Why can’t you eat an Osage orange?

The Osage orange, also known as hedge apple or mock orange, is the fruit of the Osage-orange tree (Maclura pomifera). It is a bright green globe-shaped fruit that is inedible for humans when raw due to its tough, sticky texture and unpleasant bitter taste.

What is an Osage orange?

The Osage orange is a spherical fruit produced by the Osage-orange tree, a small deciduous tree or large shrub that is native to the south-central United States. It earned the name “hedge apple” because early settlers used the trees as living fences to divide fields and pen livestock. It gets the name “mock orange” from its resemblance to oranges, despite not being closely related to citrus fruits.

Osage oranges are typically 3-6 inches in diameter and turn bright yellow-green in the fall. They have a lumpy outer surface covered in a sticky latex sap. Inside, the fruit has a dense and woody flesh with a bitter and unpalatable taste.

Why are Osage oranges inedible for humans?

There are several reasons why Osage oranges are too unpalatable to eat fresh:

  • Unpleasant bitter taste – They contain high levels of bitter-tasting phenolic compounds.
  • Tough, sticky texture – The flesh is hard to chew and has an adhesive, latex-like feel.
  • Toxicity – Though not deadly poisonous, they can cause stomach upset if eaten.
  • Low moisture content – The dry, dense flesh lacks juiciness or moisture.
  • Minimal sugar content – They have very little sugar to balance out the bitterness.

The strong bitter taste and rubbery texture make Osage oranges completely inedible except with significant preparation. Even squirrels and deer tend to avoid fresh hedge apples.

Are Osage oranges toxic to humans?

Osage oranges are not deadly poisonous, but they do contain chemicals that make them toxic to humans in large quantities. These include:

  • Triterpenes – Bioactive compounds that act as toxins.
  • Tetrahydrofuroguaiacin – A potentially toxic chemical compound.
  • Bergapten – A furanocoumarin compound that can cause phototoxic skin reactions.

Eating one or two hedge apples is unlikely to cause more than temporary stomach upset. However, ingesting significant quantities could result in vomiting, diarrhea, and neurotoxic effects due to the triterpenes. Osage orange extracts have also been shown to have pesticidal properties.

What do Osage oranges taste like?

The predominant flavor of raw Osage oranges is bitter, with very intense bitterness compared to most fruits. Some descriptions compare the taste to bitter almonds, lemon rind, or grapefruit mixed with turpentine. The bitterness is due to high levels of flavonoid compounds like pomiferin.

In addition to the strong bitter taste, Osage oranges also taste:

  • Astringent – They have a dry, puckering mouthfeel.
  • Acrid – There is a harsh, irritating pungency.
  • Latex-like – The flesh has a sticky, rubbery texture.
  • Woody – The flesh is dense and difficult to chew.

The texture and acidity also affect the taste. The dry flesh and citric acid notes enhance the sour bitterness. Overall, the flavor profile is too unbalanced and intense for the fruit to be edible on its own.

Can you eat Osage oranges if you prepare them?

Osage oranges require significant processing and preparation before they become palatable for human consumption. Some ways the fruit can be altered to make it less bitter and more edible include:

  • Boiling/simmering – Extended cooking can help mellow some bitterness.
  • Soaking in multiple changes of water – Leaches out some bitter compounds.
  • Fermenting – Yeast fermentation helps reduce bitter flavors.
  • Mixing with sugar or other fruit – Sweeteners and fruit concentrates mask bitterness.
  • Drying – Some bitterness dissipates as moisture is removed.

Even with significant processing, the peculiar flavor remains quite strong. Osage oranges are most commonly eaten in the form of jams, jellies, and preserves, often combined with sweeter fruit.

Are any parts of the Osage orange edible?

While the fruit is inedible raw, other parts of the Osage orange tree can be eaten or used for food purposes:

  • Flowers – Can be eaten or used to make tea.
  • Leaves – Young leaves can be boiled as a pot herb or used to make tea.
  • Seeds – Roasted seeds can be used as a coffee substitute.
  • Wood – Historically used for lye in soapmaking.
  • Sap – Potentially can be tapped for syrup similarly to maple trees.

The flowers, leaves, and roasted seeds are more palatable than the fruit due to lower concentrations of bitter chemicals. However, they may still retain some bitterness and astringency when consumed.

What animals can eat Osage oranges?

