Why we can t remember our youngest years?

It’s a common experience that most adults cannot recall memories from the first few years of their lives. Some research suggests that most people’s earliest memories date back only to around 3 to 4 years old. So why is it that we can’t remember anything before this time? There are a few key reasons.

Infantile Amnesia

The phenomenon of being unable to remember early childhood experiences is called infantile amnesia. Researchers believe there are several factors that contribute to infantile amnesia:

Immature Brain

One of the main reasons we can’t form lasting memories in our earliest years is that our brains are simply not developed enough. The hippocampus, which is the part of the brain crucial for memory and learning, is not fully functional until around age 3 or 4. So any memories formed before that time are unlikely to persist.

The prefrontal cortex, responsible for higher cognitive functions like attention, planning, and memory retrieval, also undergoes rapid change during the first few years of life. With an immature prefrontal cortex, it becomes even harder to form, store, and retrieve coherent memories from our early experiences.

Lack of Language

Language development also plays a key role. When we learn words and start verbally expressing ourselves, it becomes much easier to translate our experiences into memories that we can hang onto. Before we have language skills, we can’t easily construct narratives or “stories” out of our early sensations and experiences.

Rapid Brain Development

The incredible amount of neurological development happening in early childhood may also overwrite any fragile memories formed before age 3 or 4. Connections in the brain are developing rapidly, meaning that early memory traces likely get brushed over.

It’s estimated that synaptic density in the prefrontal cortex doubles in the first year of life. This overabundance of connections gets gradually pruned back to more efficient networks. In the process, early memories are likely cleared away.

Context and Perspective

Another reason we may not be able to remember being infants or toddlers is that we lack the appropriate context or perspective to make sense of those memories.

Looking back as adults, it’s hard for us to put ourselves back in the shoes of a pre-verbal child who sees the world in a totally different way. A memory of looking up at some colored shapes and noises would seem trivial and incomprehensible to our adult minds. But to an infant, that might have been a significant sensory experience at the time.

No Concept of “Self”

Young infants also don’t have a clear concept of “self” – they don’t yet differentiate between themselves and the external environment. Without this sense of self, it becomes difficult to assign first-person ownership to early memories the way adults do.

Different Sense of Time

Similarly, very young children have no real understanding of time. They live entirely in the present moment. Without a concept of time passing, early memories have no temporal context, making them hard to retrieve later on.

Explicit vs. Implicit Memory

Some developmental researchers make a distinction between explicit and implicit memories when discussing infantile amnesia.

Explicit memories are conscious, purposeful recollections of past events, like remembering your first day of school. Implicit memories are unconscious traces of past experiences that can influence later behavior, perceptions, emotions, and habits.

Implicit Memories Remain

While we lack explicit memories from the first years of life, some implicit memories may still be embedded in our minds. These implicit memories can emerge later in indirect ways.

For example, a childhood fear of dogs could stem from an early upsetting encounter with a dog that the adult has no explicit memory of. Certain sensations, smells, sights, or sounds from infancy might also provoke emotional responses in adulthood, hinting at buried implicit memories.

So it seems we carry remnants of very early experiences in our unconscious minds, even if we have no awareness of them.

When Do Earliest Memories Form?

If infantile amnesia blocks early memories, when do our first explicit autobiographical memories start to form? Some key research findings:

Age 3-4

Most studies show that our earliest childhood memories date back to around age 3 or 4. In one study, adults were asked about their first memory. On average, the subjects reported that their first memory was from the age of 3.5 years.

Earlier Memories Possible

While rare, some individuals have been able to describe coherent autobiographical memories from before age 3, even as far back as their first year of life. However, these very early memories are fragile and difficult to verify.

Language and Culture

The language environment and cultural influences seem to play a role in how early memories emerge. One study found that the average age of first memory was around 2 years earlier for Chinese adults compared to Caucasian adults. The rich linguistic context in Chinese families may support earlier autobiographical memory.

Traumatic Events

Highly emotional, vivid, or traumatic experiences are more likely to be remembered from an early age than mundane events. For instance, memories of accidents, injuries, hospital visits, or the birth of a sibling tend to stick with people from as young as 2 years old.

