Is sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding healthy?

Quick Answer

Sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding can be a relatively healthy dessert option for people looking to reduce their sugar intake. However, it still contains artificial sweeteners which may have negative health effects. Overall, sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding is lower in calories and sugar than regular chocolate pudding, but it’s best consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet.

Calorie and Macronutrient Content

One serving (1/2 cup) of sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding contains:

  • 60 calories
  • 0 g fat
  • 12 g carbohydrates
  • 5 g protein

Compared to regular Jello chocolate pudding, the sugar-free version contains fewer calories and carbohydrates since it does not contain added sugar. However, the protein content is the same.

The main sweetener used in sugar-free Jello pudding is sucralose, also known as Splenda. One serving contains 3g of sucralose. This provides sweetness without significantly adding calories.

Vitamins and Minerals

Sugar-free chocolate pudding is not a significant source of vitamins and minerals. However, it provides a small amount of calcium and iron:

  • 4% DV calcium
  • 2% DV iron

Regular Jello chocolate pudding contains a bit more calcium and iron at 10% DV and 4% DV respectively.

Overall, sugar-free Jello pudding is not intended to provide much nutritional value beyond taste and texture. It’s best to get necessary vitamins and minerals from whole foods.

Artificial Sweeteners

While sugar-free chocolate pudding is lower in sugar and calories, the use of artificial sweeteners is controversial.

Sucralose has been deemed safe by health authorities. But some studies have linked it to negative effects like:

  • Altered gut bacteria
  • Interference with appetite signaling
  • Increased insulin resistance

More research is still needed on the health effects of non-nutritive sweeteners like sucralose.

Consuming artificial sweeteners in moderation as part of an overall healthy diet is likely fine for most people. But avoiding excessive amounts is recommended until more safety data is available.

Weight Loss

Sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding can be useful for weight loss diets or for people with diabetes trying to control carbohydrate and sugar intake.

By replacing high-sugar desserts with sugar-free options, people can reduce their overall calorie intake which can lead to weight loss over time.

However, keep in mind that portion control is still important. Consuming large amounts of even sugar-free pudding can stall weight loss efforts.

Here is a comparison of calorie and sugar content in common dessert servings:

Dessert Serving Size Calories Sugar (g)
Regular chocolate pudding 1/2 cup 160 16
Sugar-free chocolate pudding 1/2 cup 60 0
Chocolate ice cream 1/2 cup 240 24
Chocolate cake with frosting 1 slice 420 36

As you can see, sugar-free chocolate pudding has significantly fewer calories and sugar compared to other popular chocolate desserts.

Diabetes Management

For people with diabetes, sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding can be a good occasional treat.

It provides the sweet taste and rich texture of chocolate pudding without spiking blood sugar levels since it is free of sugar.

However, moderation is key as the artificial sweeteners may still have effects on insulin response. Consuming large amounts could affect blood sugar control.

As with any dessert, it’s best to carefully incorporate sugar-free chocolate pudding into a healthy diabetes diet containing plenty of vegetables, fruits, whole grains, lean protein, and healthy fats.


Sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding contains the following main ingredients:

  • Water
  • Modified food starch
  • Cocoa processed with alkali
  • Contains less than 2% of the following: Sodium stearoyl lactylate, salt, artificial flavor, sucralose, acesulfame potassium, colored with caramel color and beta carotene

The main ingredients provide the pudding’s rich texture and chocolate flavor.

Sucralose and acesulfame potassium are the artificial sweeteners used. Caramel color and beta carotene provide the brown color.

Overall, the ingredient list is relatively clean with no controversial additives beyond the artificial sweeteners. But as with all processed foods, fresh homemade chocolate pudding would contain more whole food ingredients.

Taste and Texture

Sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding receives good reviews for its taste and texture.

It provides the thick, creamy mouthfeel expected from chocolate pudding. The combination of sucralose and acesulfame potassium replicates the sweet taste of sugar quite closely.

However, some people detect a slightly artificial aftertaste from the sweeteners. The taste is a matter of personal preference and sensitivity to artificial sweeteners.

Additionally, chilling the pudding fully before eating improves its consistency according to reviews. Freshly made pudding right out of the package can be a bit gelatinous and gummy.


Sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding is competitively priced with other packaged pudding options. Here is a cost comparison per serving:

  • Sugar-free Jello pudding: $0.60
  • Regular Jello pudding: $0.50
  • Specialty brand sugar-free pudding: $0.75
  • Pre-made fresh pudding: $2-4

As you can see, sugar-free Jello pudding provides a budget-friendly option for packaged chocolate pudding with minimal sugar. Pre-made fresh pudding cups are pricier.

Buying the large boxes in bulk and separating into single servings can further reduce the cost per serving.


Sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding requires minimal preparation. The steps include:

1. Whisk the dry pudding mix with 2 cups cold milk until well blended.

2. Let mixture sit for 2 minutes to thicken.

3. Whisk again and divide between 4-6 individual ramekins or bowls.

4. Refrigerate a minimum of 15 minutes to set pudding.

5. Can be topped with whipped cream before serving if desired.

The total prep and cook time is only about 10 minutes plus chilling time. This makes it a quick and convenient dessert solution.

No cooking is required, unlike homemade chocolate pudding recipes. However, the convenience comes at the cost of artificial ingredients compared to homemade.


Unopened packages of sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding are shelf-stable at room temperature. Once opened, refrigerate unused dry mix.

The prepared chocolate pudding can be stored in the refrigerator in a covered container for 3-4 days.

Pudding stored for over 24 hours may develop some liquid on top but can be stirred back to the proper consistency.

For longer storage, the pudding can be frozen for 2-3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before using. The texture may become slightly grainy with freezing.

Nutritional Alternatives

For greater nutritional value, consider these alternatives to pre-packaged sugar-free pudding:

  • Chia seed chocolate pudding – Made with avocado, cacao powder, chia seeds, milk of choice. Provides healthy fats, fiber, and minerals.
  • Silken tofu chocolate pudding – Blend together silken tofu, cacao powder, banana, vanilla. Provides protein, potassium, and magnesium.
  • Cottage cheese chocolate pudding – Mix together cottage cheese, cocoa powder, peanut butter, and milk. Offers a protein boost.
  • Chocolate chia seed pudding – Made with Greek yogurt for protein, chia seeds for fiber and omega-3s.
  • Avocado chocolate pudding – Combines avocado, cocoa powder, maple syrup for healthy fats and fiber.

These options provide more whole food nutrients and less processed ingredients. However, they require a bit more hands-on prep time compared to instant pudding mix.

Potential Downsides

Some potential downsides of sugar-free chocolate pudding include:

  • Contains artificial sweeteners which may negatively impact gut bacteria and metabolism
  • Highly processed and not a whole food
  • Higher cost than homemade pudding
  • Higher carbs than some low-carb dessert options
  • Requires restraint for portion control
  • May increase cravings for sweet foods
  • Not suitable for people following paleo, vegan, or gluten-free diets

While sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding can be an occasional healthier treat, it should not be a daily indulgence. Over-consumption may counteract potential benefits.


Sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding earns an average 4 out of 5 star rating online. Here’s a sample of positive and negative reviews:


  • “Tastes almost exactly like the regular version! Can’t even tell it’s sugar-free.”
  • “Thick and creamy texture just like I remember with Jello pudding as a kid.”
  • “The perfect portion control dessert for me as I’m trying to watch my sugar.”
  • “My husband is diabetic and loves that he can enjoy chocolate pudding again with the sugar-free version.”


  • “You can definitely taste the artificial sweetener aftertaste.”
  • “Not as smooth as I expected, a bit grainy.”
  • “More liquid separates than I remember with the regular pudding.”
  • “Contains artificial colors and sweeteners so not really a healthy product in my opinion.”

As with any food product, personal taste preferences and diet approach impact opinions on sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding.


Overall, sugar-free Jello chocolate pudding can be a relatively healthy dessert choice in moderation, especially for people limiting sugar for weight loss or diabetes management.

However, it still contains artificial ingredients and minimal whole food nutrition. Consuming chocolate pudding made from natural ingredients may be healthier for some.

Sugar-free chocolate pudding works best as an occasional treat in the context of a balanced diet focused on wholesome foods the majority of the time. Carefully controlling portions is important to avoid over-consumption.

It offers an easy lower-sugar dessert option at a reasonable price point for most budgets. But those following paleo, vegan, or gluten-free diets will want to avoid it.

While not the most nutritious choice, sugar-free chocolate pudding can be a decent better-for-you dessert pick in small amounts. But plenty of healthier whole food pudding alternatives can also suit a sweet craving.

Leave a Comment