Is it worth getting hip surgery?

Quick Summary

Hip surgery can be a good option for treating severe hip pain and restoring mobility if more conservative treatments like physical therapy have failed. The most common hip surgeries are total hip replacement, hip resurfacing, and hip arthroscopy. Recovery time is around 3-6 months. Hip surgery costs between $20,000-$50,000 in the U.S. without insurance. Pros of hip surgery include pain relief, improved mobility, and better quality of life. Cons include risks of complications like infection, stiff joints, dislocated hip, and blood clots. Alternatives like pain medications, steroid injections, weight loss, and physical therapy may help avoid surgery. Overall, for suitable candidates, hip surgery can be worth it to regain mobility and improve daily function. Discuss options thoroughly with your orthopedic surgeon.

What are the common types of hip surgery?

There are several types of hip surgery aimed at relieving pain and improving function:

Total hip replacement – This is the most common hip surgery, with over 300,000 procedures annually in the U.S. It involves removing damaged cartilage and bone from the hip joint and implanting prosthetic components. The femoral head (ball) and acetabulum (socket) are replaced with metal, plastic or ceramic prosthetics to recreate the joint. Recovery takes around 3-6 months.

Hip resurfacing – This is a bone-conserving alternative to hip replacement. Instead of removing the femoral head completely, it is trimmed and capped with a metal covering. The damaged acetabulum is also fitted with a metal implant. This procedure preserves more bone and is generally suited for younger, active patients.

Hip arthroscopy – This minimally invasive keyhole surgery is done to repair torn cartilage and labral tears with small incisions and an arthroscope (camera). It has a quicker recovery but is not suitable for arthritis.

Open reduction internal fixation – This surgery realigns bone fragments and stabilizes them with plates, rods, screws or pins if the hip is fractured.

Hip osteotomy – For hip dysplasia or arthritis limited to one side of the joint, this surgery reshapes and reorients the bone to redistribute weight evenly across the hip.

The type of hip surgery depends on the underlying condition, extent of damage, and the patient’s age, activity levels and bone quality.

What is recovery and rehabilitation like after hip surgery?

The recovery and rehabilitation process after a hip replacement or other hip surgery aims to safely restore mobility while allowing the tissue to heal. Here are some general timelines and info on what to expect:

Hospital stay – For hip replacements, hospital stays are typically 1-3 days on average. Some shorter stay hip replacements are done as outpatient procedures.

Early recovery (0-6 weeks) – The first 6 weeks focus on wound care, managing pain and swelling, preventing complications like blood clots and infections, and regaining initial mobility with support. Patients use ambulation aids like walkers or crutches and undergo physical therapy. Activities are restricted to protect the new hip joint while the soft tissues heal and gain strength.

Intermediate recovery (6 weeks – 3 months) – Physical therapy continues to improve strength, flexibility and gait. Crutches are usually no longer needed but may be used for stability in some cases. Light activities like short walks, stationary biking, swimming or golf may be cleared after 12 weeks depending on the patient’s progress.

Late recovery (3 – 6 months) – Gradual return to more normal function and activities around 3-6 months, with lifting restrictions around 10-15 lbs early on and up to 50 lbs after 6 months. Continued exercise and physical therapy improves endurance, muscle strength and balance. Full recovery takes time and work.

With rigorous adherence to rehabilitation, most patients can expect to return to light activities after 1-3 months and more strenuous work and sports after around 6 months. Timelines vary by individual factors like age, pre-surgery condition, bone health, complications, and more. Patience is key.

What are the pros and cons of hip surgery?

Hip surgery has both potential benefits and drawbacks to weigh:

Pros:

  • Relieves chronic hip pain and stiffness
  • Restores range of motion and mobility
  • Enables return to normal daily activities
  • Improves overall quality of life
  • Delays need for total hip replacement in younger patients (for hip arthroscopy or resurfacing)

Cons:

  • Significant surgical risks including infections, blood clots, hip dislocation, nerve damage, fracture
  • Possibility of hip implant failure or loosening requiring revision surgery
  • Intensive rehabilitation protocol with lengthy recovery period
  • Restrictions on activities to protect hip joint for 6+ months
  • High medical costs often exceeding $20,000-$50,000

The benefits tend to outweigh the risks and limitations for most patients with severe hip arthritis, fractures or injuries who have failed more conservative therapies. Discuss your specific circumstances thoroughly with an orthopedic surgeon.

What are the alternatives to hip surgery?