Age Memory Milestones
0-2 years No conscious autobiographical memories
2-4 years Fragmentary flashes of events or situations begin to emerge
3-4 years Earliest childhood memories form, often related to salient events
5 years + Children can provide coherent narratives about past events

How Childhood Amnesia Develops

Childhood amnesia follows a typical pattern as children grow up. Research shows that adults’ memories of childhood gradually get pushed later, in a process of “forward telescoping.”

Age 2

At age 2, a child might have scattered memories stretching back months earlier. But by age 6, those very early traces will have faded.

Age 3

At age 3, a child may remember incidents from 6 months to 1 year ago. But asking the same child at age 8, those memories will now only go back to age 2 or 3.

Age 5

By age 5, some memories extend back 3 to 4 years. An adult recalling childhood at age 20 will often no longer remember anything before age 5.

Age 9

So as we age, the boundary of childhood amnesia continues to move forward in time. Memories get compressed and the earliest ones are eventually lost altogether.

Is Forgetting Early Memories Adaptive?

Childhood amnesia leads to the natural question – is the forgetting of early memories actually beneficial in some way? Could there be an adaptive purpose?

Some evolutionary psychology theories suggest that forgetting our earliest years may support survival by allowing us to move past innate behaviors we are born with. For example, not remembering being bottle-fed as infants facilitates our maturation toward independence and self-reliance.

Letting go of earliest memories may also streamline our use of memory capacity, preventing overload. Or the fragility of early memories may reflect that overall, remembering very early childhood experiences is less essential for adults’ functioning than recalling recent events.

However, there are currently no definitive explanations for what evolutionary advantages childhood amnesia may confer. So far, empirical evidence cannot confirm any clear survival benefits to forgetting our first years of life. But researchers continue exploring this fascinating question.

Impacts on Development

Despite not remembering our earliest years, those early experiences absolutely shape our development. Language, attachment styles, cognitive abilities, emotional regulation, and social skills all have foundations in our first few years of life that we are unable to recall.

Some ways the forgotten years influence development:

Language and Speech

Linguistic inputs we receive as infants affect the neural networks for hearing, listening, and vocabulary. Early language exposure impacts our communication abilities and literacy later in childhood.

Attachment and Relationships

The bonds and interactions we have with caregivers from birth to age 3 provide models for our future relationships and capacity for emotional intimacy.

Cognitive Skills

Our sensorimotor experiences as babies and toddlers lay the groundwork for many cognitive skills. Exploring objects, navigating physical space, etc. contributes to abilities like categorization, causation, spatial awareness, and differentiating self from other.

Emotional Security

Having attentive, responsive caregivers who meet our needs in infancy provides core emotional security and self-confidence that shapes our moods and resilience long-term.

So while we don’t consciously remember anything before age 3 or 4, almost every domain of human development has foundations rooted in those unremembered early years. The infant experiences we can’t recall are still integral to explaining who we become.

Efforts to Uncover Early Memories

Given how fascinating yet perplexing childhood amnesia is, various techniques have been used in attempts to uncover adults’ blocked out early memories. But most methods end up creating false memories rather than reliably recovering accurate ones.


Hypnosis has suggestibility effects that often generate imagined memories instead of real ones. Under hypnosis, subjects recall childhood events that likely never took place.

Dream Analysis

Linking elements in dreams to possible early memories is extremely speculative and unverifiable. There are no solid conclusions from dream analysis about forgotten memories.

Age Regression

Techniques meant to mentally “regress” adults back to a childlike state are similarly unreliable. Adults asked to act infantile end up producing behaviors based on stereotypes rather than actual memories.

Story Construction

When adults are asked to free-associate childhood scenarios and construct stories around them, this produces fictional narratives, not recovered memories.

Overall, there are currently no psychotherapy techniques that can accurately retrieve forgotten memories from the infantile amnesia period of life. The recollections that get generated are generally false, so the barrier of childhood amnesia remains resistant to recall methods.

