Are David’s brownies gluten-free?

The Short Answer

Without knowing the specific recipe David used or being able to analyze the ingredients, it’s impossible to definitively say whether his brownies are gluten-free. However, most traditional brownie recipes do contain gluten, so the likelihood is that David’s brownies are not gluten-free unless he specifically formulated the recipe to exclude gluten-containing ingredients. Some detectives work would need to be done to determine if he used any gluten-free flours or binders and avoided ingredients like wheat flour that contain gluten.

What is Gluten and Why Does it Matter?

Gluten is a protein found in grains like wheat, barley and rye. It acts as a glue that helps food maintain its shape and have a chewy texture. For most people, eating gluten is not a problem. However, for those with celiac disease or non-celiac gluten sensitivity, consuming gluten can cause issues like abdominal pain, bloating, diarrhea and other digestive distress.

Celiac disease is an autoimmune disorder where the body mounts an attack against its own tissues when gluten is eaten. This damages the lining of the small intestine and impairs its ability to absorb nutrients. Non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS) is a milder condition that also causes adverse reactions to gluten but does not involve the autoimmune response.

The only treatment for celiac disease and NCGS is adhering to a strict lifelong gluten-free diet. This means avoiding any products made with wheat, barley, rye and related grains. Following a gluten-free diet can be challenging, as gluten is commonly used in many processed foods and restaurant dishes. Reading ingredient lists carefully and being aware of cross-contamination is key.

For people with celiac disease or NCGS, determining if a food like brownies contains gluten is extremely important, as even small amounts of exposure can trigger symptoms and intestinal damage. That’s why finding out if David’s brownies are gluten-free is necessary for those who need to avoid gluten.

Common Sources of Gluten in Brownies

Most traditional brownie recipes call for ingredients that contain gluten. Here are some of the most common sources of gluten typically found in brownies:

  • Wheat flour: Most brownie recipes use all-purpose flour, which is made from wheat. Wheat contains gluten, so wheat flour is not gluten-free.
  • Barley malt: Some brownie recipes include barley malt or malt extract as an ingredient. Barley is a gluten-containing grain, so barley malt is not gluten-free.
  • Malt powder: Malted milk or malt powder is sometimes used in brownies too. These are made from barley and contain gluten.
  • Beer: Brownies made with beer as an ingredient are not gluten-free, as most beers contain gluten from their ingredients.
  • Soy sauce: Soy sauce often contains wheat and is not gluten-free. Brownies made with soy sauce would contain gluten.
  • Flavor extracts: Some flavor extracts like vanilla contain alcohol distilled from gluten-containing grains and are not gluten-free.
  • Unsafe oats: Regular oats are often contaminated with wheat during growing and processing. Only gluten-free oats are safe for a gluten-free diet.
  • Unsafe grains: Other gluten-containing grains like rye are sometimes added to brownies, making them unsafe for those avoiding gluten.

Unless the recipe has been specially formulated to exclude these ingredients and use gluten-free alternatives instead, most traditional brownies contain sources of gluten and are not naturally gluten-free.

Potential Gluten-Free Ingredients in Brownies

While traditional brownies are likely to have gluten, there are many ingredients that can be used to make gluten-free brownies instead:

  • Gluten-free flours: Rice flour, almond flour, coconut flour and other gluten-free flours can replace wheat flour in brownies.
  • Xanthan gum: This acts as a binder to give structure to gluten-free baked goods.
  • Eggs: Eggs help hold gluten-free brownies together.
  • Unsweetened chocolate: Most pure unsweetened chocolate and cocoa powder are gluten-free.
  • Butter: Plain dairy butter contains no gluten.
  • Extracts: Pure extracts like vanilla, almond and peppermint that don’t contain alcohol are gluten-free.
  • Sugar: White sugar, brown sugar and powdered sugar do not contain gluten.
  • Salt: Most table salt is gluten-free.
  • Nuts: Almonds, walnuts, pecans and other nuts can be used.
  • Dairy: Milk, cream cheese, sour cream and yogurt are options for gluten-free brownies.
  • Oils: Vegetable, olive, coconut and other oils are gluten-free.
  • Gluten-free chocolate chips: Many brands make chocolate chips that are gluten-free.

