How many calories are in a New York bakery bagel?

Quick Answer

The number of calories in a New York bakery bagel can vary depending on the specific bakery and type of bagel. On average, a plain New York bagel contains around 250-350 calories. An everything or sesame seed bagel may contain 300-400 calories. Smaller mini bagels tend to be around 100 calories.

Calculating Bagel Calories

To determine the calories in a bakery bagel, you need to consider the size and any toppings or fillings added. Here are some general estimates:

Plain Bagels

– A standard plain bagel is around 3.5-4 inches wide and weighs 2.5-3 ounces. It contains:

  • 250-300 calories
  • 50-55g carbohydrates
  • 2-5g fat
  • 10-15g protein

Whole Wheat or Multigrain Bagels

– Whole wheat or multigrain bagels have a similar calorie count to plain bagels. They contain around:

  • 240-320 calories
  • 50-60g carbohydrates
  • 2-5g fat
  • 10-15g protein

The extra fiber makes them slightly more dense and higher in calories.

Sesame or Everything Bagels

– An everything or sesame seed bagel contains:

  • 300-400 calories
  • 55-65g carbs
  • 5-10g fat
  • 10-15g protein

The seeds add more fat and calories compared to a plain bagel.

Sweet Bagels

– Sweet bagels like cinnamon raisin or blueberry tend to be higher in calories. They have:

  • 320-400 calories
  • 60-70g carbs
  • 5-10g fat
  • 8-12g protein

The sugar coating and fruit add more carbs.

Mini Bagels

– A mini bagel is around 2 inches wide and weighs 1-1.5 ounces. It contains approximately:

  • 100-140 calories
  • 22-28g carbs
  • 1-2g fat
  • 5-7g protein

The small size means fewer calories.

Factors That Affect Bagel Calories

The exact number of calories in a bakery bagel can vary depending on:


– Larger bagels contain more calories and carbs. A jumbo 5-inch bagel may have 500+ calories.

Density and Thickness

– Denser, chewier bagels tend to be higher in calories than lighter types. Thickness impacts calories too.


– Whole grain, sweet, or seed-coated bagels add more fat and carbs. Plain bagels tend to be lower in calories.

Cooking Method

– A boiled then baked bagel is lower in fat and calories than one just baked. The boiling process gives a chewier interior.

Toppings and Fillings

– Additions like cream cheese, butter, jam, or bacon significantly increase the calories and fat.


– A fresh, soft bagel is able to absorb more oil during cooking, making it higher in fat and calories than a day-old bagel.

Serving Size

– Consuming multiple bagels or halves versus just one whole bagel impacts the calorie intake.

Comparing Bagel Calories by Top NY Bakeries

Here is the calorie count for a plain bagel from some top bakeries in New York City:

Bakery Bagel Calories
Ess-a-Bagel 260
Absolute Bagels 310
Brooklyn Bagel & Bread Co. 300
Bagel Bob’s 275
Tal Bagels 250
Best Bagel & Coffee 280
Murray’s Bagels 300
H&H Midtown Bagels East 260

As you can see, calories range from 250-310 per plain bagel depending on the bakery. Size, density, cooking method and ingredients account for the differences.

How Bagel Calories Fit into a 2000 Calorie Diet

Most nutritionists recommend consuming around 2000 calories per day for weight management and good health. Here is how bagel calories fit into a standard 2000 calorie diet:

– One 250-350 calorie bagel represents 12-18% of the total daily 2000 calorie intake.
– Limiting bagel intake to 3-4 times per week allows room for other carbohydrate sources and meets general nutrition guidelines.
– Splitting a bagel with a partner or consuming just half reduces the calorie contribution.
– Pairing bagels with protein sources like eggs or nut butter helps provide more balanced nutrition.
– Choosing mini 100 calorie bagels more often can help decrease overall calories.

Consuming too many bagels in a day or week can make it tricky to stay within the recommended daily 2000 calorie budget. But enjoying bagels in moderation can absolutely fit into a healthy diet.

High Calorie Bagel Combinations to Avoid

While a plain bakery bagel contains 250-350 calories, the calorie count shoots up when you add in spreads, toppings or fillings. Here are some high calorie bagel combinations to avoid:

Bagel with Cream Cheese

– A smoked salmon bagel with 2 ounces of regular cream cheese adds around 400 calories.

Buttered Bagel

– An everything bagel with 1 tablespoon of butter has about 450 calories.

Bagel Sandwiches

– A sausage, egg and cheese on an asiago bagel can hit 850+ calories.

