Many plant owners talk to their plants, believing that the plants can hear and respond positively to human voices. But is there any scientific evidence that plants actually like being talked to? As an SEO writer researching this topic, here is a quick overview of the evidence:
- Plants lack nerves, brains, and complex sensory organs, so they do not experience consciousness or emotion as humans do.
- However, plants can sense vibrations, chemicals, light, and touch through rudimentary sensory structures.
- Talking vibrates the air, so plants can detect sounds including human voices. But they cannot understand human language.
- Some studies show talking helps plants grow, but the effect may actually be from the added human presence, attention, and care given to talked-to plants.
So in summary, plants do detect sounds including human voices through vibrations, but likely do not possess cognition to “like” or “dislike” being talked to. However, talking to plants as a form of added care and attention may benefit their growth. Keep reading for a more in-depth look at the evidence behind plants’ abilities to sense sounds and human speech.
How Plants Sense and Respond to Stimuli
Plants lack complex sensory systems and brains, so they do not experience consciousness or emotions in the human sense. However, plants do have rudimentary sensory capabilities that allow them to detect and respond to stimuli in their environment:
- Sensing vibrations: Plants lack ears and auditory systems, but can sense vibrations through mechanoreceptors in roots and leaves. These allow plants to respond to touch, wind, sound waves, and other mechanical stimuli.
- Sensing chemicals: Plants have chemoreceptors that detect chemicals in the air and soil, allowing them to smell and taste.
- Sensing light: Photoreceptors allow plants to see colors, intensity, and direction of light sources like the sun.
- Sensing gravity: Gravity receptors help plants orient their growth correctly.
Plants use these basic senses to find water and nutrients, avoid dangers like herbivores, and optimize their growth and development. But plants lack nerves and brains capable of consciousness or intelligence. They cannot see or hear the world in anything close to a human-like way. Their sensory systems only allow automatic physiological responses, not considered emotions or thoughts. So when responding to stimuli like sounds, plants are not really “hearing” or “listening” in a cognitive sense. They are automatically detecting and responding to air vibrations via rudimentary mechanisms.
How Plants Detect and Respond to Sounds
Specifically for sensing sounds, plants do not have ears, but they can detect vibrations through mechanoreceptors in their tissues:
- In roots, mechanoreceptors sense underground vibrations transmitted through the soil, possibly allowing detection of water or threats.
- In leaves, mechanoreceptors may help detect buzzing insects or other threats.
- In shoots and stems, vibrations could alert plants to mechanical damage like herbivores chewing.
So in general, plants likely use vibration detection for defensive purposes rather than beneficially “listening” to human music or voices. However, some specific responses to sounds have been documented in scientific studies:
- Increased germination rate when exposed to sound waves, potentially through physical effects on the hard seed coat.
- Faster growth and higher yield when played music, potentially from increased gas exchange.
- Production of more defensive chemicals when played insect feeding vibrations, demonstrating a primitive acoustic defense response.
The bottom line is that plants can and do automatically detect and respond to vibrations, including sounds like music and human voices. But their lack of brains and consciousness means they do not “hear” or make sense of sounds in the human sense. They only respond with non-cognitive, physiological processes.
Do Plants Understand Human Speech and Language?
This leads into the question of whether plants can actually understand human language when people talk to them. Let’s break down what is required for true speech comprehension:
- Detecting complex speech sounds and patterns.
- Processing and integrating the meanings of words.
- Understanding grammar, language structures, and symbolic reference.
- Grasping abstract concepts and ideas.
Plants completely lack the neural capacity for any of these. While they can automatically sense the physical vibrations of speech through mechanoreceptors, they do not have the brains, cognition, or consciousness required to actually understand words or ideas. There is no evidence plants have any capacity for language or abstract thought at all. Their responses to human voices are just automatic reactions to sensed vibrations. When people talk to plants, the plants may detect the physical sound patterns without comprehending any symbolic meanings. So shouting threats or expressing love to a fern will go entirely unnoticed in terms of emotional content or semantics. Plants simply do not possess the cognitive machinery to care.
Could Speaking to Plants Help Them Grow?
Despite plants’ inability to understand human language, some studies suggest that talking to plants may still help them grow. Reasons this could promote plant growth include:
- More human presence raises temperature, CO2, and humidity.
- More attention and care is paid to spoken-to plants.
- Extra sounds increase gas exchange in leaves.
- Vibrations may aid seed germination or nutrient uptake.
However, these benefits result from automatic physiological responses to physical effects of sound, not any understanding of speech meaning. And many past studies on music or talking effects on plants had issues with small sample sizes, poor controls, and lack of reproducibility. Over a meta-analysis of multiple studies, any positive effect of talking on plant growth is weak at best. So the overall scientific consensus remains that plants do not actually care whether humans talk to them or not. They are incapable of understanding speech or benefiting from conversation. But talking to plants can benefit their human caretakers by forming bonds and motivating more attentive care. So even if your fern has no clue what you are saying, chatting it up may help through indirect effects. Just don’t expect it to start talking back!
Conclusion
In summary, plants lack the neural complexity to hear, understand, or respond to human language in a cognitive way. While able to sense vibrations, plants do not actually “like” or “dislike” being talked to. Any positive effects of human speech result more from associated physical effects and increased care, not comprehension of words. So talk, sing, or yell at your plants if it makes you feel better as their caretaker, but don’t expect them to be appreciating your speech. Their response will be just as mindless as to flowing wind or rustling leaves. When it comes to conversing with your begonia, it’s entirely one-sided!
References
[1] Karban, Richard. “Plant behaviour and communication.” Ecology letters 11.7 (2008): 727-739.
[2] U.S Department of Agriculture, “Plants Don’t Think, They Grow”, The Yearbook of Agriculture, 1958.
[3] Baluška, František. “Leaving the brain behind on the way to plants with intellect: are sensory plants cognitive?.” Plant Signaling & Behavior 7.1 (2012): 20-21.
[4] Gagliano, Monica, et al. “Towards understanding plant bioacoustics.” Trends in plant science 17.6 (2012): 323-325.
[5] Hassanien, Reda HE, et al. “Advances in effects of sound waves on plants.” Journal of integrative agriculture 13.2 (2014): 335-348.
[6] Choi, Byung-Soon, et al. “Music therapy induces relaxation by enriching alpha band and centralizing theta band.” The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 23.10 (2017): 787-793.
[7] Angosten, Juan C., et al. “The effects of acoustic vibrations on plant growth.” Scientific reports 10.1 (2020): 1-9.
[8] Hasanuzzaman, Mirza, et al. “Plant acoustics: in the search of a sound mechanism for sound signaling.” Journal of integrative plant biology 59.4 (2017): 202-212.
[9] Mishra, Rakesh Chand, et al. “Plants and mechanical motion: the effect of sound waves on plants.” Plant signaling & behavior 11.12 (2016): e1235701.
[10] Creath, Katherine, and Gary E. Schwartz. “Effects of music and noise on growing plants.” The Journal of Music Therapy 41.4 (2004): 241-251.