There are some less invasive options to consider before resorting to hip surgery:

  • Medications – Anti-inflammatory drugs, cortisone injections, nerve blocks, analgesics
  • Physical therapy – Stretching, strengthening exercises, manual therapy, modalities like heat/ice treatment
  • Weight loss – For overweight patients, losing extra pounds reduces joint stress
  • Assistive devices – Canes, walkers, raised toilet seats, grab bars, shoe inserts
  • Alternative therapies – Acupuncture, massage, yoga, chiropractic
  • Lifestyle modification – Activity pacing, joint protection techniques, balance exercises

Maximizing these conservative treatments is often the first step. They may help manage symptoms in early stages of arthritis and delay the need for surgery. But if they fail to provide adequate pain relief or function, hip surgery may be the best option.

How much does hip surgery cost?

Hip replacement surgery is expensive. Here’s an overview of the typical costs in the United States without insurance:

  • Total hip replacement surgery: $35,000-$52,500
  • Hip resurfacing surgery: $28,000-$45,000
  • Hip arthroscopy: $20,000-$30,000
  • Hospital and anesthesia fees: $15,000-$20,000
  • Physical therapy: $2,000-$5,000

So the total costs can range from $20,000 for a hip scope up to $75,000 for a total replacement including physical therapy.

Many insurance plans cover a portion of these costs, but out-of-pocket expenses can still be thousands. Medicare reimbursement rates are around $16,000 for hospitals and $1,500 for surgeons. Options to lower surgical costs include traveling abroad for treatment or choosing an outpatient center rather than hospital.

How long does it take to recover after hip surgery?

The overall hip surgery recovery timeline is around 3-6 months but occurs in phases:

Early (0-6 weeks) – The initial recovery focuses on healing incisions, managing pain and swelling, restoring some mobility, and preventing complications. Crutches are needed for 4-6 weeks and activities are restricted.

Intermediate (6 weeks – 3 months) – Crutches are discontinued and physical therapy increases strength and function. Light daily activities can resume around 8-12 weeks post-op.

Late (3-6 months) – Gradual return to more normal function with increased endurance and activities. Lifting limits are eased over time. Full recovery takes at least 6 months.

Some key timeframes:

  • Sitting: Within days of surgery
  • Driving: 4-6 weeks
  • Walking without support: 6 weeks
  • Climbing stairs: 6-8 weeks
  • Jogging: About 3 months
  • Golfing or swimming: 3 months
  • Lifting 50 lbs: 6 months
  • High-impact sports: 8-12 months

Recovery is faster with hip arthroscopy vs. total hip replacement. But all hip surgery requires an extended rehab period of around 3-6 months before resuming normal activities.

Who performs hip surgery?

Orthopedic surgeons who specialize in hip procedures most often perform hip replacement and arthroscopic surgeries. Qualifications to look for include:

– Board certification in orthopedic surgery
– Fellowship training in hip and knee surgery or sports medicine
– Extensive experience performing hip procedures
– Membership in orthopedic associations
– Staff privileges at accredited surgical hospitals
– Active involvement in continuing education

When choosing a surgeon:
– Check their credentials and hospital affiliations
– Review success rates, complication rates, and patient satisfaction
– Meet for a consultation to discuss your condition and surgical options
– Make sure you feel comfortable with their experience and approach

Select an experienced hip surgeon you trust to maximize your chances of a successful procedure and smooth recovery.

How long does a hip replacement last?

Modern hip replacements typically last 15-20 years on average before requiring replacement, known as a revision surgery. Some key factors affecting longevity include:

Age – Hip implants in younger patients tend to wear out sooner. Replacements in patients under 50 may last 10-15 years. Those in patients over 65 may last 20-30 years.

Implant materials – Metal-on-plastic implants have shorter lifespans on average while ceramic-on-ceramic can last 25+ years. Highly crosslinked plastic extends longevity.

Surgical technique – Precise placement and alignment of the hip components has a major impact on how long implants last.

Patient health and activity – Being overweight, overly active in high-impact sports, or sustaining trauma can accelerate wear. Health conditions like osteoporosis also reduce lifespan.

Newer techniques – Minimally invasive surgery, computer navigation, and robotic assistance are improving results.

With optimum surgical technique and reasonable activity levels, today’s hip replacements provide over 15 years of reliable function on average before needing to be redone. Discuss implant options with your surgeon.

Can you walk after hip replacement surgery?

Yes, you can and should start walking soon after hip replacement surgery to aid the healing process. Here’s what to expect:

– You’ll start gentle walking with support the day after surgery. Nurses will assist you taking some steps around your hospital room using a walker or crutches.

