Rolling Pin Bake Shop in Fitchburg (Photos, Menu, Reviews & Ratings)

Rolling Pin Bake Shop

Address: 2935 S Fish Hatchery Rd #4, Fitchburg, WI 53711

Phone: (608) 270-9611

Price: $

Menu: View Online

Rating: 4.5


What Time Does Rolling Pin Bake Shop Open?

Saturday,: 7:30AM to 2PM

Sunday,: Closed

Monday,: 7AM to 4PM

Tuesday,: 7AM to 4PM

Wednesday,: 7AM to 4PM

Thursday,: 7AM to 4PM

Friday,: 7AM to 4PM

Rolling Pin Bake Shop Directions

More Donuts In Fitchburg


Rolling Pin Bake Shop Reviews

Heather L.

I had to make a stop at the UPS Store, and on my way out I peeked into the Rolling Pin window and I’m glad I did. Such a great bakery! The baked goods are beautiful and super tasty. Madison has a lot of great bakeries but the variety at Rolling Pin impressed me. The staff was very friendly. The drink I ordered (Snickers latte) was almost too good. I will definitely stop by again!

Julie Block

Rolling Pin Bakery made our wedding cake. The entire process was quite easy. From the first meeting with staff to sample different wedding cake flavors, to designing the cake and being flexible with changes to our cake as we went along. Delivery was flawless and the cake looked wonderful and tasted delicious. So many compliments on the look and taste of the cake. I also had a last minute add on of a cheesecake because my groom loves cheesecake – best cheesecake ever! Go with Rolling Pin Bakery – you will not be disappointed. We also frequent them for breakfast and lunch and have never been disappointed. Thank you Rolling Pin Bakery!

Kathleen Clemens

We got our wedding cake and apple cider donuts for our wedding from Rolling Pin Bake Shop, and they did a wonderful job with both! Our wedding cake is exactly what we hoped for with its look and taste. They were wonderful at setting up a cake tasting as well, and it was really great to have so many options to pick from. The apple cider donuts we ordered for our wedding were also amazing. We are so happy with our wedding cake and the donuts!

Nancy Mair

Amazing menu! Including my favorite blueberry lemon curd pancakes! I was here too late for breakfast today so I had the salmon bowl. Delicious! The veggies were so fresh and local.

Barb Irvin

Stopped in for a breakfast bowl and was very pleased. The veggies were perfectly sautéed and the flavors worked well together.
The bakery offerings are extensive and there are some gluten-free options to satisfy a sweet tooth. Beautiful cupcakes, fun iced cookies and loaves of bread too. I’ll be back!

D Erb

Great dessert place, huge variety, they even have coffee and beverages with sit down areas. We had a mint brownie and Mexican chocolate cookie that were both excellent.

Kat Thornsen

I had their cakes before and was super impressed with the quality and taste. Also so many options!

I ordered traditional-sized cakes for our small backyard wedding a few months in advance. They followed up with me when the time got closer on how I wanted them to look. They were tasty and beautiful- So glad we went with them.

Lauren P

They’re not only amazing with their cookies, bread, and pastries, but breakfast and lunch are great as well. Their rosemary and olive oil bread is SO GOOD.

Cindy Will

Anna did a great job on my son’s Groom cake. It was extremely detailed. The death by chocolate was delicious. Highly recommend for all your baking needs. (Every time we stopped by to check on the details we always left with a dozen or more treats!)

Moses Altsech

I could go on and on about Rolling Pin Bake Shop’s cakes but I’ll let my photo do the talking. This was a special order, but they have tons of delicious ones ready for pick up, along with a large selection of pound cakes, cookies, and pastries. While you’re thinking of what to get, get an omelette–made to order and very tasty! Discover Rolling Pin Bake Shop; it’s well worth the drive no matter where in Dane County you may be!

More Reviews for Rolling Pin Bake Shop

More Donuts In Fitchburg

Donuts Guides