Is sherbet good for a diet?

Sherbet is a frozen dessert that is made with sweetened fruit juice, milk or cream, and sometimes egg whites. It has a creamy, icy texture that is similar to sorbet, but contains milk or cream which gives it a richer taste and smoother consistency.

Sherbet is lower in fat and calories compared to ice cream, but higher in sugar. This leads many people to wonder – is sherbet a good option for dieting or weight loss? Or is the high sugar content too much of a problem?

Is sherbet lower in calories than ice cream?

Yes, sherbet is significantly lower in calories and fat than ice cream. Here is a calorie comparison of sherbet versus ice cream (per 1/2 cup serving):

Food Calories Fat (g)
Sherbet 140 2
Vanilla ice cream 137 7
Chocolate ice cream 220 12

As you can see, sherbet contains about half the calories and 75% less fat as ice cream. The biggest difference is the fat content – ice cream gets a large number of calories from fat, while sherbet’s calories come mostly from sugar.

So if you are counting calories or fat grams, sherbet is clearly the better choice over ice cream. But the higher sugar content means it may not be ideal for all diets.

Is the sugar content in sherbet bad for diets?

Sherbet does contain more sugar than ice cream. A 1/2 cup serving may have 20-30 grams of sugar, coming from the fruit juice and added sugar.

This level of sugar is about the maximum daily amount recommended for women by health authorities. For men, it is slightly less than the 36 gram/day limit.

So while not extremely high in sugar, sherbet certainly contains a lot of sugar in a small serving. The sugar adds calories and can cause blood sugar spikes. This may be a concern for people with diabetes or prediabetes.

For most healthy people on a weight loss diet, sherbet in moderation is fine. But it would be easy to overdo it and consume excessive sugar and calories from sherbet and other sweets.

Some tips:
– Stick to a small portion of sherbet, such as 1/2 cup. Avoid mega-sized servings.
– Have it as an occasional treat, not every day. The fruits in sherbet do provide nutrition, but the high sugar content can add up.
– Look for sherbet with less added sugar, and focus on fruit-based flavors like raspberry, lemon, or orange.
– Avoid adding sugary toppings like chocolate sauce or crushed candy, which pile on even more sugar.

How does sherbet impact blood sugar levels?

Sherbet’s high sugar content means it will cause more rapid blood sugar and insulin spikes compared to lower-sugar frozen desserts.

For most people, an occasional small serving of sherbet won’t have too dramatic of an effect. But for diabetics or prediabetics, the sugar and carb content is a real concern.

Here is how 1/2 cup of some popular sherbets impacts blood sugar levels:

Sherbet Carbs (g) Sugar (g)
Orange sherbet 26 23
Raspberry sherbet 33 23
Rainbow sherbet 33 27

The carbohydrate content is mostly from sugar. This means sherbet will cause a rapid spike in blood glucose. The crash after the spike may also lead to increased hunger and cravings.

People with diabetes need to be careful about counting carbs from sherbet and account for it in their meal plan. Anyone with prediabetes or insulin resistance should also use caution and eat sherbet sparingly.

However, sherbet may not spike blood sugar quite as severely as ice cream or chocolate-based frozen desserts. The fruit juice provides some micronutrients and the lactose in the milk product means the sugar is absorbed a bit more slowly than pure sucrose. But overall, sherbet should still be seen as a high glycemic food.

Is sherbet allowed on low-carb or keto diets?

Low-carb and ketogenic diets aim to keep daily carb intake very low, usually under 50 grams per day. Some go as low as 20-30 grams for maximum ketosis.

On these types of diets, sherbet would definitely be off limits, as just 1 serving may provide over 20 grams of carbs. Even the “low-carb” or “no sugar added” sherbet options contain too many carbs to fit these diets.

People following a standard low-carb diet can occasionally work in a small amount of sherbet if they account for the carbs. But those doing keto or very low-carb plans should avoid sherbet completely.

The high sugar content means it will disrupt ketosis by spiking blood glucose and insulin. Plus, the calories from sugar provide immediate energy, while keto depends on burning fats.

