Is it OK to use old fertilizer?

Using old or expired fertilizer is a common question many gardeners have. Fertilizer can become less effective as it ages, but how can you tell if it’s still good to use in your garden? Here’s a look at the shelf life of fertilizers and what to consider when deciding whether to use old fertilizer.

How long is fertilizer good for?

Most standard synthetic fertilizers have a shelf life of 1 to 3 years when stored properly. Organic fertilizers and natural products usually range from 6 months to 2 years before the nutrients begin degrading. Here are some more specifics on the shelf life of common fertilizers:

  • Dry granular fertilizer: 2-3 years
  • Liquid fertilizer: 1-2 years
  • Water-soluble fertilizer: 1-2 years
  • Organic fertilizers like compost, manure, bone/blood meal: 6-12 months

The expiration date on the packaging is the manufacturer’s recommendation for when the fertilizer is most potent. After that date, the nutrients can begin to slowly degrade in quality but don’t immediately become useless.

Signs fertilizer is past its prime

With age, fertilizer can undergo physical and chemical changes. Here are some signs your bags or bottles of fertilizer are past their peak effectiveness:

  • Granules are hardened or caked together
  • Fertilizer has a foul, rotten egg smell
  • Liquid fertilizer is cloudy or has particles settling at the bottom
  • Organic fertilizer is dried out or moldy

If you notice any of these characteristics, the fertilizer’s nutrients have likely broken down and oxidized over time. The nitrogen is especially prone to dissipating from the fertilizer within 1-2 years if not stored properly.

Properly storing fertilizer

To get the most life out of your fertilizer, store it correctly:

  • Keep fertilizer in a cool, dry place away from direct sun and moisture
  • Avoid storage temperatures over 100°F which can accelerate breakdown
  • Use plastic bins or buckets with tight lids to keep granular fertilizer dry
  • Store liquid fertilizer above 40°F to avoid freezing and breakage
  • Open bags of fertilizer should be resealed tightly or transferred to airtight containers

With proper storage, most fertilizers can safely be used for 2-3 years past the expiration date. But there are a few other factors to consider before using very old fertilizer.

When to throw out old fertilizer

Even if stored correctly, fertilizer that is more than 2-3 years past its expiration date should probably be discarded. Extreme age, exposure to moisture, or drastic temperature swings can make fertilizer so degraded it’s not worth using.

Here are some signs it’s time to throw out the old fertilizer:

  • The fertilizer is caked together in solid clumps
  • There is a strong, rancid smell, especially of ammonia
  • The color has changed to grey, brown, or white
  • Liquid fertilizer has separated or solidified
  • Organic fertilizer is dried out and crumbly with no scent

If the fertilizer shows signs of significant breakdown, the nutrients will likely be unavailable to your plants. At that point, it’s better start fresh with new fertilizer.

Testing old fertilizer

If you have fertilizer that’s nearing the end of its shelf life but isn’t obviously degraded, there are ways to test whether it still contains viable nutrients:

  • Conduct a physical inspection – Check for caking, odor, and color changes
  • Mix a small sample with warm water – Properly diluted fertilizer will dissolve completely
  • Apply to a test plot – Spread on a small area of lawn or garden and monitor results
  • Use fertilizer test strips – These measure nutrient levels, especially nitrogen
  • Send a sample to a lab – A fertility lab can analyze nutrients remaining

These tests will give you an idea if the fertilizer still contains nutrients or if it’s time to replace it. Most home gardeners can get by with a physical inspection and mixing test.

Using expired fertilizer

If your expired fertilizer passes inspection and the mixing test, it’s likely still fine to use with a few precautions:

  • Use it up – Don’t save degraded fertilizer another season
  • Apply at a higher rate – Nutrients are lower so compensate by using more
  • Avoid direct contact with plants – Mix into soil instead of foliar feeding
  • Watch for burn signs – Damaged fertilizer can release ammonia and burn plants

Applying at double the normal rate can help make up for depleted nitrogen and other nutrients. Just be cautious as super old fertilizer can damage plants if over-applied.

Alternatives to old fertilizer

Instead of trying to use up questionable old fertilizer, here are some alternatives to consider:

  • Buy fresh fertilizer – Invest in new products each season
  • Use organic options like compost – Breaks down slowly so ages better
  • Plant nitrogen-fixing plants – Beans, peas, and clover add nitrogen to soil
  • Rotate high and low feeder crops – Vary nutrient demands from season to season
  • Incorporate green manures – Crops like rye or oats add organic matter

Organic approaches, like compost, green manures, and cover crops naturally amend soil without relying so much on purchased chemical or organic fertilizers.

The risks of using too old fertilizer

While old fertilizer rarely poses significant safety risks, there are a few potential downsides to over-applying severely degraded products:

  • Plants may suffer fertilizer burn or toxicity symptoms
  • Excess salts from chemical fertilizer can build up in soil
  • Nutrient runoff can pollute groundwater and nearby waterways
  • Leggy, weak growth from ineffective nutrition
  • Wasted money on fertilizer that doesn’t benefit crops

The best way to avoid these pitfalls is to always store fertilizer properly, test older products before use, and apply at conservative rates. Relying too much on depleted fertilizer can be risky.


Most standard fertilizers remain viable for 1-3 years past their expiration date if stored correctly. After that, degradation starts to lower nutrient levels and quality. With extreme age fertilizer can become practically useless and potentially harmful if over-applied.

Testing very old fertilizer before use and applying at a higher rate can compensate for some nutrient decline. But it’s generally best to discard fertilizer more than 2-3 years expired. Alternatives like compost and green manures provide slow-release nutrition without the same storage limitations.

While using old fertilizer is usually fine, rely on fresh products each season if possible. Proper storage and rotation of inventory helps avoid wasting money on depleted fertilizer.

Fertilizer Type Shelf Life Proper Storage
Dry granular 2-3 years Cool, dry place in sealed container
Liquid 1-2 years Above 40°F out of direct sunlight
Organic 6-12 months Sealed container in cool location

This table provides a quick reference for proper storage and shelf life of common fertilizer types.

Tips for using old fertilizer

If you need to use older fertilizer, here are some best practices:

  • Inspect physical condition and mix test before applying
  • Start with half rate and increase if plants show deficiencies
  • Water in granular fertilizer instead of broadcasting
  • Use on lawns and lower value crops first to test
  • Discard if color changes, smells rotten, or caked together

Follow these guidelines to safely take advantage of fertilizer that’s nearing expiration but still viable. And remember to always store new purchases carefully to get full use from your investment.

Alternatives to purchased fertilizers

Here are some eco-friendly alternatives to conventional fertilizers:

  • Compost from yard and food waste
  • Manure from livestock, poultry, or rabbits
  • Cover crops like clover, vetch, peas
  • Crop rotation with legumes that add nitrogen
  • Allowing land to lay fallow between plantings
  • Intercropping with nitrogen-fixing plants
  • Using organic mulches like wood chips or leaves

Nature provides many of the nutrients our gardens need if we work with natural cycles. Reduce reliance on bagged products by incorporating more organic practices.

Leave a Comment