Can you eat expired yogurt if it was frozen?

Quick Answer

It is generally safe to eat expired yogurt that has been continuously frozen, as long as it has no signs of spoilage like mold, off odors, or slime. The cold temperatures prevent bacteria growth that causes spoilage. Frozen yogurt can maintain quality and safety for 1-3 months past the expiration date if stored properly at 0°F (-18°C) or below. Thaw frozen yogurt in the refrigerator before eating. Discard yogurt if it smells bad or looks moldy after thawing.

Does Freezing Yogurt Extend Its Expiration Date?

Freezing yogurt can extend its shelf life and allow it to be safely eaten past the expiration date printed on the container. This is because freezing puts bacteria into a dormant state, effectively pausing their growth.

As long as frozen yogurt remains continuously frozen at 0°F (-18°C) or below, the bacteria and mold will remain inactive. So even if the expiration date has passed, frozen yogurt should be safe to eat if it has been properly stored in the freezer and shows no signs of spoilage.

Proper freezing cannot reverse spoilage that began before the yogurt was frozen. So yogurt that was already expired or spoiled when it was frozen should not be consumed.

Additionally, frozen storage does not kill microbes – it only presses pause on their growth. So if expired frozen yogurt is thawed and left at room temperature for too long, bacteria may become active again, multiplying to potentially unsafe levels that could make you sick.

As a general rule, frozen yogurt that has been kept at a constant 0°F with no thawing or temperature fluctuations should retain its safety and quality for 1-3 months past the printed expiration date. But when in doubt, it’s best to rely on your senses. Discard yogurt that smells off or looks moldy, even if frozen previously.

How Can You Tell if Frozen Yogurt Has Spoiled?

It can be difficult to visually identify spoilage in frozen yogurt. But here are some signs that indicate frozen yogurt may be unsafe to eat:

– Ice crystals or freezer burn throughout the yogurt – This indicates the yogurt has been thawed and refrozen, allowing bacteria growth during the thawing period.

– Mold – Check for furry or fuzzy spots of mold when you open the container. Mold can grow even at freezing temperatures.

– Odd odor – If you smell anything sour or off when you open your frozen yogurt, that’s a red flag.

– Weird consistency – Yogurt should be smooth and creamy. If it’s become grainy, watery, or slimy, it has likely spoiled.

– Discoloration – Normal yogurt should be white or off-white. Grey, yellow, or pink discoloration indicates spoilage.

After thawing expired yogurt in the fridge, inspect it closely before consuming. Look for:

– Excessive wateriness – Can indicate separation and bacterial overgrowth. Good yogurt should be thick.

– Strange smell – Should have a pleasant, tangy yogurt aroma. Foul odors means toss it.

– Change in texture – Fresh yogurt is smooth and creamy. If it’s become slimy or stringy, do not eat it.

– Mold – Any fuzzy spots or colorful growths signals spoilage.

When expired yogurt has been stored frozen properly, it can still be safe if thawed and inspected closely before eating. But never eat yogurt that shows obvious signs of spoilage.

How to Safely Thaw and Consume Expired Frozen Yogurt

Follow these guidelines for safely consuming expired frozen yogurt:

– Move the frozen yogurt to the refrigerator to thaw, not the counter. Thawing at cooler fridge temperatures helps prevent bacteria growth.

– Allow adequate time for the yogurt to fully thaw in the fridge – typically 24 hours for a standard container. Don’t try to rush thawing at room temp.

– Inspect the thawed yogurt carefully. Look for any signs of spoilage like odd textures, wateriness, mold, or off smells. If it flunks the inspection, discard it.

– If the thawed yogurt passes inspection, give it a good stir. This helps evenly distribute any separation of whey that occurred during freezing.

– Taste a small spoonful of the yogurt before digging in, to ensure it has a pleasant tangy flavor with no off tastes.

– Once thawed and inspected, yogurt should be consumed within about a week for best quality. Don’t refreeze thawed yogurt.

– Discard the yogurt if you notice any changes in texture, smell or taste as you consume it over the next few days. Trust your senses.

With an expiration date 1-3 months past, frozen yogurt has a decent shelf life. But it’s still best consumed as soon as possible once thawed, for optimal flavor and texture.

Can You Freeze Yogurt After Opening?

Yes, you can safely freeze yogurt again after opening, as long as you follow proper handling guidelines:

– Make sure the yogurt was continuously frozen before opening with no thawing. Yogurt that has been thawed and refrozen should not be consumed.

– Check that the yogurt looks and smells fresh before freezing. Do not freeze yogurt that shows any spoilage.

– Ensure the yogurt has been stored at 40°F or below in the fridge after opening. Yogurt should be used within 7-10 days after opening.

– Re-freeze yogurt within 1-2 days of opening for best quality. The sooner frozen, the better it retains texture.