Sweet Bagels

– Cinnamon raisin bagel with honey peanut cream cheese has over 600 calories.

Large Portion Sizes

– Eating 2 jumbo bagels in one sitting could total 1000+ calories.

Daily Bagel Habit

– Getting a 350 calorie bagel every morning adds an extra 2450 calories over a week.

To keep bagel calories reasonable, stick to a standard size with light toppings. Flavor combinations like herb cream cheese or nut butter with banana are lower calorie options.

Tips for Making Bagels Healthier

While bagels are fairly high in carbs and calories, there are ways to enjoy them in a more balanced way:

Choose Whole Grain

– Whole wheat or multigrain bagels provide extra fiber and nutrients.

Portion Control

– Opt for a small, mini, or thin bagel or just eat half to reduce calories.

Lighter Toppings

– Use hummus, avocado, tomato, onion or nut butter instead of cream cheese or butter.

Add Protein

– Pair your bagel with eggs, lean ham, smoked salmon or turkey for staying power.

Bake Instead of Boil

– Baking uses less oil than boiling, reducing fat and calories slightly.

Avoid Sugary Add-Ons

– Skip the honey, jam, chocolate chips or sugary cream cheese spreads.

With a few adjustments, it’s definitely possible to enjoy bagels as part of a healthy diet, even in a carb and calorie conscious city like New York! Moderation and making smart topping choices are key.

Nutrition Information for Popular Bagel Chains

Here is the nutrition info for some of the largest bagel chains in the US:

Bruegger’s Bagels

– Plain bagel (3.5 oz): 270 calories, 54g carbs, 1g fat, 11g protein

Einstein Bros Bagels

– Original bagel (3 oz): 260 calories, 54g carbs, 1g fat, 10g protein

Panera Bread

– Plain bagel (3 oz): 250 calories, 52g carbs, 1g fat, 10g protein

Noah’s New York Bagels

– Plain bagel (3 oz): 230 calories, 46g carbs, 1.5g fat, 11g protein

As you can see, even among the major chains, bagel calories vary from 230 to 270 for a comparable plain, original or regular bagel. Customizing with add-ons will further impact the nutrition counts.

Low Calorie Bagel Alternatives

If you love bagels but want to lighten up the calorie count, here are some low calorie alternatives:

Bagel Thins or Mini Bagels

– At around 100 calories, these provide the bagel taste with less than half the calories.

Egg Bagel Rounds

– These bagel-shaped egg muffins are a protein-packed breakfast swap.

Cauliflower Bagels

– With just 60 calories, these veggie bagels are a guilt-free option.

Lettuce Wraps

– Replace the bagel with lettuce leaves for a low carb, low cal wrap.

Rice Cakes

– Topped similarly to a bagel, 60-calorie rice cakes offer crunch without the dense calories.

Ezekiel Bread

– This protein-rich, sprouted whole grain bread has just 80 calories per slice.

With a little creativity, you can definitely still get your bagel fix in a lighter way. Just adjust portion sizes, swap in lower calorie bases or picks nutrient-dense toppings.

Health Impact of Too Many Bagel Calories

While the occasional bakery bagel is perfectly fine, regularly consuming too many bagel calories can negatively impact your health:

Weight Gain

– At around 250-400 calories each, too many bagels can lead to excess calorie intake and unwanted weight gain over time.

Blood Sugar Spikes

– With 50-60g carbs per bagel, overdoing intake can spike blood sugar and insulin levels.

Nutritional Imbalances

– Heavily relying on bagels for calories can bump out more nutrient-dense foods from your diet.

Increased Cholesterol

– Eating bagels topped with fatty ingredients like cream cheese or butter regularly may raise cholesterol levels.

Gut Health Issues

– The combination of excess refined carbs and minimal fiber in bagels can contribute to digestive issues.

Energy Crashes

– You may feel tired, irritable or hungry soon after eating due to blood sugar fluctuations.

Everything in moderation is the best approach when it comes to bagel nutrition and health. Be mindful of portions, frequency and toppings to keep your diet balanced.


A New York bakery bagel can range from 250-400 calories depending on size, flavor and additions. While bagels are high in carbs and calories, enjoying them occasionally within a healthy diet is perfectly reasonable. Splitting or opting for a mini bagel, picking light toppings and pairing with protein are ways to balance out a bagel’s nutritional impact. Limit portions to 3-4 times per week and avoid heavily topped or supersized bagels to keep calories under control. With some adjustments, you can definitely still get your bagel fix even if watching your waistline!

Leave a Comment