What about sugar-free sherbet?

There are sugar-free and low-carb sherbet options made with alternative sweeteners like:

– Aspartame
– Acesulfame potassium
– Sucralose
– Stevia
– Monk fruit

These provide the sherbet taste with minimal impact on blood sugar. By replacing sugar with non-nutritive sweeteners, the carb count is drastically reduced. A serving may have just 5-10 grams of carbs instead of 25-30 grams.

This makes sugar-free sherbet an option for low-carb or diabetic diets. However, keep in mind that artificial sweeteners are controversial and may have unintended effects in some people.

The safety of sugar substitutes is still being debated, though major health authorities consider them safe in moderation. As with any processed food, sugar-free sherbet shouldn’t be eaten in excess.

How many calories in popular sherbet flavors?

Calories in sherbet range from about 130-180 per 1/2 cup serving. Here’s a look at calories for some popular sherbet flavors:

Sherbet Flavor Calories
Orange 140
Raspberry 130
Lime 150
Rainbow 160
Pineapple 180

As you can see, calorie differences between flavors are modest. What really differs is the sugar content. Check labels and choose flavors made with less added sugar when possible.

In general, fruit sherbets are preferable to chocolate-coated or candy-filled options. Skip anything with cookies, cake pieces, or swirls of sugary sauces which can pile on calories.

What about creamy vs. sorbet texture?

Sherbet has a smoother, creamier mouthfeel than sorbet. This comes from the milk or cream used in the recipe.

Sorbet relies only on fruit juice, sugar, and water to create its signature light and icy texture. Sherbet also contains dairy ingredients like:

– Milk
– Cream
– Buttermilk
– Yogurt
– Egg whites

This gives it a richer, more indulgent taste and feel on the tongue. However, the dairy does add a tiny amount of fat and calories compared to sorbet.

Here is a calorie comparison of similar fruit flavors:

Frozen Dessert Calories
Orange sherbet (1/2 cup) 140
Orange sorbet (1/2 cup) 130

The differences are minor, but sorbet does edge out sherbet when counting every calorie. For most diets, opting for sorbet over sherbet won’t make a huge impact. But on a ketogenic diet, sorbet is preferable due to being lower in carbs and non-dairy.

Should you make your own sherbet at home?

Making homemade sherbet isn’t too difficult, and allows you to control the ingredients. You can make it lower sugar and skip any artificial sweeteners or preservatives.

Homemade sherbet recipes generally call for:

– Fruit puree from fresh or frozen fruit
– Milk, cream, or yogurt
– Sweetener like honey, maple syrup, or stevia
– Lemon juice or zest for flavoring
– Pinch of salt

The ingredients are blended, then chilled and churned in an ice cream maker for 20-30 minutes. Without an appliance, you can periodically stir a sherbet mixture in the freezer as it solidifies.

Benefits of homemade:

– Less added sugar than store-bought
– No preservatives or stabilizers
– Control over flavors and mix-ins
– Fun activity for kids

Downsides:

– More time consuming
– Requires appliances like a blender and ice cream maker
– Has to be eaten shortly after making

What about sherbet vs. frozen yogurt or gelato?

Frozen yogurt and gelato are other popular frozen desserts. How do they compare to sherbet for dieting?

Here is a nutrition comparison:

Dessert Calories Fat Carbs Protein
Sherbet (1/2 cup) 140 2g 33g 2g
Frozen yogurt (1/2 cup) 100-200 2-7g 17-30g 4-8g
Gelato (1/2 cup) 140-170 5-11g 17-26g 3-7g

As you can see, frozen yogurt and gelato can vary more widely in calories and macros. In general:

– Sherbet is highest in sugar and carbs
– Gelato is moderate in fat, but lower in sugar than sherbet
– Frozen yogurt is lowest in fat and calories

So frozen yogurt may be the best choice if you are strictly monitoring calories and fat. Gelato offers a creamier texture with less sugar spike than sherbet. But overall, the differences are small when sticking to a 1/2 cup portion.

Should you buy sherbet when it’s on sale?

