders contain toxins in their skin and organs that can be poisonous if consumed. However, there are a few instances where salamanders may be eaten, such as in survival situations or by certain cultures as part of their cuisine. Proper cooking and preparation is necessary to reduce the risk of illness.

Are salamanders poisonous?

Many salamanders have toxins in their skin and organs, part of their natural defense mechanisms. The toxins are meant to deter predators from eating them. Some of the toxins found in salamanders include:

  • Tetrodotoxin – Found in newts, this neurotoxin can cause paralysis, respiratory failure, and death in high doses.
  • Samandarin – A toxic steroid found in some salamanders that can cause heart problems.
  • Alkaloids – Toxic nitrogen-based compounds found in the skin of some salamanders.

So yes, many salamanders contain toxins that are poisonous to humans and other animals if consumed. The toxins are present as a defense mechanism and can make a salamander deadly if eaten.

Risk of bacterial infections from salamanders

Salamanders can carry bacteria like salmonella and E. coli that can cause foodborne illnesses in humans. Some reasons salamanders pose an infection risk:

  • Live in damp environments where bacteria thrive.
  • Eat things like insects and worms that may transmit bacteria.
  • Toxins compromise immune system, letting bacteria proliferate.
  • Rough skin and moist bodies are good surfaces for bacteria.

One study found that more than 50% of wild-caught salamanders had salmonella bacteria. Proper cooking kills the bacteria, but eating undercooked salamander puts you at risk of bacterial infections.

What cultures eat salamanders?

Most cultures do not traditionally eat salamanders, but there are a few that have incorporated them into cuisine:

  • China – Some parts of China eat firebelly newts in soup dishes.
  • Indonesia – Javanese people eat salamanders in stews.
  • Mexico – A few Mexican restaurants serve a salamander dish called axolotl.
  • Slovenia – Lake salamanders are eaten fried in Slovenia.

These cultures have experience preparing salamanders to reduce poison and infection risks. However, improper preparation can still make salamanders dangerous to eat.

Is it safe to eat pet store salamanders?

Eating pet store salamanders carries higher risks than wild ones:

  • Often less natural immunity to bacteria.
  • Stress weakens toxins that fight bacteria.
  • Captivity increases parasites and diseases.
  • Fed unfamiliar diets unlike wild ones.
  • Less toxin development since not predator threatened.

Overall it is not recommended to eat pet store salamanders. The controlled captivity environment leads to higher susceptibility to illness and infections. Wild salamanders are better adapted with natural defenses.

Proper preparation methods to reduce risks

If consuming salamander, proper preparation can reduce poison and disease risks:

  • Remove skin, organs, and head where toxins concentrate.
  • Cook thoroughly to kill bacteria – boil, grill, or fry.
  • Avoid cross-contaminating other foods.
  • Wash hands and sterilize utensils after preparation.
  • Only eat young, healthy specimens.

Following traditional preparation methods of cultures with a history of eating salamanders can also help avoid illness. Strict safety measures are essential.

Survival situations where salamanders may need to be eaten

In dire survival situations with no other food sources, eating salamanders may be necessary despite the risks:

  • Lost in wilderness for many days without rations.
  • Natural disaster separates you from supplies.
  • War or collapse leads to severe food scarcity.
  • Nuclear fallout ruins existing food sources.
  • Stranded on island with no edible plants or animals besides salamanders.

In these scenarios, salamanders may be the only possibility even though they should be avoided when other options exist.

Can you eat salamander eggs?

Salamander eggs should not be consumed. Reasons include:

  • Contain the same tetrodotoxin toxins as adults.
  • Small size means eaten in larger quantities, increasing toxin exposure.
  • Often carry salmonella just like adult salamanders.
  • Eggs from terrestrial species may contain more toxins than aquatic ones.
  • Unappetizing taste and texture.

Overall, salamander eggs do not reduce the risks of eating salamanders and also provide very little nutritional value. They should be avoided.

Nutritional value of salamanders

Salamanders are not a good food source nutritionally:

  • Very high protein, but less than other meat sources.
  • Minimal amounts of vitamins and minerals.
  • High saturated fat compared to protein provided.
  • Rough skin low in digestible calories.
  • Small size means large quantities must be eaten.

The risks outweigh the minimal nutritional gains. Other more standard protein sources are recommended over salamanders.

Cases of illness from eating salamanders

There are documented cases of people becoming ill after eating salamanders:

  • 1980s – 300 people in China sick after eating poisonous firebelly newts.
  • 2013 – 11 people in Slovenia hospitalized after consuming raw salamanders.
  • 2015 – Wedding party in Costa Rica sickened after appetizers of axolotl salamander.
  • 2017 – Man in Philippines dies from salamander poisoning.

This demonstrates why proper preparation and cooking is essential, and that even experienced chefs can make mistakes with toxic salamanders.

Legal restrictions around harvesting wild salamanders

In some areas, it is illegal to harvest wild salamanders for consumption:

  • U.S. and Canada prohibit commercial salamander harvest under wildlife protection laws.
  • European Union bans collection of wild salamanders as they are an endangered species.
  • Violators can face fines up to $25,000 and 6 months imprisonment in the U.S.
  • Always check regional laws before capturing wild salamanders.

The restrictions are in place to prevent over-harvesting and extinction of rare salamander species. Be aware of the laws in any area before attempting to catch salamanders.

Can you eat a hellbender salamander?

Giant hellbender salamanders should never be eaten:

  • Classified as near threatened or endangered in parts of the U.S.
  • Long lifespan with high toxin concentrations.
  • More bacteria and parasites due to bottom-dwelling in rivers.
  • Strict regulations against harvesting them.
  • Provide important ecosystem services like pest control.

Eating threatened or slow-breeding salamanders can damage populations and have legal consequences. All giant salamanders should be avoided as food.


In most situations, eating salamanders and newts should be avoided. The toxins and bacteria risks outweigh any potential nutritional gains, especially with safer protein options available. Salamanders may only be considered in desperate survival scenarios with no alternatives. If consuming, proper cooking and preparation is absolutely vital to reduce the chances of poisoning or infectious illness. Be also aware of legal restrictions in many regions. Overall, salamanders are best appreciated in their natural habitats and ecosystems, not as a food source.

Leave a Comment