Should I keep crypto in Coinbase or wallet?

Quick Answers

There are pros and cons to keeping crypto on Coinbase versus in a wallet. Coinbase is convenient and secure, but you don’t control the private keys. A wallet gives you control, but you are responsible for security. For small amounts, Coinbase is likely fine. For large holdings, a hardware wallet is recommended.

What is Coinbase?

Coinbase is a leading cryptocurrency exchange platform and wallet provider based in San Francisco. Founded in 2012, Coinbase has become one of the most trusted and widely-used platforms for buying, selling, and storing cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum, and others.

Some key features of Coinbase include:

  • Easy to use interface and mobile app
  • Supports over 100 different cryptocurrencies
  • Built-in hosted wallet to store crypto
  • Ability to easily buy crypto with bank transfer, debit/credit card, or PayPal
  • Advanced trading platform (Coinbase Pro) with low fees
  • Insured custodial storage for institutional investors
  • Educational resources for new crypto users

Coinbase aims to be the most trusted brand in the crypto space by focusing on security, compliance, and ease of use. They have over 98 million verified users and processes over $145 billion in trading volume every quarter.

Pros of Keeping Crypto on Coinbase

Here are some of the major benefits of storing cryptocurrency on Coinbase:

Convenient and Easy to Use

Coinbase has a clean, easy to use interface on both mobile and desktop. Buying, selling, sending, and receiving crypto is designed to be simple for newcomers. Their educational resources help users understand crypto and get started.

Secure Storage

Coinbase utilizes industry-leading security measures like 2-factor authentication, biometrics, and encrypted storage to keep funds safe. Only 2% of funds are held online for liquidity, while 98% are kept in cold storage offline. Coinbase is insured and has not had a major security breach.

Compliance and Insurance

As a regulated company that complies with applicable laws, Coinbase provides a level of trust and legitimacy that unregulated exchanges don’t. U.S. customer funds are insured up to $250,000 by the FDIC.

Supported by Major Institutions

Backing by trusted investors like Andreessen Horowitz, Union Square Ventures, and the New York Stock Exchange gives Coinbase credibility. Top institutional investors also trust Coinbase with over $180 billion in assets under custody.

Wide Selection of Cryptos

Coinbase supports over 100 different cryptocurrencies including all the major ones like Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Solana. This makes it easy to trade into altcoins.

Liquidity and Staking Rewards

Keeping funds on Coinbase allows easy liquidity to trade or withdraw at any time. Certain assets also generate staking rewards, allowing users to passively earn crypto simply by holding it on Coinbase.

Cons of Keeping Crypto on Coinbase

However, there are also some downsides with leaving cryptocurrency on the Coinbase platform:

You Don’t Control the Private Keys

When you keep crypto on Coinbase, you don’t actually hold the private keys that control the funds – Coinbase does. This means you must trust them to give you access to your crypto when needed.

Susceptible to Outages

If Coinbase has an outage, you may be unable to access or trade your funds. This happened on several occasions in 2022 when traffic surged during market volatility.

Target for Hackers

As a major centralized exchange, Coinbase is a ripe target for hackers and attackers. Users must trust their security measures will not be breached.

Limits and Bans

Coinbase can freeze accounts and block withdrawals if they suspect illicit activity. They have banned accounts before, leaving users unable to access funds.

Pays Less than Holding Yourself

The rewards from staking and other benefits may be lower than what can be earned from holding crypto independently in a wallet.

Higher Fees than Decentralized Exchanges

Using Coinbase to trade and convert cryptocurrencies can incur higher fees compared to decentralized exchanges.

What is a Crypto Wallet?

A cryptocurrency wallet is a software program or physical device that allows users to store, send, and receive different cryptocurrencies. Unlike keeping crypto on an exchange like Coinbase, having a wallet means you fully control the private keys to your cryptocurrency funds.

There are several different types of crypto wallets:

Software Wallets

These are software applications that can be installed on mobile or desktop devices to manage crypto private keys. Examples include Exodus, MetaMask and Coinbase Wallet.

Hardware Wallets

These are physical devices like the Ledger Nano X and Trezor Model T that store private keys offline for security. Hardware wallets plug into computers via USB.