If sherbet is marked down in price at the grocery store, should you stock up? Here are some tips on buying sherbet on sale:

– Check the expiration date and only buy what you’ll use in time. Sherbet stays fresh for 1-2 months in the freezer before getting icy crystals.

– Stick to reasonable portions and don’t go overboard just because it’s cheap. Portion control is still important.

– Pick flavors you enjoy. Just because it’s on sale doesn’t mean you have to buy flavors you don’t love.

– Compare brands and nutrition facts. The sale brand may not always be the best value.

– Buy extra to have on hand for guests or a fun weekend treat. Just plan ahead so it doesn’t go to waste.

– Avoid buying too much if you tend to overindulge in sweets. Out of sight, out of mind.

Overall, it’s fine to pick up some extra tubs of sherbet when the price drops. But still focus on your diet goals and only buy what you’ll reasonably use within a month or two.

Sherbet nutrition facts

Here are some key nutrition facts per 1/2 cup serving of sherbet:

– Calories: 130-180
– Fat: 1-3g
– Saturated fat: 1-2g
– Trans fat: 0g
– Carbs: 26-33g
– Fiber: 0-1g
– Sugar: 20-30g
– Added sugar: 15-25g
– Protein: 1-3g

As you can see, sherbet is high in sugar, moderate in carbs, and low in fat and protein. The carb count comes almost entirely from sugar.

Vitamin and mineral content is minimal other than small amounts of calcium and vitamin C. Any nutritional benefits come mainly from fruit flavors like berry or citrus. Overall, sherbet is considered more of a sugary treat than a nutrition powerhouse!

Is sherbet gluten free?

Most sherbet is gluten-free, which is good news for anyone following a gluten-free diet due to celiac disease or gluten intolerance.

Always check the ingredients list to confirm there are no sources of gluten like wheat, barley, rye or malt. Most brands of sherbet simply contain fruit, sugar, milk products, and natural flavors.

Some sherbets may contain cookies or cake pieces that could add gluten. And certain flavors like chocolate or cookie dough may have sources of gluten in mix-ins.

So read labels carefully and look for a “gluten-free” confirmation on the packaging when possible. Popular brands that offer gluten-free sherbet include:

– Turkey Hill
– Talenti
– Haagen-Dazs
– Breyers
– Prairie Farms
– Ciao Bella

Making your own sherbet at home is another way to control the ingredients and avoid any gluten. Overall, sherbet can be enjoyed worry-free by most people avoiding gluten – just check labels to verify.

Does sherbet have lactose?

Sherbet is not naturally lactose-free, as it contains milk products like cream or skim milk. The amount of lactose can vary by brand.

Some sherbets are higher in lactose due to containing:

– Milk or cream as the main ingredient
– Milk powder
– Condensed or evaporated milk
– Ice cream or custard mix

Brands that use milk alternatives like coconut or almond milk would be lower in lactose. Also, yogurt or kefir as an ingredient contains less lactose than straight milk.

If you are lactose intolerant, sticking to sorbet would avoid lactose completely. Or look for “lactose-free” labeled sherbets made with lactose-reduced milk. Eating sherbet in small portions and taking lactase enzyme can also help minimize digestive issues.

Overall, those with severe lactose intolerance will likely want to choose alternatives to standard milk-based sherbet. But many people can enjoy it in moderation.

Conclusion

Sherbet can be an appropriate occasional treat for most healthy diets, provided portion sizes are controlled. While relatively high in sugar, it is much lower in fat and calories than ice cream or other frozen desserts.

The fruit flavors provide vitamin C, and dairy ingredients like milk and yogurt offer a creamy, smooth texture. Just watch your servings to keep sugar and calories reasonable.

Those on keto or very low-carb diets should avoid sherbet, along with diabetics and anyone with blood sugar regulation issues. As a fruit-juice-based frozen dessert, sherbet has an inherently high glycemic index.

Overall, enjoy sherbet in moderation as part of a balanced diet, and opt for fruit-based flavors over candy or cookie variations. Pair it with fresh fruit or nuts to add more nutrition without excess calories.

Leave a Comment