Does Betty Crocker make a sugar free cookie mix?

Betty Crocker is one of the most popular and well-known brands when it comes to baking mixes and ready-to-eat products. With a wide variety of cake, brownie, muffin, and cookie mixes available, Betty Crocker aims to make home baking easy and accessible. However, with increasing awareness around reducing sugar intake, many consumers wonder if Betty Crocker offers any sugar-free options for those limiting their sugar consumption or managing diabetes. In this article, we’ll take an in-depth look at Betty Crocker’s product lineup to answer the question: does Betty Crocker make a sugar free cookie mix?

About Betty Crocker

Before diving into whether or not they offer a sugar free cookie mix, let’s first take a quick look at the history and background of the Betty Crocker brand. Betty Crocker was created in 1921 as a fictional spokesperson for the Washburn-Crosby Company (which later became General Mills). The character of Betty Crocker was invented to give a personalized response to consumer questions about baking – her signature and handwritten responses aimed to provide a more personal touch. Over the decades, Betty Crocker evolved into one of the most recognizable brands and authorities on baking and cooking in America. Today, the Betty Crocker line includes over 2,000 products including baking and cookware items, recipes, and custom content over a variety of media formats. While Betty Crocker herself is fictional, the brand promises to deliver reliable, accessible products and information when it comes to all things cooking and baking.

Standard Betty Crocker Cookie Mixes

Betty Crocker currently offers a wide range of cookie mixes as part of their extensive product line. Some of the most popular Betty Crocker cookie mixes available include:

  • Sugar Cookie Mix
  • Peanut Butter Cookie Mix
  • Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Mix
  • Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix
  • Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookie Mix
  • Gingerbread Cookie Mix
  • Monster Cookie Mix
  • Double Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix

The majority of traditional Betty Crocker cookie mixes contain added sugars in the form of sucrose, brown sugar, or corn syrup. The specific amount can vary by flavor, but most standard mixes contain between 9-12g of added sugars per 16g serving of dough.

For example, Betty Crocker’s popular Double Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix contains both sugarcane and brown sugar totaling 10g per 16g dough serving.

So for consumers monitoring their sugar intake, Betty Crocker’s traditional mixes likely contain more added sugar than ideal based on current recommendations by health organizations.

Sugar Free Baking Options

Reducing sugar intake has become an important health strategy for many consumers – from those managing diabetes to individuals simply aiming to cut back on refined sugars.

The American Heart Association recommends limiting added sugar intake to no more than 6 teaspoons per day for women and 9 teaspoons per day for men. For optimal health, the World Health Organization suggests reducing added sugars to less than 5% of total daily caloric intake.

For baking purposes, there are a few options to reduce the added sugars in cookie recipes:

  • Substitute granulated sugar with lower-calorie sweeteners like erythritol or stevia
  • Use sugar-free syrups like maple or vanilla
  • Replace some sugar content with pureed fruit like applesauce or bananas
  • Incorporate cocoa powder or extracts for flavor over added sugars

Making these adjustments can reduce the total sugar content by 25-50% while still maintaining taste.

Does Betty Crocker Offer Sugar Free Cookie Mixes?

So does Betty Crocker offer any cookie mixes specifically made to be low in sugar or sugar free?

Unfortunately, at this time Betty Crocker does not offer any cookie mixes advertised as “sugar free” or significantly reduced in sugars. The majority of their traditional mixes rely on regular granulated sugar, brown sugar, honey, or corn syrup as the main sweetening agents.

However, Betty Crocker *does* offer a few mixes that can be used as *bases* for lower sugar cookies with some simple ingredient adjustments:

Gluten Free Sugar Cookie Mix

While not sugar free, Betty Crocker’s Gluten Free Sugar Cookie Mix only contains 5g of sugar per serving compared to 9-12g in their traditional mixes. By swapping half the required butter for unsweetened applesauce and using a lower-calorie sweetener like erythritol, this mix could be modified into a reduced sugar cookie dough.

Dairy Free Cookie Mix

Betty Crocker’s Dairy Free Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix is dairy free as the name suggests, but still includes 7g of sugarcane per serving. Again, substituting half the butter for unsweetened applesauce and experimenting with sugar replacers could transform this into a reduced sugar option.