Using these alternative ingredients, it’s totally possible to prepare brownies that don’t contain any gluten at all. However, unless David’s recipe was developed specifically to be gluten-free using these types of substitutions, the likelihood is that his brownies do contain sources of gluten.

Cross-Contamination Risks

Even if the ingredients themselves are gluten-free, cross-contamination during processing, handling and cooking can introduce gluten into foods unintentionally. Here are some potential sources of cross-contamination when making brownies:

  • Shared equipment: If equipment and utensils used to make wheat-based baked goods are also used for gluten-free items without thorough cleaning in between, there is a high risk of cross-contamination.
  • Shared facilities: Similarly, if a facility processes gluten-containing products, gluten could be introduced into gluten-free items through shared machinery, air circulation, etc.
  • Shared ingredients: Scoops and containers used for ingredients like flour may pick up traces of gluten if used for multiple purposes.
  • Toasters: If regular bread is toasted in a toaster, crumbs left behind can contaminate gluten-free items later toasted in the same toaster.
  • Sifters: Using the same sifter for wheat flour and gluten-free flours spreads gluten throughout.
  • Wooden utensils: Grooves in wooden spoons and cutting boards can harbor gluten that transfers to gluten-free doughs and batters.

Unless a very careful approach is taken to prevent cross-contamination at every stage, it can be challenging to prepare 100% gluten-free items even with gluten-free ingredients. If David used shared equipment and tools to make his brownies, gluten could have inadvertently been introduced.

Packaged Brownie Mixes

Many pre-packaged brownie mixes available at the grocery store contain gluten. However, there are some widely available brands of gluten-free brownie mix, such as:

  • Betty Crocker Gluten Free Brownie Mix
  • Pillsbury Gluten Free Chocolate Brownie Mix
  • King Arthur Baking Gluten Free Brownie Mix
  • Bisquick Gluten Free Brownie Mix
  • Bob’s Red Mill Gluten Free Brownie Mix

If David used one of these gluten-free mixes, it would provide some reassurance that his brownies are gluten-free. However, as always, the actual manufacturing practices should be reviewed to ensure no cross-contamination. Many gluten-free consumers call companies directly to ask about their protocols before determining if a product is truly safe.

Common Questions to Determine if Brownies are Gluten-Free

Here are some questions that can be helpful to ask in order to get more clues about whether or not a particular brownie is gluten-free:

  • What recipe did you use? Ask to see the exact ingredients and directions.
  • Did the recipe include any wheat flour, barley, malt, beer or soy sauce?
  • Did you use a packaged gluten-free brownie mix? Which brand?
  • What gluten-free flours or binders were included?
  • Were any of the ingredients or mixes labeled “gluten-free”?
  • Was the brownie made in a certified gluten-free facility?
  • What steps did you take to avoid cross-contamination with gluten?
  • Were any kitchen tools or appliances used that may have had gluten on them?

Knowing the details about the specific ingredients, kitchen practices and awareness around gluten can help determine the likelihood of whether or not the finished brownies actually ended up being gluten-free.

When in Doubt, Leave it Out

If there is any doubt about whether or not a food contains gluten, the safest approach for those with celiac disease or NCGS is simply to avoid it entirely. Consuming gluten can have serious long-term consequences for those who are gluten-intolerant.

It’s not worth taking risks when it comes to your health, as the impacts can build over time. Even if David’s intention was to make gluten-free brownies, unless you have complete confidence that it was executed properly using verified gluten-free ingredients and practices, erring on the side of caution is wise.

Testing Brownies for Gluten

If necessary, brownies can be tested for the presence of gluten using laboratory analysis. Here are some options for gluten testing:


The ELISA test detects antibodies in foods. Most gluten tests use a sandwich ELISA, which can determine if a sample contains as little as 5-10 parts per million (ppm) of gluten. For people with celiac disease, ingesting under 20 ppm is unlikely to cause damage. So a brownie testing below this threshold could be considered gluten-free.

PCR Test

PCR testing amplifies DNA sequences and can detect the presence of grains containing gluten, like wheat, barley and rye in a food sample. It provides a positive or negative result, but doesn’t quantify the exact amount of gluten present. A negative PCR test indicates a food is likely gluten-free with very minimal traces, if any.