– Freeze yogurt in airtight containers or bags, pressing out excess air. This prevents freezer burn.

– Freeze yogurt at 0°F or below. Consistent freezing is key to prevent bacteria growth.

– Label yogurt containers with “use by” dates so you know how old it is. 3 months is the max frozen storage time.

– Once thawed again, yogurt should be eaten within a week and not refrozen.

By properly refreezing opened yogurt immediately, you can safely extend its shelf life for up to 3 additional months while preserving texture and flavor.

Does Refrigerating Yogurt After Opening Also Extend Expiration?

Refrigerating opened yogurt can prolong its shelf life for up to 7-10 days past the “use by” date printed on the container. To maximize this fridge shelf life:

– Store opened yogurt in the coldest part of the refrigerator, at 40°F or below. This slows bacteria growth.

– Keep yogurt in its original container when possible, or an airtight sealed container. This prevents contamination.

– Avoid introducing extra moisture into the container, which could cause premature spoilage.

– Use clean utensils each time you take yogurt out to avoid introducing new bacteria.

– Check for any signs of spoilage like mold, sliminess, or off-smells before eating refrigerated yogurt past its date.

– Consume within 7-10 days for highest quality. Texture and flavor will degrade over time.

Proper refrigeration can buy you up to a week or more with opened yogurt. But freezing gives you longer shelf life if you won’t finish it quickly.

Is it Safe to Eat Yogurt That Smells Sour After Expiring?

It’s generally unsafe to eat expired yogurt with a sour smell, even if refrigerated or frozen previously. A sour odor typically signals excess bacterial growth and spoilage:

Lactobacilli – These good yogurt bacteria produce lactic acid, giving yogurt its tang. Too much causes a sour smell.

Yeasts & molds – Overgrowth results in alcohol, CO2, and fruity/sour smells.

Wild bacteria – Can multiply post-expiration, creating sulfur compounds and amine that smell rancid.

While fresh yogurt will have a mildly tangy sour aroma and flavor, an overly sour or acidic smell is usually a clear sign of spoilage. The bacteria have grown to potentially hazardous levels that can make you ill if ingested.

Additionally, sourness from excessive bacterial fermentation gives yogurt a less creamy, thinner texture that is unappetizing.

So it’s best to discard any expired yogurt that smells distinctly sour, even if it looks ok and was previously frozen. When yogurt smells off, that indicates it’s no longer safe to eat. Rely on your senses.

Can Eating Spoiled Yogurt Make You Sick?

Yes, eating spoiled yogurt can cause food poisoning, with symptoms like nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and cramping. Here are the main risks of consuming yogurt past its prime:

Foodborne pathogens – Harmful bacteria like E. coli, Salmonella, and Staph can grow if yogurt is mishandled post-expiration.

Toxins – Bacteria and mold can produce toxins that cause illness. Moldy yogurt is especially hazardous.

Wild microbes – Yogurt contains live cultures. If good bacteria die off, any wild bacteria can thrive, producing toxic byproducts.

Amines – Protein breakdown creates toxic amines like putrescine and cadaverine linked to nausea/headaches.

While properly handled frozen yogurt may be safe up to 3 months past its date, yogurt that shows any odd changes in smell, consistency, taste or appearance should be discarded. “When in doubt, toss it out” is smart policy with expired dairy products to avoid foodborne illness.

Tips for Safely Consuming Yogurt Past Its Expiration Date

Here are some tips for minimizing risks when eating expired yogurt:

Check for freezer burn – Avoid yogurt with ice crystals or drying on surface, which indicate improper freezing.

Inspect consistency – Yogurt should be smooth and creamy after thawed, not watery or slimy.

Smell first – Off odors like sourness or mustiness means toss it.

Start with a small portion – Taste a spoonful before eating a large amount to check for off flavors.

Avoid yogurt way past date – 1-3 months is reasonable for frozen. More than that is risky.

Don’t thaw on counter – Thaw frozen yogurt in the fridge to prevent bacteria overgrowth.

When in doubt, throw it out! – If yogurt looks or smells at all iffy, play it safe.

The bottom line – trust your senses. Yogurt that passes visual, smell and taste inspections is less likely to make you sick. But always discard yogurt at the first signs of spoilage.


Yogurt that has been continuously frozen can generally be safely eaten 1-3 months past the printed expiration date, provided it shows no signs of spoilage like off odors, mold, or bad texture. Freezing puts bacteria dormant, slowing spoilage. However, yogurt that was already expired before freezing should not be consumed.

Once expired frozen yogurt is thawed in the fridge, inspect it closely before eating. It should look and smell fresh with a normal creamy texture. If thawed yogurt smells or looks bad, err on the safe side and throw it away. Follow basic food safety practices when handling and consuming expired frozen foods. While the cold can preserve yogurt beyond its date, always rely on your senses, not the calendar.

Leave a Comment