While too bitter for most human tastes, Osage oranges hold more appeal for some animal species. Animals that are able to consume the fruit include:

  • Squirrels – Will gnaw open the fruit but do not consume much.
  • Deer – Sometimes eat fallen fruits off the ground.
  • Cattle – May chew on fruits if hungry enough.
  • Pigs – Relish the fruit and will seek it out as a food source.
  • Horses – Occasionally eat Osage oranges.

Some wild animals like squirrels and deer avoid eating much of the bitter fruit. Domesticated livestock like pigs and horses are more likely to willingly consume hedge apples, especially if other food is scarce. Cattle also occasionally snack on the fruits.

Does any wildlife eat Osage oranges?

Aside from pigs, the most notable wildlife species that consume Osage oranges are:

  • Foxes – Foxes will eat fallen Osage oranges, seeds and all.
  • Opossums – Relish the fruit and are efficient at cracking open the tough rinds.
  • Raccoons – Will eat both the seeds and flesh of hedge apples.
  • Woodpeckers – Drill into the fruit exterior to access the inner flesh.
  • Squirrels – Gnaw into the rind but do not eat much of the fruit inside.

Other species like box turtles, quail, and mallard ducks have also been observed consuming at least parts of the Osage orange fruit at times. Overall, opossums and raccoons appear to be the wildlife most likely to seek out and eat hedge apples.

Why did Native Americans value Osage oranges?

Although not good to eat, Osage oranges were valued by Native Americans for reasons other than food. Some key uses included:

  • Bow wood – The elastic wood made excellent, sturdy bows.
  • Fence posts – Its rot resistance made long-lasting fence posts.
  • Insect repellent – Pounded fruits used to repel insects.
  • Dye – Yellow-orange dye extracted from the wood and bark.
  • Medicine – Used to treat ailments like coughs and arthritis.

Osage orange wood is flexible, dense, and decay-resistant, making it ideal for toolmaking and building. The Comanche, Osage, and other tribes heavily utilized the valuable wood, trading bows and arrows made from it.

What natural insect repellents can be made from Osage oranges?

Osage orange extracts can be used to create natural insect repellents. Some traditional repellent methods include:

  • Mashing fruits – Pounding fruits makes an insect-repelling mush.
  • Boiling fruits – Extracts from boiled fruits can repel insects.
  • Smoldering fruits – Smoky smoke deters insects.
  • Making tinctures – Liquid extracts applied to skin deter bugs.
  • Making salves – Thick salves block insects from biting.

The triterpenes and flavonoids in Osage oranges have proven insecticidal effects. The fruits can be made into sprays, powders, salves, and smudge sticks to repel mosquitoes, spiders, cockroaches, and other pests.

Osage Orange Insect Repellent Recipe

Here is a simple DIY Osage orange insect repellent recipe:

Ingredients Quantity
Osage oranges 2 fruits
Water 4 cups
Vodka or witch hazel (optional) 1/2 cup
Essential oils like citronella or eucalyptus (optional) 5-10 drops

Instructions:

  1. Chop the Osage oranges finely and place in a pot with the water.
  2. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat and simmer for 30 minutes.
  3. Remove from heat and mash the fruits, then strain out the solids.
  4. Mix in vodka or witch hazel and any essential oils.
  5. Pour into a spray bottle or rub directly on skin.

The liquid can be applied to skin or sprayed onto clothing or surfaces. The alcohol and essential oils help the repellent effects last longer. Store any extra repellent in the refrigerator.

What traditional medicines were made using Osage oranges?

Native Americans traditionally used parts of Osage orange plants to create herbal remedies, including:

  • Bark tea – Used to treat fevers, arthritis, and kidney problems.
  • Root bark tea – Given as a laxative and to induce vomiting.
  • Fruit tincture – Applied topically to treat ringworm and other skin issues.
  • Twig tea – Used as a diuretic and stimulant.
  • Leaf tea – Given to ease childbirth and soothe toothaches.

The Osage were known to brew a tea from the inner root bark as an emetic and laxative. Bark extracts may also have some antimicrobial properties that could help combat certain infections or skin conditions.

Precautions

Osage orange extracts should not be ingested by pregnant women as they may stimulate the uterus. The fruits also contain toxic compounds that can cause stomach issues in some individuals if consumed.

Conclusion

In summary, Osage oranges have an intensely bitter and unpalatable flavor that makes them completely inedible for humans when raw. Their texture is also dry, woody, and sticky. Significant processing is required through cooking, soaking, or mixing with sweeteners before the fruit becomes remotely edible. While Osage orange trees provided valuable wood and insect repellents, the fruits themselves remain too bitter and toxic for people to eat under normal circumstances.

Leave a Comment