Does implant replacement hurt?

If you have an implant such as a hip or knee replacement that needs to be replaced, you may be wondering whether the surgery will be painful. Many factors contribute to the level of pain and discomfort experienced by patients undergoing implant replacement surgery.

What is implant replacement surgery?

Implant replacement surgery, also known as revision surgery, is a procedure to remove and replace a damaged or worn out implant. Some common reasons implants may need to be replaced include:

  • The implant has loosened or become unstable
  • There is excessive wear of the implant surfaces
  • The implant has broken or cracked
  • There is an infection in the implant area
  • The implant has migrated or moved from its original position
  • There is persistent pain or discomfort from the implant

Some types of implants that may need replacement include hip, knee, shoulder, elbow, finger joint, spinal fusion devices, breast implants, cardiac pacemakers, and more. The procedure to replace an implant is similar to the original implantation surgery.

Will it be painful?

Implant replacement surgery, like any major surgery, will involve some degree of pain and discomfort. However, there are ways for the surgical team to manage pain and make you as comfortable as possible.

Pain during surgery

You will be under general anesthesia for the procedure, so you will not be awake or feel pain during the surgery itself. You will have an IV and be fully asleep and unconscious while the surgeon removes the old implant and replaces it with the new one.

Pain immediately after surgery

When you first wake up from anesthesia, you may experience some pain or discomfort. Your surgeon can prescribe strong pain medications to help manage this initial post-operative pain. Patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) pumps allow you to self-administer pain medication as needed by pressing a button. Many patients report the worst pain being within the first 24 hours after implant replacement surgery.

Intermediate pain

Over the next several days after your operation, your pain should gradually reduce. Your doctor can prescribe oral pain medications to help control any lingering discomfort. Alternating cold therapy with short periods of gentle movement can also help reduce swelling, stiffness, and achiness in the implant area during the first week of recovery.

Long-term pain outlook

After the first week, your pain should be minimal with over-the-counter analgesics or non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Any lingering stiffness or soreness around the implant normally fades over the 6-12 weeks of recovery. Physical therapy also helps strengthen the muscles around the implant and restore mobility.

Most patients report a significant reduction in chronic joint or implant pain after successful replacement. However, some patients may continue to feel residual discomfort if there is scarring, muscle damage, or other complications. Nerve damage during surgery can also lead to lasting neuropathic pain.

Factors affecting level of pain

Every patient’s level of pain with implant replacement surgery is unique. Here are some factors that can influence how much pain you experience:

Extent of surgery

More complex revision surgeries that involve bone grafts, tissue reconstruction, or removal of damaged cement or tissue tend to be more painful. Simple implant exchanges may involve less pain.

Surgical approach

Minimally invasive keyhole surgery typically results in less pain, scarring, and recovery time than open procedures. But not all implant replacements can be performed minimally invasively.

Type of anesthesia

Beyond general anesthesia during surgery, regional nerve blocks and local anesthetics can provide targeted numbness and pain relief during and after surgery.


Prescription medications like opioids, NSAIDs, and acetaminophen are commonly used for post-surgical pain management. Alternative medications like gabapentin may also be helpful.

Cold therapy

Applying ice packs or cold compresses helps reduce swelling, inflammation, and pain after implant replacement procedures.

Nerve damage

If nerves are damaged or cut during the original implant surgery or replacement, it can result in chronic neuropathic pain that is often difficult to treat.


Factors like anxiety, depression, and general stress levels can influence how much discomfort someone experiences after surgery.

Pain tolerance

Everyone has a different pain tolerance which affects their perception of pain. Those with a low pain tolerance may suffer more.

Activity level

The more active you are during recovery, the more you can exacerbate inflammation and pain around the implant. Staying off your feet can make you more comfortable.

Implant position

If the new implant is not optimally aligned or positioned, it can cause greater discomfort due to improper mechanics and force distribution within the joint.


Post-surgical complications like infections, blood clots, fracture, prosthesis failure, and poor wound healing can all contribute to increased pain.

Pre-existing conditions

Having conditions like obesity, diabetes, or arthritis can make you more prone to discomfort and surgical pain.


Smoking causes vasoconstriction and poor tissue healing that are linked to greater post-op pain for implant patients.


The level of pain following implant replacement surgery varies significantly between patients. While the procedure and recovery do involve discomfort, your surgeon will take steps to control pain safely and effectively. Being proactive with your pain management regimen, limiting activity, and keeping expectations realistic can result in the best outcome.

Factor Impact on Pain
Extent of surgery More complex surgeries increase pain
Surgical approach Minimally invasive surgery reduces pain
Type of anesthesia Regional anesthesia reduce pain
Medications Prescription medications help control pain
Cold therapy Ice therapy decreases pain and swelling
Nerve damage Can result in chronic neuropathic pain
Psychology Anxiety and stress increase pain perception
Pain tolerance Lower tolerance leads to more perceived pain
Activity level More activity exacerbates pain
Implant position Poor alignment causes more pain
Complications Infections, blood clots, etc. increase pain
Pre-existing conditions Obesity, diabetes, arthritis increase pain
Smoking Smoking impairs healing and increases pain

Tips to reduce implant replacement pain

If you are facing implant replacement surgery, there are some steps you can take to potentially reduce your discomfort during recovery:

  • Discuss anesthesia options like nerve blocks with your surgeon
  • Stay on top of your medication schedule, especially in the first few days
  • Use ice packs or cold compresses to control swelling around the joint
  • Keep activity light and limit weight bearing on the implant at first
  • Work with a physical therapist to gradually regain strength and mobility
  • Treat any pre-existing illnesses that could impair healing
  • Adopt relaxation techniques to reduce stress and anxiety
  • Join a support group to connect with other implant patients
  • Communicate regularly with your surgeon about your level of pain
  • Consider non-pharmacological therapies like acupuncture or massage
  • Maintain a positive attitude and outlook on your recovery

While implant replacement procedures are a major undertaking, patients typically experience significant pain relief once healed. Being proactive and utilizing all pain management options can help you get through the immediate post-operative period as comfortably as possible.

Leave a Comment