Peter Sciortino Bakery in Milwaukee (Photos, Menu, Reviews & Ratings)

Peter Sciortino Bakery

Address: 1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202

Phone: (414) 272-4623

Price: $

Menu: View Online

Rating: 4.7

Website: https://petersciortinosbakery.com/

What Time Does Peter Sciortino Bakery Open?

Saturday,: 7AM to 4PM

Sunday,: 7AM to 1PM

Monday,: Closed

Tuesday,: 7AM to 4PM

Wednesday,: 7AM to 4PM

Thursday,: 7AM to 4PM

Friday,: 7AM to 4PM

Peter Sciortino Bakery Directions

More Donuts In Milwaukee

 

Peter Sciortino Bakery Reviews

Denice Korean

Stumbled upon this place when I was exploring the neighborhood. Everything looks delicious. I got an assortment of cookies (9.95) as well as the banana split cupcake, about 5 bucks. I was a little disappointed because although it had a good flavor, it was dry. I read other reviews about this issue, as well as the response from the owners. Seems like there is no resolve about this. The creme topping that was used had a great texture and was delicious however. The cookie assortment was delicious. The texture and how it melts in your mouth will bring me back. I will try the cupcakes again, but go when the store first opens to see if there is a difference.

Chase Nelson

I finally stopped in today to try some of these delicious sweets. I ended up ordering a three layer cake and loved it. I’d love to come back.
@dietproof

Jessica Bachansingh

My FAVORITE family-owned neighborhood bakery. The cannolis are assembled fresh and are so cheap & yummy. Must visit!!

Dmitry E

First of all they blocked counters where customers could eat with some worthless merchandise as you can see on the photos. I hate when people are doing this. Looks like I need to drive home to eat my cake with coffee there, that’s ridiculous.
So, they told me that I can go to Italian place next block(which is wonderful by the way) and eat there. Here goes second, there the same cake was one dollar cheaper, and the question is why I needed to by cake in this first place.
And when I thought: “OK it is bad, but not one star bad”, I tried coffee and nearly puked – my late was made from spoiled milk which has curled. 🙂

Mona Lisa Battaglia

Customer service was courteous and kind. I ordered ahead which I love to do so pickup is easy and you get exactly what you are looking for. Expensive, but nice for a treat a few times a year. Desserts were very good. We purchased chocolate tutus, coconut cookies dipped in chocolate, eclairs, cannoli, and sfogliatelle. Dee-lish!

B Mikel

Everything is SO fresh and delicious! I enjoyed several cookies, a kolacky, almond croissant (an absolute MUST try!) and scone. I will continue to go back over and over!

Patricia Henkel

Cute Italian bakery with everything your heart needs. From breads to rolls to deli items, this place has it. Went in looking for Lobster rolls (pics below) and left with a little extra. The employees are friendly and welcoming. The prices are reasonable and of course the baked goods do not disappoint!

Janice Johnson

We live in the Northwoods but lived in Milwaukee always had your delicious cookies bread so we just finished eating all the cookies our son Brian barks brought us 2 weeks ago they by far the best grew up on Italian cookies thanks for them

Michelle thor

The cookies were amazing…the service was great the guy who helped us waited patiently. I’ve never been or never had any italian pastries before so it took a bit to decide what to get. I would come back.

Marizona S

I come here just for the nutella croissant! love this place

More Reviews for Peter Sciortino Bakery

More Donuts In Milwaukee

Donuts Guides