My Old World Bakery in Columbus (Photos, Menu, Reviews & Ratings)

My Old World Bakery

Address: 962 Demorest Rd, Columbus, OH 43204

Phone: (614) 278-8046

Price: $$

Menu: View Online

Rating: 4.3


What Time Does My Old World Bakery Open?

Saturday,: 6:30AM to 3PM

Sunday,: 7AM to 1PM

Monday,: Closed

Tuesday,: 6:30AM to 3PM

Wednesday,: 6:30AM to 3PM

Thursday,: 6:30AM to 3PM

Friday,: 6:30AM to 3PM

My Old World Bakery Directions

More Donuts In Columbus


My Old World Bakery Reviews

Katie J

Doughnut bakeries are a dime a dozen but this Bakery is something special. They sell homemade bread that is amazing and will even slice it for you. Their pastries are also amazing and the owner was so friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend

Marcia Hamilton

I ordered a 2 tier wedding anniversary cake for 165.00. Cake was so dry you needed a gallon of milk to wash it down. Not very tasty.

Kim R

The owner was lovely and everything I purchased was really yummy! I bought raspberry paczkis, donut stick, a family sized cherry danish, and cinnamon bread!

Betsy K

Great pastries. You can call a day ahead and place your order for pickup.

Kayann Hoffman

May be a little run down on the outside, but we have gone twice within one week of discovering this bakery because it is so good! Plus everything is extremely well priced. We loved the donut sticks, pecan rolls, honeycomb, and the maple peanut cinnamon roll. Definitely worth trying!

Valery Wilson

For a week i tried to get a cake made for my daughter’s 4th birthday…. I called and was told to get ahold of them through their Facebook page as well as asked when I needed the cake, which was 8 days later from when I called and was told thats plenty of time… Then on their Facebook page I only got an answer to a question every 2 days. We are new to the area and this place was recommended… unfortunately we didn’t like the first experience and won’t be trying to get anything from them again

love heart

We really enjoy the glazed fried Danish, peanut crispies,cherry turnovers,
beehives and the delicious breads always a wonderful experience we return often for more of our favorites.

Jillian Manning

Friendly small-town bakery! I ordered a few pies for my wedding, and a baby shower cake. Amazingly affordable prices and really good donuts. Love the pecan roll (when they aren’t sold out)! Some items are a little dry, so I recommend buying any items early in the day. All in all, a great little local shop.

Aaron VanHook

Our family& I really enjoy the family feel here! The staff’s warm and inviting. My kid’s love the donuts,&I can’t get enough of their homemade pies! It’s nice knowing that we’re supporting a long standing neighborhood, family shop like this! Anyone can go to a chain grocery store for just about anything, however, I love being able to take my girls here on their way to school for a job well done &know that I’m creating memories that will last. The service is faster than any chain, &it’s nice seeing the same friendly faces that lend to a wonderful start of the day!

Kimberly Mader

Husband and I went there, about 15 to 20 mins ago. Our first time. Nice small shop. Nice owner. I just tried her cinnamon roll with white icing, it was mouth watering delicious. Loved it. And it’s only 5 minutes driving from my home.

More Reviews for My Old World Bakery

More Donuts In Columbus

Donuts Guides