– During the hospital stay, you’ll progress from short frequent walks to taking longer laps around the unit. This early mobility boosts circulation and prevents complications.

– You’ll continue walking with crutches or a walker once discharged for 4-6 weeks. Daily short walks are encouraged starting with 5-10 minutes and building distance over time. No limping or bending at the waist.

– With physical therapy, you’ll regain normal gait patterns and weight-bearing ability. Crutches are phased out around 6-8 weeks as strength improves.

– By 12 weeks, you should be able to walk reasonable distances without an assistive device while avoiding hills or stairs initially.

– No limping, fast paced walking or jumping while the joint is healing for the first 3 months.

Walking is essential after hip surgery with modifications and support as you recover. Increased walking and weight-bearing will get you back on your feet again.

What are the risks and complications of hip surgery?

As with any major surgery, hip replacement and other hip procedures carry some risks and possible complications. These include:

Blood clots – Clots can form in the lower legs after surgery. If a clot breaks loose it can travel to the lungs (called pulmonary embolism) which is life-threatening. Strict precautions are taken to reduce this risk.

Infection – Any surgery poses an infection risk, especially involving implants. Antibiotics are given to prevent infection which is rare in hip procedures (around 1-2% risk).

Bleeding – While uncommon with minimally invasive techniques, significant blood loss can sometimes occur during or after surgery requiring transfusions or revision surgery

Nerve damage – Despite careful techniques, nerves around the hip may be stretched or damaged causing numbness, tingling or even paralysis in the leg or foot which often resolves over time.

Dislocation – The ball can dislodge from the socket if the hip is positioned improperly. Avoiding certain movements like crossing your legs and using supportive equipment helps minimize this.

Fracture – The femur bone can sometimes be cracked during insertion of the stem. Additional fixation is required if this occurs.

Component loosening – Implant parts can loosen over time often requiring additional surgery. Modern cementing and bonding techniques reduce this risk.

Make sure to discuss the specific risks and complications of your planned hip procedure with your orthopedic surgeon. Following all postoperative precautions can help avoid these.

How long is the hospital stay after hip replacement?

Typical hospital stays after a total hip replacement are 1-3 days on average. Here are some factors affecting hospitalization time:

– For minimally invasive hip replacements, stays are generally 1-2 days.

– With conventional open surgery, stays average 2-3 days.

– If done as an outpatient procedure, the hospital stay may only be 12-24 hours.

– Complex revisions or cases with complications sometimes require longer hospitalization of 4-7 days.

– Patients are discharged once they can get in and out of bed, walk short distances with support, and perform basic self-care.

– Going home earlier bypasses risks of hospital infections and allows for more comfortable recovery.

– Private rehab facilities are an option before going straight home if additional nursing care is needed.

The trend is towards shorter hospitalization of just a day or two as surgical techniques advance. Talk to your surgeon about expected timeframes and discharge plans.

Can you drive after hip replacement?

Most surgeons recommend waiting around 4-6 weeks before resuming driving after hip replacement surgery. Here are some general guidelines:

– Do not drive while taking narcotic pain medications which cause drowsiness.

– Stop narcotics 1-2 weeks before driving and see how you feel without them. Use over-the-counter medications if needed.

– You must be able to walk confidently without any support devices like crutches or walker before driving.

– Test sitting in a chair with your leg bent for 45-60 minutes to ensure you have adequate hip mobility before trying to drive.

– Make your first few drives short trips with little traffic to rebuild skills and stamina. Have someone come along if possible.

– Position your seat properly so your feet easily reach the pedals and you can turn comfortably. Use hand controls if needed.

– Avoid long drives greater than 1 hour for the first 2-3 months after surgery. Take breaks to stretch your legs.

Discuss your timeline for resuming driving with your surgeon at follow-up visits. Regain mobility skills before attempting to drive again.

Conclusion

In summary, hip surgery like total replacement or hip arthroscopy can provide excellent outcomes in terms of relieving chronic hip pain and restoring mobility, especially when conservative treatments fail. For appropriate candidates, the benefits tend to outweigh the risks and limitations associated with lengthy recovery periods and strict postoperative precautions. However, the surgery is expensive without insurance, costing anywhere from $20,000-$50,000. Be sure to thoroughly discuss your specific circumstances including expected results, potential complications, rehabilitation protocols and costs with a qualified orthopedic surgeon in order to make an informed decision about pursuing hip surgery. With careful preparation and dedication to the recovery process, most patients undergoing hip procedures gain significant improvements in their comfort, daily function and quality of life.

Leave a Comment