Is soft serve ice cream considered dairy?

Soft serve ice cream is a popular frozen dessert that can be found in ice cream shops, fast food restaurants, theme parks, and more. It’s known for its smooth, creamy texture and ability to be served right out of the machine in a signature swirl. But with its main ingredients being milk and cream, an important question arises – is soft serve actually considered a dairy product?

What is soft serve ice cream?

Soft serve ice cream is made with similar ingredients to regular ice cream, but has a lighter consistency enabled by air being whipped into the mixture as it freezes. The basic ingredients in soft serve are milk, cream, sugar, and stabilizing additives like guar gum or cellulose gum. It contains at least 10% milkfat, though usually closer to 11-12%. The mixture is churned and aerated at very cold temperatures, then dispensed directly from a soft serve machine into cones or cups. This gives it a characteristically smooth, almost mousse-like texture.

Why do people question if it’s dairy?

There are a few reasons why soft serve’s dairy status is sometimes called into question:

– It lacks the rich, creamy mouthfeel of premium ice creams – Soft serve has more air incorporated into it, giving it a lighter texture that some don’t associate with full-fat dairy products.

– Flavor variations – Plain soft serve tastes quite milky, but popular flavorings like chocolate or strawberry can overpower the dairy flavor. This leads some to think it’s made from water frozen with artificial flavors and thickening agents.

– Allergies or lactose intolerance – Those who must avoid dairy for medical reasons will often be told soft serve is “dairy-free”, likely due to the presence of vegetable gums and the potential for cross-contamination with ingredients like nuts in shops that use them.

– Marketing as non-dairy – A small number of soft serve products using non-dairy milk substitutes like coconut or almond milk are marketed as “non-dairy” or “dairy-free”. This leads some to assume no soft serve contains milk products.

Nutritional profile

Looking at the nutritional information of soft serve ice cream quickly confirms its status as a dairy food:

Nutrition Facts per 1/2 cup serving of vanilla soft serve
Calories 140
Fat 7g
Saturated Fat 4.5g
Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 25mg
Sodium 65mg
Carbohydrates 18g
Dietary Fiber 0g
Sugars 16g
Protein 3g
Calcium 85mg
Vitamin A 170IU

With 10g of fat per serving, 25mg of cholesterol, and high calcium content, it’s clear that soft serve is a product derived from dairy milk and cream. The fat percentages and vitamin levels match what you would expect from a food containing significant amounts of milkfat.

Ingredients

Checking the ingredients list of major soft serve brands confirms the presence of dairy products:

– McDonald’s soft serve contains milkfat and nonfat milk as its first two ingredients.

– Dairy Queen’s soft serve lists milk, cream, and milk protein concentrate in its vanilla recipe.

– Carvel’s soft serve ingredients include milk, sweet cream, and sweetened condensed skim milk.

– Dippin’ Dots liquid ice cream base contains milkfat, whey, and casein (milk proteins).

Non-dairy soft serve made with alternate milks will be specifically labeled as such, and list ingredients like coconut cream, soy milk, rice milk, or almond milk rather than dairy derivatives. Products described only as “soft serve” or “frozen dairy dessert” are predominantly dairy-based.

Specific components that make it dairy

Looking closer at soft serve’s ingredients, several key components confirm its dairy identity:

Milkfat

Milkfat gives dairy products their rich taste and creamy texture. Soft serve contains at least 10% milkfat, usually from whole milk or cream. Without milkfat, it would lack the smooth, velvety consistency people expect from soft serve.

Milk proteins

Milk naturally contains two main proteins, casein and whey. These are present in soft serve, and help contribute to its structure and body. Whey proteins in particular help form smaller ice crystals for a smoother frozen product.

Lactose

The milk sugar lactose is present in most soft serve products. Lactose helps ice cream stay scoopable straight from the freezer by lowering the freezing point. Those with lactose intolerance can have gastrointestinal issues after eating soft serve if it contains lactose.

Emulsifiers

Emulsifiers are added to help soft serve remain smooth and resist iciness. Common ones used include polysorbate 80 and mono- and diglycerides – both derived from dairy fats.

Regulatory standards for frozen desserts

Soft serve is classified and regulated as a frozen dairy product by food authorities like the FDA and USDA. Anything marketed as “soft serve ice cream” must adhere to standards including:

– Minimum 10% milkfat content

– Maximum overrun (incorporation of air) of 100%

– Containing no more than 55% total air by volume

Meeting these specifications guarantees soft serve fundamentally consists of a significant amount of dairy components like milkfat, milk proteins, and lactose.