Theories Around Childhood Amnesia

Many theories aim to explain why we can’t remember our earliest years, but there is no consensus on which provides the best explanation. Some leading theories include:

Developmental Theory

As covered earlier, this theory focuses on the normal processes of brain maturation. According to this view, infantile amnesia occurs due to the underdeveloped neurological systems of young children. Proponents argue that as the hippocampus, prefrontal cortex, and other brain structures develop, sharper explicit memories become possible around age 3 or 4.

Language Acquisition Theory

This theory highlights that being preverbal severely limits a child’s ability to encode cohesive declarative memories. Only after acquiring a rich vocabulary, understanding syntax, and communicating in sentences can children form memorable narratives of their experiences.

Identity Development Theory

Some argue that infantile amnesia results from young children lacking a clear concept of identity or coherent sense of self until around age 3. Without realizing itself as a separate individual, a child cannot associate subjective experiences as belonging to “me”, making them harder to recall later.

Infantile Trauma Theory

According to Freud, we repress traumatic memories from infancy and childhood to protect our psyche. However, there is little evidence that blocked memories from 0-3 years are linked to trauma. Traumatic events are typically more memorable than positive ones.

Consolidation Failure Theory

This account says memories are successfully encoded in infancy, but the memory consolidation process somehow fails. However, some recent studies have demonstrated that children under 3 do show implicit memory, so the issue seems to be with retrieval rather than consolidation.

The debate continues around exactly how much each of the above factors truly contribute to childhood amnesia. And new theories may emerge as we learn more about memory development.

Ways to Investigate Childhood Memories

Given the mysteries still surrounding early childhood amnesia, researchers employ various methods to try to gain insights into our forgotten earliest memories and experiences.

Interview Studies

In these studies, adults are directly interviewed about their early memories. Researchers analyze the age distribution, content, nature and features of the childhood events subjects are able to recall.

Parental Reports

Parents might keep diaries about children’s experiences and development. Researchers can then compare what parents recorded about a child’s early years with what that individual remembers later on to see what details were lost.

Photographic Cues

Another technique is showing adults childhood photos or home movies of themselves under age 3. The visual cues are analyzed for triggers and amount of related memories recalled.

Implicit Behavioral Studies

Some studies measure implicit memory in children under 3 to assess whether early experiences still impact perception, preferences, or behaviors even when no conscious memory exists. For example, studies have found toddlers retain implicit memories of faces.

Clinical Case Studies

Researchers also look at clinical cases like early brain trauma. Studying those with damaged hippocampi can reveal the precise neurological correlates of unable to form lasting memories in early childhood.

How Much Are Early Memories Trusted?

When adults do report memories from before age 3 or 4, how reliable are those recollections? Overall, memories from our first few years require caution and scrutiny.

Hard to Verify

One problem is we have no objective way to confirm whether a very early childhood memory is accurate or not. Memories predating external records like photographs require dependence on the individual’s unverified narrative.


There is evidence that people create self-stories around imagined experiences, then mentally rehearse them until they feel as if they genuinely happened. Without proof, some claimed early memories may simply be such self-generated narratives.

Suggestibility Effects

Studies also show that false suggestions or leading questions easily distort early memories. Young kids are especially susceptible to having imaginary memories implanted.

Mistimed Memories

Apparent memories of infancy could also be mistaken. For example, an incident from age 2 or 3 may get recategorized in retrospect as occurring even earlier than it did. Without records, timing is difficult to pinpoint.

So when individuals claim coherent recollections from age 1 or 2, psychologists recommend treating these with healthy skepticism, given the documented unreliability of such early memories.

Final Thoughts

Childhood amnesia remains one of the most intriguing mysteries of human memory development. While we have gained many insights around the causes and influences of infantile amnesia, a full understanding remains elusive.

The forgetting of our earliest years reflects how memory, identity, language, emotions, and neural networks dynamically interplay as a child matures. Unlocking those initial few years that virtually all adults cannot access could reveal fundamental clues about memory formation itself.

But for now, our first conscious recollections remain walled off, leaving an impenetrable black hole in our autobiographical timelines. And the question continues – what really did happen in those earliest, unremembered chapters of our lives? The answers lie locked away in our minds, unavailable to introspection.

Leave a Comment