Is bisque made with milk?

Bisque is a smooth, creamy soup that is typically made with seafood or vegetables. It has a rich, velvety texture that comes from being pureed and strained. The key ingredient that gives bisque its signature creamy texture is dairy, usually heavy cream or milk.

Table of Contents

What is bisque?

Bisque is a French soup that dates back to the 17th century. It was originally made by grinding raw shellfish shells and thickening the soup with rice. Over time, recipes evolved to include pureeing seafood, vegetables or mushrooms to create a smooth texture. Cream was also added to enrich the soup.

Today, bisque is defined as a thick, creamy soup that is pureed to create a smooth, velvety consistency. It can be made with various ingredients like seafood, poultry, vegetables or mushrooms. The three main characteristics of bisque are:

Contains pureed ingredients
Thickened with cream
Smooth, velvety texture

Some classic bisque soups include:

Lobster bisque
Shrimp bisque

Crab bisque
Mushroom bisque
Roasted red pepper bisque

Butternut squash bisque

Is milk required to make bisque?

Yes, milk or cream is an essential ingredient in making classic bisque. This is what gives the soup its characteristic rich, creamy and smooth texture.

There are a few reasons why dairy is so important for making bisque:

Thickening agent – Milk contains proteins like casein that help thicken the bisque when heated. This gives the soup more body without diluting the flavor.
Smoothing agent – The fat in milk or cream creates a silky texture when pureed that cannot be replicated with broth or water alone.
Enhances flavor – Milk adds a layer of richness, creaminess and savory depth to bisque.

Binds ingredients – Dairy helps bind all the ingredients together into a cohesive, smooth soup.

Heavy cream is most commonly used because it contains at least 36% milk fat, creating an especially velvety texture. Light cream, half and half or whole milk may also be used. Non-dairy milk substitutes can mimic the creaminess of dairy but the results may not be quite as rich.

What role does milk play in making bisque?

Milk plays several important roles in creating the ideal smooth, creamy bisque texture:

Thickener – When milk is gently simmered, the proteins coagulate and thicken the surrounding liquid.
Emulsifier – Milk fats help bind water and oil-based ingredients together to form a creamy emulsion.
Pureeing aid – The fat in milk allows bisque to be pureed into an ultrasmooth consistency.

Flavor enhancer – Lactose and milk fat carry flavor and give bisque a rich, indulgent taste.
Mouthfeel – Milk gives bisque a coating, velvety texture on the tongue.

When making bisque, the dairy is typically added toward the end once the main ingredients have simmered and softened. After pureeing, the bisque is finished by gently reheating with the dairy to preserve its silky texture.

Can you make bisque without milk or cream?

It is possible to make a bisque-style soup without milk or cream, but it will lack the quintessential rich, velvety texture of a classic bisque. There are a few alternatives that can be used:

Non-dairy milk – Soy, almond or oat milk can mimic some creaminess when pureed but may curdle if boiled. Always add after pureeing.
Nut butters – A spoonful of creamy nut butter can add some richness without dairy.

Starchy thickeners – Starches like flour, cornstarch or potato flakes can thicken non-dairy bisques.
Pureed vegetables – Blending starchy veggies like potatoes or white beans adds body.
Coconut milk – Offers some natural creaminess and fat to carry flavors.

Grains – Cooked rice, barley or oats add texture when pureed.

These substitutions can create a creamy, non-dairy bisque but the texture may end up thinner compared to a traditional bisque made with dairy. Adding too many thickeners can also make the soup gluey.

What are some tips for making dairy-free bisque?

Here are some helpful tips for creating a rich, dairy-free bisque:

Saute aromatics like onions, garlic and celery well to build a flavorful base.
Roast vegetables before blending to caramelize natural sugars.
Puree in smaller batches for the smoothest texture.

For seafood bisques, use shells to make a flavorful seafood stock.
Add some acid like lemon juice or white wine to brighten the flavors.
Blend in creamy ingredients like starchy tubers, cooked grains or beans.