Paper Wallets

Paper wallets are crypto private keys printed physically on paper. This is one of the most secure forms of cold storage wallets if done properly.

Custodial Wallets

Hosted wallets provided by exchanges fall into this category. The exchange controls the actual private keys so users must trust them.

With a non-custodial wallet where you control the keys, the phrase “not your keys, not your coins” sums up the philosophy. If you don’t have the keys, you don’t fully control the crypto.

Pros of Crypto Wallets

Below are some key benefits of using a cryptocurrency wallet versus keeping assets on an exchange:

You Control the Private Keys

Having the private keys in your possession gives you full, independent control over the crypto. You don’t have to worry about an exchange restricting access.

More Secure from Hacks

Hardware wallets in particular keep private keys offline so they are virtually impossible to hack remotely. This security is far greater than any exchange.

Better Privacy

Wallets don’t require personal information to set up, allowing for greater anonymity. Coinbase requires ID verification and monitors transactions.

Avoid Exchange Limits and Bans

With your own wallet, you don’t have to worry about exchange transaction limits or having accounts arbitrarily restricted.

More Flexibility and Customization

Wallets allow for advanced management options like setting custom fees and gas prices. You can also integrate DeFi apps to unlock additional functionality.

Participate in New Crypto Launches

You can use wallets to acquire new cryptocurrency projects directly during launches before they list on exchanges.

Access Decentralized Apps (dApps)

Wallets like MetaMask allow you to directly access various dApps built on Ethereum, Polygon, BNB Chain and more.

Cons of Crypto Wallets

There are also some potential downsides to be aware of when it comes to crypto wallets:

You are Responsible for Security

With great power comes great responsibility. If you lose your private keys or get hacked, you could lose access to your funds permanently with no way to recover.

Steeper Learning Curve

It takes more time and effort to understand how to properly use crypto wallets compared to simple exchange accounts. Mistakes can also lead to lost funds.

No Insurance Protection

Unlike Coinbase and other regulated exchanges, wallet funds are generally uninsured. Users have to self-insure.

No Staking or Lending

Holding crypto in a wallet does not generate staking rewards or allow lending out for yield. You have to actively manage assets.

Less Liquidity and Access

Funds may take longer to transfer between wallets than on an exchange. There is also no fiat offramp directly to cash out.

Should I Keep Crypto on Coinbase or in a Wallet?

So should you keep your cryptocurrency holdings on a platform like Coinbase or move them into a dedicated crypto wallet? Here are some guidelines to consider:

Keep Small Amounts on Coinbase

For smaller crypto holdings under $1,000, keeping funds on a reputable exchange like Coinbase is reasonable. Just be aware of the risks.

Large Holdings Should Use a Hardware Wallet

Once your crypto assets grow above several thousand dollars or more, it makes sense to move them to a hardware wallet for added security. Popular options include the Ledger Nano X or Trezor Model T.

Always Withdraw to Wallet Before HOLDING Long Term

If you intend to hold significant cryptocurrency for months or years, it’s wise to withdraw to a wallet where you control the private keys yourself.

Be Cautious of Coinbase Debit Card for Privacy

While convenient, the Coinbase debit card may compromise your financial privacy since they can monitor your transactions. For privacy, use a wallet instead.

Use Stablecoins to Avoid Volatility

Stablecoins like USDC minimize volatility, making it safer to keep funds on Coinbase to earn yield. Always withdraw normal crypto though.

Conclusion

There are good reasons to keep some cryptocurrency holdings on trusted platforms like Coinbase – its convenient, easy to use, and has robust security measures in place. However, for long term storage of significant funds, utilizing a wallet where you control the private keys is recommended.

Hardware wallets like the Ledger Nano provide excellent security for minimizing risk and protecting your investment against loss. For large holdings especially, it makes sense to take asset protection into your own hands instead of relying on an intermediary like Coinbase to have full access.

Overall, a balanced approach using Coinbase for a portion of funds, and wallets for primary savings, combines the benefits of accessibility and security. This provides peace of mind knowing your crypto investment has reduced risk from hacking, theft or exchange restrictions.

Leave a Comment