Can I use margarine instead of butter for Swiss meringue buttercream?

Swiss meringue buttercream is a light, silky smooth frosting made by whisking egg whites and sugar over a double boiler to create a meringue, then slowly incorporating softened butter into the meringue. The use of butter is key for both the texture and flavor of Swiss meringue buttercream. So can margarine be substituted for the butter? Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of using margarine versus butter.

The Role of Fat in Swiss Meringue Buttercream

In Swiss meringue buttercream, butter provides fat, which is essential for proper emulsion and getting the desired smooth, creamy texture. Fat coats the sugar crystals and starch molecules from the meringue, preventing them from bonding with water and crystallizing. This gives the frosting a smooth, silky texture. Butter also contributes flavor.

Margarine contains fat, so in theory it could be used in place of butter. However, there are some important differences between butter and margarine that impact how well margarine works in Swiss meringue buttercream.

Differences Between Butter and Margarine

The main differences between butter and margarine are:

  • Butter is made from cream, while margarine is made from vegetable oils
  • Butter has a higher fat content – usually around 80% – while margarine typically contains 70-80% fat
  • Butter is mostly saturated fat, while margarine has more unsaturated fats
  • Butter has a rich dairy flavor, while margarine has little flavor
  • Butter has a firmer texture than margarine

These differences impact the texture, flavor, and performance of margarine versus butter in baking applications like Swiss meringue buttercream.

Pros of Using Margarine

There are some potential benefits to using margarine instead of butter in Swiss meringue buttercream:

  • Cost – Margarine is typically cheaper than butter
  • Availability – Margarine is easier to find than butter in some areas
  • Consistency – The softer texture of margarine makes it easier to cream into the meringue
  • Non-dairy – Margarine often contains no milk products, so it can be used for dairy-free frosting
  • Flavor – The mild flavor of margarine allows other flavors like chocolate or vanilla to shine

For home bakers looking for a more budget-friendly option, margarine can offer some benefits over butter.

Cons of Using Margarine

However, there are also some notable downsides to using margarine instead of butter for Swiss meringue buttercream:

  • Texture – Margarine has a softer texture that can make it more difficult to achieve the silky smooth, stable consistency of Swiss meringue buttercream.
  • Flavor – The flavor of margarine is not as rich buttery as real butter, so the frosting may lack depth of flavor.
  • Appearance – Margarine tends to make frosting look more greasy or oily.
  • Water content – Margarine contains more water than butter, which can impact emulsification.
  • Stability – Higher water content also means margarine frosting may not hold its shape as well.
  • Melting point – Margarine’s lower melting point means frosting may get soft and melt more easily in heat.

For professional and high-end baking applications, these drawbacks make margarine a poor substitute for butter.

The Verdict

Here is a summary of the key points on using margarine instead of butter in Swiss meringue buttercream:

Butter Margarine
  • Rich dairy flavor
  • Smooth, silky texture
  • Bright white color
  • Holds shape well
  • Mild flavor
  • Softer texture
  • Can look greasy
  • Loses shape more easily

While margarine is perfectly fine for baking applications like cookies, for frostings like Swiss meringue buttercream that rely so heavily on the specific properties of butter, most professional bakers agree margarine is not a good substitute.

Using margarine instead of butter impacts both the texture and flavor of Swiss meringue buttercream. The differences in fat content and composition mean margarine does not emulsify as well into the meringue, resulting in a softer, greasier frosting that is less smooth and stable. The flavor of margarine is also not as rich and creamy as butter.

That said, home bakers working with budget or dietary constraints may find margarine can work in a pinch. When using margarine, opt for a high-quality tub margarine with a fat content as close to butter as possible. Chill the margarine well before using to improve its texture. And use the minimum amount needed to achieve the creamy consistency, as over-softening with too much margarine can ruin the frosting. Expect some compromise on texture, appearance, and flavor compared to butter.

Tips for Using Margarine

If you do want to use margarine instead of butter, here are some tips:

  • Choose a firmer margarine with a fat content as close to 80% as possible
  • Chill the margarine well before using
  • Use the minimum amount needed, adding slowly
  • Beat very well to incorporate air for texture
  • Add a pinch of salt to enhance flavor
  • For stability, replace up to 50% of margarine with vegetable shortening
  • Refrigerate frosting to improve consistency

Butter Substitutes for Dairy-Free Frosting

For bakers avoiding dairy, butter can be replaced with non-dairy alternatives:

  • Coconut oil – Adds great coconut flavor, but can solidify if chilled
  • Palm oil – Similar properties to butter, but flavors may clash
  • Vegetable shortening – Neutral flavor, but not as creamy
  • Vegan butters – Mimic taste and texture of real butter, but more expensive

With non-dairy substitutes, combining margarine or shortening with oils helps improve the texture and moisture. The flavor and performance will depend on the particular oils and fats used.

In Conclusion

Margarine can work in Swiss meringue buttercream in a pinch for home bakers looking to cut costs or avoid dairy. However, for the best flavor and texture, butter is highly preferred over margarine. Non-dairy substitutes like coconut oil or vegan butter may be better options for dairy-free frosting with a closer resemblance to the real thing.

When it comes to Swiss meringue buttercream, the unique properties of butter – its rich flavor, bright color, pliable texture, and ability to emulsify – are hard to duplicate. Using margarine instead often means compromising on the characteristic silkiness, stability, and taste. While margarine may work, butter is truly best for optimal Swiss meringue buttercream.

Leave a Comment