So in summary – while Betty Crocker currently does not offer a specific “sugar free cookie mix”, some of their specialty mixes like gluten free or dairy free could potentially be adapted into lower sugar alternatives with a little creativity!

Sugar Free Mix Options from Other Brands

Though Betty Crocker does not offer their own complete sugar free cookie mix, there are a few options available from other mainstream brands:

Pillsbury Sugar Free Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix

Pillsbury’s mix comes with a sugar free chocolate chip packet to mix in after baking. The cookies themselves contain zero grams of sugar per serving. This brand is likely the closest competitor to Betty Crocker when it comes to sugar free cookie mixes.

Pyure Organic Sugar Free Cookie Mix

Pyure’s mix contains zero grams of sugar per serving and uses stevia and erythritol as its sweeteners. It comes in chocolate chip, double chocolate, and oatmeal raisin flavors.

Pamela’s Products Ultimate Sugar Free Cookie Mix

This mix uses sucralose and stevia to achieve zero grams of sugar per serving. It can be prepared plain or with chocolate chips.

So while Betty Crocker may not offer their own sugar free cookie mix, there are a few options on the market from other brands that consumers can use instead if monitoring sugar intake.

Homemade Sugar Free Cookie Recipes

In addition to boxed mixes, there are many recipes available online for making homemade sugar free cookies from scratch using your own ingredients:

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Popular recipes substitute sugar with a blend of erythritol and stevia. Coconut or almond flour is sometimes used for a low-carb twist.


Cinnamon is the star flavor in snickerdoodle cookies. Almond flour, fat sources like cream cheese or coconut oil, and sugar substitutes like monk fruit create the sugar free base.

Peanut Butter

The bold peanut butter flavor allows the cookies to shine with minimal added sweetener. Sugar free chocolate chips can provide an extra sweet crunch.

Oatmeal Raisin

Heart-healthy oats bake up nicely with the texture and taste provided by raisins. Sugar free syrup helps sweeten the dough.

With the amazing range of recipes online today, you can certainly find sugar free cookie options to satisfy any craving using natural ingredients. While it takes more effort than a boxed mix, the payoff is fresh, healthier cookies enjoying the flavors and textures you love.

Does Betty Crocker Offer Any Explicitly Sugar Free Products?

So while their cookie lineup currently does not include any sugar free options, let’s take a look at whether Betty Crocker offers any products specifically marketed as “sugar free” across their broader portfolio of mixes.

After thoroughly browsing their available baking mixes, ready-to-eat products, and other offerings, here is an overview of what we found:

Cake Mixes

No sugar free cake mixes – All contain at least 2g added sugar per serving


No sugar free brownie mixes


No sugar free muffin mixes


Whipped Vanilla Sugar Free Frosting – sweetened with sucralose, yields 10 calories per serving

Pancake Mix

No sugar free pancake mixes

Baking General

No sugar free baking mixes beyond frosting

Based on this product investigation, Betty Crocker’s sugar free whipped vanilla frosting is the only item explicitly positioned and marketed as “sugar free”. Everything else, including all cookie, cake, brownie and muffin mixes contain significant amounts of added sugar according to nutrition labels.

The Bottom Line

After reviewing the full range of baking mixes and other products from Betty Crocker, we can conclusively confirm:

At this time, Betty Crocker does NOT offer any sugar free cookie mixes. Their line of traditional cookie mixes all contain between 7-12g of added sugars from various sources per 16g serving.

While no dedicated sugar free cookie mixes, some of Betty Crocker’s specialty mixes like gluten free or dairy free varieties could potentially be modified into lower sugar versions with careful ingredient substitutions.

Those looking for pre-made sugar free cookie mixes can find options from competitor brands like Pillsbury or Pyure. And homemade recipes allow you to craft sugar free cookies tailored to your own dietary needs and preferences.

Beyond cookies, Betty Crocker offers very few explicitly sugar free items – only a sugar free whipped vanilla frosting could be found labeled as such. All other baking mixes contain notable amounts of added sugars according to their nutrition facts.

So for those monitoring sugar intake for health or dietary reasons, exercise caution when purchasing Betty Crocker baking mixes – the majority of their products do not cater to the sugar free segment. Substituting their mixes’ added sugars or opting for another brand will be your best options for keeping sugar low in homemade baked goods.


Leave a Comment