Simmer the soup briefly after adding non-dairy milk to prevent curdling.
Garnish with herbs, spices, croutons or grated parmesan for complexity.

With patience and care, it’s possible to craft a velvety smooth bisque without the dairy. The key is building plenty of flavor into the base and then using purees and thickeners to add richness and body.

What ingredients can you use to make vegan bisque?

There are many plant-based ingredients that can be used to mimic the creamy texture of dairy-based bisques:

Vegetable purees – Potatoes, cauliflower, pumpkin, carrots
Beans – White beans, cannellini beans, chickpeas

Grains – Rice, barley, quinoa, oats
Nuts – Cashews, almonds
Non-dairy milk – Soy, oat, almond, coconut

Plant-based cream – Coconut cream, cashew cream
Vegetable broth – Onion, mushroom, celery
Herbs and spices – Thyme, sage, garlic, pepper

When combined and pureed, these ingredients can produce a lush, creamy bisque without any dairy products. A blend of starchy vegetables, non-dairy milk, aromatics and seasonings is often the base of a vegan bisque. Herbs, spices and garnishes add complexity.

What are good substitutes for heavy cream in bisque?

Some good dairy-free substitutes for heavy cream in bisque include:

Substitute	How to Use
Full-fat coconut milk	Use 1:1 for heavy cream. Chill cans before opening.
Cashew cream	Blend soaked cashews with water. Adds richness.
Silken tofu	Puree tofu into soups and sauces for creaminess.
Cooked white beans	Puree beans into bisques for body and texture.
Vegetable purees	Carrots, squash and potatoes create smooth texture.
Roasted garlic	Adds tangy flavor and richness when blended.

Depending on the flavor profile, combining multiple substitutes like beans and coconut milk can provide both creaminess and nutrition in dairy-free bisques.

Are there any tips for getting a bisque to thicken without dairy?

Here are some useful tips for thickening and enriching a dairy-free bisque:

Simmer the soup uncovered to reduce excess liquid.
Puree some of the soup’s starchy vegetables before adding back.

Whisk in arrowroot powder or cornstarch slurry as the soup simmers.
Blend in cooked grains like rice, barley or farro.
Swap water for vegetable broth to add more body.

Add a peeled, boiled potato and simmer until softened.
Finish with a swirl of plain coconut cream or olive oil.
Sprinkle with ground nuts or nutritional yeast before serving.

Getting the perfect velvety texture requires balancing the proportion of liquids to starches and purees. Go slowly, adding more broth only as needed. The starchier the vegetable puree, the more luscious the finished bisque will be.

What would be an example recipe for dairy-free bisque?

Here is an example recipe for a rich, dairy-free butternut squash bisque:

Ingredients

3 lbs butternut squash, peeled and cubed

1 yellow onion, diced
2 carrots, peeled and sliced
3 cloves garlic, minced

1 Tbsp olive oil
4 cups vegetable broth
1 (14oz) can coconut milk

2 tsp thyme leaves
1 bay leaf
Salt and pepper to taste

Instructions

Heat oil in a pot over medium heat. Add onions, carrots and garlic. Cook 5 minutes.
Add squash, broth, coconut milk and herbs. Bring to a boil.
Reduce heat and simmer until squash is very tender, about 20 minutes.

Remove bay leaf. Carefully puree soup until completely smooth.
Return to pot and season with salt and pepper.
Heat gently until warmed through before serving.

Garnish bowls with roasted pumpkin seeds, if desired.

This recipe uses coconut milk for creaminess, and pureed squash and aromatics for body. The result is a luxuriously velvety bisque without a drop of dairy!

Conclusion

Traditionally, bisque soups obtain their characteristic creamy, velvety texture from the addition of dairy like heavy cream or milk. However, with care it is possible to craft rich, dairy-free bisques using purees, thickeners and non-dairy ingredients for similar smoothness. The keys are building flavor in the base, roasting vegetables, and then blending to a completely smooth consistency. With a balanced use of pantry staples like beans, grains, and non-dairy milk, anyone can make a deeply satisfying bisque that just happens to be vegan.