Mass Spectrometry

This method identifies proteins by molecular structure and can differentiate intact gluten from hydrolyzed gluten, which is not as likely to cause issues for those with gluten disorders. The detection level can be as low as 5 ppm. Results provide an exact gluten concentration.

At-Home Testing Kits

There are some gluten testing kits available for consumers to use at home. These typically involve extracting a food sample and adding it to a test strip that changes color based on a gluten reaction. However, they tend to have high detection limits of 20-100 ppm and can have questionable accuracy.

Laboratory testing provides the most precise, sensitive results to truly determine if a food like brownies contains gluten and if so, how much. This gives the best information for deciding whether consuming the brownies could be safely tolerated by someone following a strict gluten-free diet for medical reasons.

When to Get Tested for Gluten-Related Disorders

If you experience symptoms like bloating, abdominal pain, diarrhea, constipation, headaches, fatigue and eczema after consuming gluten, you may have an underlying sensitivity or intolerance. It’s important to get tested by a doctor in order to know if avoiding gluten could improve your health.

Here are some indications that testing for celiac disease or non-celiac gluten sensitivity makes sense:

  • Ongoing digestive distress after eating foods with wheat, barley or rye
  • Nutrient deficiencies like iron deficiency anemia, folate deficiency, vitamin D deficiency, etc.
  • Unexplained weight loss or difficulty gaining weight
  • Family history of celiac disease
  • Autoimmune disorders like type 1 diabetes, autoimmune thyroid disease, rheumatoid arthritis, etc.
  • Diagnosis of irritable bowel syndrome or small intestinal bacterial overgrowth
  • Persistent mouth ulcers, skin rash or joint pain
  • Neurological symptoms like gluten ataxia, peripheral neuropathy or gluten encephalopathy

Testing often involves blood work to detect specific antibodies, along with an endoscopy and intestinal biopsy to examine damage. In some cases, a gluten challenge trial may be conducted where gluten is consumed daily for 6-8 weeks prior to retesting.

Knowing your status provides the information needed to properly manage your health through dietary changes and medical follow up. It also ensures you have an explanation when asking about gluten content, as restaurants and manufacturers take requests for gluten-free foods more seriously when they understand it is for medical reasons.

Finding Alternatives to Enjoy Treats Like Brownies

Following a gluten-free diet for medical reasons doesn’t have to mean feeling deprived. Here are some tips for still being able to satisfy your sweet tooth with delicious baked goods:

  • Search for recipes that are designed to be gluten-free, rather than trying to modify traditional recipes.
  • Look for packaged mixes and batter products that are certified gluten-free.
  • Buy treats from dedicated gluten-free bakeries you trust.
  • Use naturally gluten-free whole food ingredients like fruit, nuts and dark chocolate in desserts.
  • Ask your local bakery if they offer gluten-free options or are willing to prepare items using your own ingredients.
  • Request that restaurants serve desserts with gluten-free accompaniments like ice cream rather than cake or cookies.
  • Focus your indulgences on foods that are naturally gluten-free like puddings, custards, frozen treats, etc.
  • Satisfy your sweet tooth with gluten-free candy bars, chocolate, licorice and other confections.

It takes some adjustments to navigate treating yourself gluten-free. But with creativity and commitment to your health, living with gluten restrictions doesn’t have to feel restrictive.

The Bottom Line

Unless David specifically set out to create gluten-free brownies using verified gluten-free ingredients and careful practices, it is unlikely that his brownies are definitively gluten-free. Most traditional brownie recipes contain sources of gluten. And even gluten-free ingredients can easily become cross-contaminated through shared equipment, utensils and facilities.

When managing celiac disease or gluten sensitivity, it’s always best to err on the side of caution. Consuming questionable baked goods from unknown sources is simply not worth the consequences and potential side effects. For those with gluten disorders, sticking to treats from trusted gluten-free brands or bakeries that are meticulous about their protocols is the safest approach.

So in summary, unless you have meticulous details about the recipe and preparation methods, it’s generally wisest to assume that brownies like David’s contain at least some amount of gluten and are not suitable for those strictly adhering to a gluten-free medical diet. When in doubt, leaving treats that could possibly contain gluten out is the best policy for preserving health. But with extra care and effort, safe and delicious gluten-free indulgences can certainly still be part of enjoying life!

Leave a Comment