TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth in Indianapolis (Photos, Menu, Reviews & Ratings)

TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth

Address: 8660 Purdue Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46268

Phone: (317) 744-9764


Menu: View Online

Rating: 4.8

Website: http://www.teejayssweettooth.com/

What Time Does TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth Open?

Saturday,: 3 to 9PM

Sunday,: 3 to 8PM

Monday,: Closed

Tuesday,: 5 to 9PM

Wednesday,: 5 to 9PM

Thursday,: 5 to 9PM

Friday,: 3 to 9PM

TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth Directions

More Donuts In Indianapolis


TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth Reviews

Tyler Gressle

This ice cream is worth the wait Especially if you get the brownie sundae version of your favorite I got the Espresso Brownie Swirl(brownie sundae version), she got Cookie Monster(brownie sundae version). They give you a gigantic amount of ice cream, toppings, and brownie that are jam packed with flavor Only downside in my own opinion is the inside currently being closed.

luis ibanez

gotta order the cotton candy burrito

Shakes are

♦️♦️stay away from donut ice cream to my preference was just not good.

To be honest I like Handel’s or la michoacana better. But they have good creativity with the burrito.

Traveling Foodie Guyde

I scream, you scream, we all scream for ICE CREAM!..with a twist!

I’m so glad I found TeeJays’s because they do ice cream like no other. With there ever changing rotating menu, you never know what you’ll get at TeeJay’s..but if you want a hint, let me school you!

I tried the fruity pebble sandwich, the doughnut ice cream sandwich, the cotton candy burrito, the egg nog dog shake (I nicknamed that) and the Oreo shake..do I sound fat yet? . Everything was 100% deliciousness!

I swore I left there with diabetes and it was worth it! And in case you happen to get a cavity, I heard the owners were in the dental industry and could help you out (wink wink).

Visit them soon and tell them your favorite @travelingfoodieguyde sent you and tag me in the pics and videos!

Erika Purlee

Great place for some unique sweet treats! We recommend the Graham Central shake, cotton candy kiddie scoops, or anything else on the menu, because it is all pretty amazing.

Explore With Me KD!

$$ We loved the taste of these shakes and the little enjoyed her cone she said it was Delicious in her Dora voice . Other kids said they’d prefer it over Dairy Queen if that says anything. I don’t know if I agree with that. They were creamy and just the right consistency not too thick and not to thin. I would have liked for them to have more of the actually toppings inside of them for the price. My favorite part was the rim whatever they apply it with is really sweet. The wait wasn’t long and since they aren’t open inside yet they bring it out to your car after you place your order in the drive through.

Jessica Lewis

Their brownies are AHHHMAZING!!!! Not to mention their ice cream is phenomenal! I love how they switch up flavors all the time! My new favorite ice cream spot for sure!

Prisilla D

Overrated- I bought the doughnut ice cream sandwich. To preface I LOVE desserts, I’ll eat and love most desserts. They use off brand weird tasting doughnuts, my kid also wouldn’t eat them. The ice cream was very basic and not creamy, or unique in any way. I could have bought ice cream and doughnuts from target and made it better for the same price and 6x the quantity. Not worth it, I won’t be returning.

Sarah Thomas

What a cool place!! The best local ice cream place around. Creative and fun treats for kids and young at heart adults. Fruity Pebble ice cream sandwich with blackberry cheesecake and strawberry. The Cloud Cone doned a huge ring of cotton candy around a scoop of banana cream pie in a waffle cone.

Romes Queen

This place was beyond what I expected! I got the Donut Sundae with 1 scoop of the Graham Central, & 1 scoop of Lemon Pound Cake. They were both delicious, but that Graham Central was the best!!! Go check out Tee Jay’s you won’t be disappointed!!!

Catherine O’Donnell

An absolute gem! I did the Pack N Go option to bring TeeJay’s ice cream to a work event. It was so easy to coordinate, reasonable pricing, and easy pickup. The team loved the ice cream!

More Reviews for TeeJay’s Sweet Tooth

More Donuts In Indianapolis

Donuts Guides