Reasons some claim it’s non-dairy

Despite its predominately dairy-based formulation, some still insist soft serve contains no dairy at all. Here are some reasons for those claims:

Lack of awareness

Many people genuinely don’t realize soft serve is a dairy food, instead assuming the texture comes from vegetable gums or coconut oil. They may have difficulty believing its creamy texture can come primarily from milkfat.

Cross-contamination concerns

Those with severe dairy allergies are sometimes told to avoid soft serve due to potential cross-contamination with milk residues on equipment and utensils in stores that also handle dairy products.

Non-dairy substitutes

There are true non-dairy soft serve products made from alternate milks that are dairy-free. However, plain “soft serve” is understood to be dairy-based unless otherwise specified.

Nutrition misconceptions

Some assume soft serve has less fat or protein than ice cream, not realizing it’s merely aerated more. In fact, legally it cannot contain less than 10% milkfat. The protein and calcium levels are similar to ice cream.

Should those avoiding dairy have soft serve?

For most with lactose intolerance or milk allergies, soft serve made with regular dairy ingredients is not recommended, for the following reasons:

Contains lactose

Almost all dairy-based soft serve includes lactose, the milk sugar that is difficult to digest for the lactose intolerant. Even small amounts of lactose can cause gas, bloating, or diarrhea.

Risk of allergic reaction

Those with a confirmed milk allergy must avoid all milk proteins like casein and whey. Even tiny residues present a risk of anaphylaxis or other adverse reactions.

Shared equipment issues

Dairy-based soft serve is commonly dispensed from the same machines used to prepare shakes, sundaes, or other milk-containing desserts. This introduces potential for allergen cross-contamination.

Not normally certified allergen-free

Soft serve shops generally don’t have dedicated equipment confirmed to be allergen-free. Those with severe dairy allergies must be very cautious when consuming.

Are there any vegan soft serves?

While most soft serve contains dairy ingredients, there are some alternative “soft serve” options appropriate for vegans:

Coconut milk-based

Some shops use canned coconut milk or coconut cream as the base for their soft serve. This gives a rich texture without dairy.

Soy milk-based

Soy milk can be used to produce a non-dairy soft serve. Soy contains vegetable proteins that help mimic the texture of dairy.

Frozen banana “nice” cream

Blending frozen bananas makes a creamy soft serve alternative. Cocoa powder or other flavors are often added. This contains no dairy or other animal products.

Aquafaba soft serve

The liquid from canned chickpeas can be whipped into soft peaks and frozen, creating an incredibly creamy vegan soft serve.

Can it be lactose-free?

While most soft serve has lactose, a few options exist for those desiring lactose-free soft serve:

Lactose-free milk

Using lactose-free milk eliminates much of the lactose otherwise contributed by the dairy components. This prevents issues for the lactose intolerant.

Lactase enzyme

Some brands add the lactase enzyme to break down lactose into simpler sugars before freezing. This helps minimize lactose content.

Soy soft serve

As a plant-based alternative, soft serve made from soy milk is naturally lactose-free, as soy contains no lactose.

Coconut soft serve

Coconut cream soft serve is lactose-free for those wanting a dairy-free, low-lactose option.

Ways to tell if soft serve contains dairy

If you need to know for sure whether a soft serve contains dairy or not, here are some tips:

Check ingredient label

Scan the ingredient list for milk, cream, milk proteins, or other dairy derivatives. If non-dairy, it will list alternate milks instead.

Ask staff directly

Don’t hesitate to ask the staff whether their soft serve contains milk/dairy or is non-dairy. Reputable shops should know exactly what’s in their product.

Look for allergen warnings

If the shop has an allergen notice stating the product “contains milk”, that’s a clear sign it’s dairy-based.

Try a small sample first

If you need to test whether dairy soft serve would affect you, start with just a tiny bite and wait to observe for any reactions before consuming more.

Stick to known dairy-free brands

Search for shops that advertise non-dairy soft serve made with coconut milk, soy, etc. This eliminates the uncertainty over ingredients.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while soft serve ice cream has a lighter texture than many frozen desserts, it still very much contains dairy ingredients like milkfat, milk proteins, and lactose in traditional recipes. Some alternative non-dairy versions do exist, but plain “soft serve” is nearly always dairy-based according to food labeling regulations and its nutritional profile. The exception would be brands that specifically advertise plant-based or dairy-free formulations. Still, those with dairy allergies or intolerance should exercise caution and carefully determine the ingredients first before consuming. When in doubt, soft serve is generally safest to consider a product containing milk and to avoid accordingly if required for dietary reasons.

Leave a Comment